Although Mercantilism Reimagined begins and ends in discussions of Adam Smith, it aims above all to escape Smith's influence, and to make sense of early modern economic thought in something other than his terms. Far from the static, specie-obsessed, authoritarian “system” Smith criticized, mercantilism appears in this volume's 17 essays as a shifting set of concepts, concerns, and practices. Editors Philip Stern and Carl Wennerlind take inspiration from Steve Pincus’ recent proposal for “rethinking mercantilism,” and insist that early modern economic thought was inseparable from political debates—not least, debates about which sorts of communities and institutions could exercise legitimate economic power (“Rethinking Mercantilism: Political Economy, the British Empire, and the Atlantic World in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries,” William and Mary, 69, no. 1, [Jan. 2012]: 3–34). Contributors find a variety of non- and para-state actors (privileged monopolies, the Church of England, pirates) flexing mercantilist ideas and practices for their own ends. Indeed, never has mercantilism seemed less the economic face of “absolutism.” States appear in this volume as “poly-centric” (Regina Grafe, p. 257); “pluralistic, fragile, and assembled” (Henry Turner, p. 169); or, in Sophus Reinert's ambitious formulation, as expressions of a baroquepunk that ties the seventeenth century to our own world of powerful corporations and uncertain states (p. 362, 370).
As the early modern state competes for historical attention with a host of new actors, canonical thinkers make room for the relatively overlooked Samuel Hartlib (1600–1662) and his school. Several essays explore the Hartlibians’ views on a range of issues, sometimes revealing unnoticed turning points in intellectual history, sometimes recapitulating the expected. Study of the Hartlib Circle allows Ted McCormick to uncover how the notion of “population” as a quantifiable reality emerged over the course of the seventeenth century out of a network of initially unrelated practices aimed at policing distinct social groups. Only through the influence of the Hartlibians, themselves inspired by Baconian theories of knowledge and nature, did these worrisome populations come to be understood as the products of national demographic conditions subject to study and control. McCormick's insights, in turn, allow Abigail Swingen to offer a stunning reappraisal of the shift from white indentured and free labor to black slave labor in the British Atlantic, which she attributes to the new, Hartlibian sense of population as a resource to be shepherded—and prevented from emigrating.
Insisting on the influence of the Hartlib Circle likewise enables powerful interventions by Thomas Leng and Fredrik Jonsson, who take up the Bacon-Hartlib connection to examine the philosophy and politics of economic knowledge-production. Applying insights from the literature of the history of science, Leng and Jonsson see the early modern economy as a field in which actors pursued knowledge and power through experiment, dreaming, like Bacon, of limitless growth fueled by discovery. Hartlib, however, is something of the Spinoza to Mercantilism Reimagined‘s radical economic enlightenment, casting a wide and sometimes hazy shadow. Wennerlind, for example, analyzes seventeenth-century British views of money, wealth, and trade, in light of the Hartlib Circle; he reveals, somewhat gratuitously, that thinkers of this era did not equate specie with wealth and had sophisticated monetary theories.
Its subtitle notwithstanding, Mercantilism Reimagined addresses political economy in a number of continental states, enriching our understanding of the place of economic thought in imperial competition. Regina Grafe lays to rest the claim (itself an Enlightenment fiction) that the economic policies of the Spanish monarchy are Exhibit A in the case against mercantilism; Spain's kings, ruling through negotiations with thousands of urban communities, could never fashion a national economy, much less regulate one along mercantilist lines. Developing Istvan Hont's work on the “jealousy of trade,” John Shovlin, Victor Enthoven, and Sophus Reinert outline continental states’ intellectual and policy responses to the rise of British commercial and military power—and above all, their attempts to comprehend the relation between these two sorts of power. Although Mercantilism Reimagined‘s essays find vernacular mercantilisms across Europe and the Atlantic World, the historiography Stern and Wennerlind address in their introduction is almost exclusively English-language, if not specific to Britain. This blunts some of their most provocative interventions. Their analysis of mercantilism, for instance, begins with the presupposition that “the economy” was not “a distinct field of operation… until perhaps the nineteenth century” (p. 7). Making this claim in earnest would require an engagement with scholars such as Catherine Larrère, who have explored the early modern roots of “the economy” as a concept (L'Invention de l'économie. Du droit naturel à la physiocratie. Paris: PUF, 1992). Similarly, the “mercantilist system” appears to Stern and Wennerlind as a chimera imagined by Adam Smith. This view ignores the role Smith's continental contemporaries played in the retrospective figuration of a coherent, state-centric mercantilism. Many of these thinkers, such as Jacques Necker in his 1773 Eloge de Colbert, sought to defend or revive the “system” Smith attacked.
The pay-offs to Stern and Wennerlind's intervention are nevertheless enormous. Taking mercantilism as a range of practices and ideas that served diverse state and non-state actors enables a range of convincing re-explanations of such fundamental early modern processes as the rise of the slave trade and the “decline” of Spain. It makes visible previously ignored thinkers, and uncovers the sophisticated moral economies of Atlantic pirates and Anglican priests. Mercantilism Reimagined is an invaluable contribution to the debate over the nature of early modern economic thought, and undoubtedly will go on to inspire more of the innovative, exciting scholarship offered by its contributors.
