Mocha carries the burden of being a city so famous for its association with coffee that its real significance is obscured. Nancy Um's excellent book, The Merchant Houses of Mocha, reorients our understanding of this well-known Yemeni port town by guiding us carefully from its place within the early modern trading network to the domestic interiors of the city, offering a thoughtful investigation of the intersections of architecture and culture. She avoids the often rigid and ineffective models scholars have imposed on cities in this part of the world, whether Arab, Islamic, or even more specifically, Yemeni. Mocha's requirements as a port city are instead thoroughly addressed, and it is presented as “a singular case responding to economic and social stimuli” (p. 8) during a time when it reached its height, from the mid-17th to the mid-18th century. The author shows that “the culture of trade profoundly shaped the underlying structure of the port city, defining the principal orientations of its urban shape, the functional modes of its built elements, and the social hierarchies that dominated community life” (p. 11). Her treatment of Mocha, often presented in the context of engaging and insightful comparative data, offers a refreshing examination of the city's urban and architectural history, which sheds considerable light on social and commercial history.
In seven chapters, Um guides the reader from the hemispheric trading network down to the commercial and social relations in the city and in its merchant houses. In the first four chapters she establishes concentric contexts for her argument. She starts by tracing the process by which Mocha was reoriented from the Ottoman to the Indian Ocean world. With the rise of the Qasimi imams and the ouster of the Ottomans in 1635, Mocha lost its direct ties to the Ottoman trading world via Cairo. Direct trade routes to the North stopped at Jedda, and, under Qasimi rule, Mocha's principal trading partner became the Gujarati port of Surat. Thus, along with its Qasimi political identity, Mocha acquired new commercial and financial features reflecting its prominence within the western Indian Ocean. Um then discusses the more immediate context of Mocha's place in Yemen, noting, among other things, that it was one of three transshipment points on the coast (along with al-Hudayda and al-Luhayya), while Bayt al-Faqih, situated inland in the Tihama, functioned as the principal emporium for the global coffee trade. Mocha became synonymous with coffee in the West because it was the port used by European traders. This clarification does not diminish Mocha's prominence, however; the city served as the principal Qasimi port for exporting a variety of commodities to South Asia. Um also highlights the political and social contexts of Mocha, offering a fresh view of the Qasimi regime that avoids the typical depiction of Qasimi rule as an “inaccessible and isolated” highland state, emphasizing instead the extent to which it was “internationalized.” Although Mocha was economically successful and a lucrative post for its governors, the port's financial impact was more clearly evident in other parts of Yemen, “bringing the maritime sphere into the most inaccessible mountain enclaves” (p. 49). Her description of Mocha society, enriched by examples of merchants and shipowners (sing. nākhūdha), vividly illustrates its intimate commercial relations with the Indian Ocean world, reinforcing the internationalized character of the port.
The core of Um's argument is presented in the last three chapters. The first of these, “Urban Form and Orientation,” examines the layout of the city and shows how commerce and politics defined Mocha's city life. Of particular interest here is her explanation of how the city was split, with a waterfront dominated by official and wholesale commercial establishments directed toward the maritime foreland and an inland side accommodating religious and retail structures directed toward Mocha's hinterland. Moving yet further inward in “Trading Spaces,” she shows how trade was conducted in the residences of merchants, rather than in institutions such as the khan, where trade was usually practiced in other parts of the Ottoman world. The merchant houses of Mocha, which share many features with those on the coasts of East Africa, the southern Red Sea, and India, accommodated the needs of both commerce and private life, indicating “a shared understanding along the trade routes leading to and emanating from Mocha” (p. 158). Finally, Chapter 7, “On the Politics of Inside and Out,” maps Mocha's social order. The foreland/hinterland distinction ordered the institutional and economic dimensions of the town while the town wall, a structure that provided outward defense and inward control, determined residential patterns and, at times, the conduct of political action. The thrust of the chapter focuses on the Baniyan community, which lived inside the city walls because of its central role in the overseas trade while other minority groups resided outside. The Baniyans resisted occasional episodes of political oppression when they took sanctuary in one of the main tombs outside the city walls, intentionally bringing trade to a halt. The author argues from this map of social hierarchies that “the practical function of everyday life may effortlessly override the administrative desire or communal impulse to separate urban communities” (p. 173).
Um's study is based on a variety of sources—architectural, archival, and literary—that she wields effectively. The historic core of Mocha is now mostly lost, but a number of its houses remain—fewer than ten when she surveyed them in 2000—although none can be dated with certainty to earlier than the 19th century (p. 140). She has had to assume, based on corroboration with the textual data, that the extant houses are representative of those used during the height of Mocha's prosperity. This relative paucity of architectural evidence is unfortunate, but the overall argument is still convincing. Her Arabic sources, which are chronicles and biographical dictionaries written from the perspective of the highland Qasimi state, seem not to have been especially informative, although they do provide details on patronage and financial connections extending from Mocha across Yemen. The real “backbone” of the argument relies on her European sources, consisting mainly of the daily logbooks of the Dutch East India Company, which provide detailed testimony of commercial practices and day to day events in the city. She also uses reports from European powers’ seasonal missions to Mocha, along with travelers’ accounts, often illustrated, from the 18th and 19th centuries.
The Merchant Houses of Mocha is a valuable contribution to the growing number of recent studies on particular localities within the Red Sea, extending from Quseir to Aden, all of which are refining and refashioning our understanding of a poorly understood but important region that connected the worlds of the Middle East, South Asia, and East Africa. Historians of cities, trade, society, and architecture, whether at home in the Indian Ocean or the Mediterranean, or in the early modern or the medieval worlds, will find this a useful, engaging, and insightful book. It is well written and accessible to advanced undergraduates. The book also includes maps, plans, photos, and appendices containing lists of the Qasimi imams and governors of Mocha and descriptions of the archival and museum sources.
