Although titled Balakirev: Complete Piano Works, this musically fascinating set is incomplete. In addition to a sizable handful of minor works, missing from it are the piano compositions for which Mily Balakirev (1837–1910) was so well known in his day, like his hugely influential oriental fantasy, Islamey – every pianist's nightmare but a required rite of passage into the elite club of the instrument's greatest virtuosos; ‘Fantasia on Themes from Glinka's A Life for the Tsar’ – Balakirev's musical calling card since the age of 17, and the work that would continue to evolve with its every improvised performance until 1899, when it was published; and a whole slew of famous transcriptions and arrangements, like the brilliant rendition of Glinka's Jota Aragonesa. Many of such representative works, not included on these compact disks, date from the 1860s – the apex of Balakirev's career and historical significance as one of Russia's greatest piano virtuosos (surpassed only by the two Rubinstein brothers), Russia's most celebrated conductor, co-founder and director of the Free Music School, unwavering propagator of Glinka's music, experimental composer in his own right, a tribune of Russia's musical nationalism, and no less a contributor to the creation of the Russian style than his predecessor Glinka or his own moguchaya kuchka (‘mighty little heap’) protégés, Musorgsky, Borodin and Rimsky-Korsakov. The works in the CD series under review – collectively amounting to almost four hours of music – capture little of this.
Of the 30 pieces recorded by Nicholas Walker on this set, 21 date from Balakirev's last creative period, roughly 1898 to 1909 – the culmination of his decades-long virtual self-isolation, political regression, religious fanaticism and vile bigotry. The music hides all of that well enough; where it fails is in concealing Balakirev's astonishing stylistic conservatism. For Balakirev in his twilight years (tragically, his most productive) musical time stood still. And therein lies the paradox of Balakirev's piano music recorded here. All these works are masterly, they demonstrate remarkable polish and total command of musical form and chromatic syntax, and they reveal Balakirev's thorough understanding of the instrument for which they are conceived. Stylistically, however, they are time capsules of the 1850s and 60s, yet created in another age. His stunning Sonata of 1905, his many excellent late mazurkas, waltzes and nocturnes are all at once archaic and anachronistic, especially when heard against similar works by his younger contemporaries. Juxtaposed with Scriabin's music, Balakirev's lacks tonal and formal innovation. Heard next to Rachmaninoff's works, with which they are stylistically closer, Balakirev's have none of the harmonic lushness or erotic lyricism. Most of Balakirev's music on these CDs failed to make any impact on the surrounding musical landscape, did not anticipate anything to come, and never developed a performance tradition. Which does not mean that this music is devoid of history. In encountering these works, one has to step away from their immediate contexts and instead to listen into the past, either approaching them collectively as a grand panoramic retrospective (though they were hardly intended as such by the composer) or treating them as souvenirs (mentally transposing them to circa 1860 and pretending that that is when they originated).
The earlier works on the disks present a different set of challenges. Of the nine recorded works that predate Balakirev's last decade, five were either left incomplete by the composer or never issued to the public. These include two unfinished piano sonatas from 1855 and 1856 respectively, one completed nocturne of 1856, and two fragments – what might be Balakirev's earliest surviving composition, a waltz from 1851, and a mazurka from 1884 – newly completed by Walker himself. With the exception of the 1856 sonata, the rest of these works exist only in manuscript and appear in this set as ‘world premiere recordings’. The nocturne is heard both in its early version of 1856 and its later re-conception of 1898, the latter published by the composer as his ‘Nocturne No. 1’. (Like the nocturne, Balakirev's first two numbered mazurkas are also found in two variants – the originals from circa 1860 and the revised and published ones of the mid-1880s. However, Walker chose to record only the earlier scores.) The two sonatas, discussed in some detail below, are unfinished works (the first, ‘Grand Sonate’, with an incomplete fifth-movement epilogue, which Walker records as a fragment; the second, without a finale), though most of their movements are, in fact, ‘complete’ – to the extent that any unfinished work is ever complete.
Although I have serious reservations about recording such completed works that the composer never intended for public dissemination, I empathize with the desire to have them heard. But when it comes to fragments, the choice is clearer – let them be. To complete the unfinished Mazurka of 1884 (which exists in earlier and later forms, all recorded here), Walker added some 53 bars to Balakirev's 235, ‘basing [the new material] on the gestures of both the earliest and the later versions … and using harmonic language similar to that of Balakirev in the 1880s’ (Grand Piano 714, p. 6). The extent of Walker's actual intervention here and in the other unfinished score is unclear, since the sketches in the Russian archives are not accessible to most listeners. Whereas with the 1884 Mazurka Walker contributed about one-sixth to Balakirev's score, with the earlier piece (‘Piece in F sharp minor’ of 1851) he had to compose one-half of it in order to have the work finished. To invent that half, Walker apparently reused ‘some of what Balakirev had written already and [introduced] some canonic imitation, typical of his style’ (Grand Piano 714, p. 8). But what style is that? At the ripe old age of 14, Balakirev hardly had a style of which to speak. There are reasons why Balakirev chose not to finish these compositions. Ever self-critical, he believed in the stable (that is, final) musical text, and never brought out his music for public judgment until it reached that status, which these works never did. Decisions by performers (and, at times, musicologists) to have such works performed (as opposed to studied) – to render them undead, in other words – are rife with ethical implications, particularly when these projects fail to offer a rationale or necessary contexts for the resurrections.
My reservations about some aspects of Walker's project – with its world premieres, recordings of unpublished works, completions of fragmentary compositions, emphasis on this specific group of works – do not extend to his playing. Recording these works, which, collectively, catalogue every Romantic pianistic technique, was an ambitious endeavour and one must commend him for his total technical command of this formidably challenging repertoire.
The CD set opens with Balakirev's three attempts at writing a piano sonata. The Sonata of 1905, the first work of the set and the only sonata actually completed, is Balakirev's most monumental piano composition. What it lacks in sheer brilliance and technical demand (compared to the more famous Islamey), it makes up in scope. To write a sonata in B-flat minor is to invoke Chopin's second sonata – one of Balakirev's favourite pieces, by a beloved composer. However, the work's opening makes one think not of Chopin but of Beethoven. The slow first movement is in sonata form, the Principal Theme (PT) of which is a fugal exposition in three voices. Its subject is of the ‘head-and-tail’ type, with the head, arguably, stylizing a protyazhnaya Russian folk song and the tail lifted right out of a Bach fugue. Alas, if in writing this fugal exposition Balakirev was aiming for something transcendental à la late Beethoven, he failed to transcend even the most scholastic. The fugal PT gives way to the Subordinate Theme (ST) in D-flat major, even less inspired and perfectly forgettable. The head motive of the opening subject, which from this point onward saturates the rest of the movement, then furnishes the Closing Theme (CT). Like the static Exposition itself, the movement as a whole never gets beyond its academic conception (be it in form, tonal layout, harmonic content or melodic treatment). The Development section begins in F-sharp minor (enharmonic G-flat minor) by recycling the fugal opening, but now with stretto effects and more ornamentation, leading to an exoticized statement of the CT, in F-sharp major – the pedal point, arpeggiated accompaniment, chromatic undulation with a prominent 6̂–@6̂–5̂ linear motion offer the entire aggregate of oriental devices (ones which Balakirev himself helped devise). The whole thing is then repeated, with surface variation, starting in A-flat minor giving way to A-flat major. The sudden – and I mean sudden – arrival of V of the home tonic initiates a brief and utterly incongruent cadenza, which could have originated in another piece altogether. As expected, the Recapitulation adjusts earlier music to work in the tonic, and the lovely ‘oriental’ Coda, based on the version of the CT already heard in the Development section, concludes the movement in B-flat major. Unfortunately, by this point, the head motive, heard ad nauseam, has rendered the Coda, and the movement as a whole, monotonous.
The remaining three movements of the sonata are far more exciting. The second is an expansive mazurka in D major and in rondo-like (ABA′B′A″) form. Its progenitors are not Chopin's little, quirky masterpieces; rather, they are the mazurkas of Glinka, which are longer, multi-sectional, with more internal tonal and melodic contrast (though Glinka's piano music never aspired to the virtuosic flair of Balakirev's). I bring this up not only to highlight that Russia had its own tradition of mazurkas, in dialogue with but not derived from Chopin's, but also to underscore Balakirev's continuous reliance on Glinka as a model for genres, forms and compositional techniques. Like Glinka, Balakirev was a true lyricist, with an uncanny ability to write simple, memorable tunes (often folk-song stylizations), which he would then subject to variation, with the melody kept largely unchanged and everything else – counterpoint, harmony, texture, figuration, colour – in a state of flux. Everyone knows the technique as ‘changing-background variations’, or simply ‘Glinka variations’, which this movement exhibits in abundance (hints of the technique are already present in the first movement, and Balakirev relies upon it extensively in the sonata's Finale as well). Significantly, Glinka never employed this type of variations in his piano music: his is an orchestral technique that depends to a great extent on instrumental timbre. Balakirev's transfer of the method to the piano requires that he treat the instrument as if it were an orchestra, and this he does with some magic in the Mazurka. The most obvious instance occurs in the first episode (B). In B-flat major, it is in itself a miniature rondo. Balakirev subjects the main theme to Glinka variations. In total, there are six statements, in pairs: straight through, in a higher register and against a widely arpeggiated background in the left hand, in the tenor voice embellished by the right hand in triplets in the upper register of the piano, in broken chords, theme in the stratosphere with cascading arpeggios underneath, and, finally, theme in chords in the right hand against wide arpeggios in the left. Walker's lucid, almost sparkly, articulation (reinforced by the superb technical calibre of the sound recording itself) contributes much to capturing the effects and affects that Balakirev was looking to transmit. At times, Balakirev actually specifies the ‘colour’ he desires. For example, later in the movement, in the second episode (B′), stating its main theme now in B major, he adds ‘quasi Flauti’ for the variation in which the theme is heard in the soprano register against the dolcissimo bubbling of triplets in the left hand in the alto range. Like some of Glinka's own variations, these are not static utterances – they are dynamic, relating to each other and working to define the larger form. The movement closes with A″ doubling as the Coda; here, in varying the music, Balakirev seems to invoke the ‘Persian Chorus’ – the locus classicus of Glinka variations – from Ruslan and Lyudmila, the opera to which he pays a more direct homage in the Sonata's Finale.
A work of some special significance to the composer, the Mazurka exists in no less than five versions, peppering Balakirev's entire compositional career. Its earliest manifestation dates back to Balakirev's first unfinished piano sonata of 1855. When the composer tabled that sonata and turned to his next attempt a year later, he transferred the Mazurka, reworking some details but leaving the substance unchanged. Most of the melodic content of the 1905 variant is already present in the earliest ones, in which its working out is chunkier, the treatment less inventive and polished, and the formal realization more fragmented. The earlier movements are also conceived on a smaller scale, in simple ternary form. Listening to the 1856 variant (which Balakirev calls ‘Mazur’), its A section is a truly rustic dance, with its open fifths on the tonic and dominant chords, and a drone. It is hard to say whether the crude parallel fifths in the left hand were deliberate or a sign of compositional immaturity, but the composer eliminated them in the 1905 version.
The slow movement of the Sonata is an entrancing and tonally meandering ‘Intermezzo’. Although written with the key signature of two sharps, the movement is essentially atonal – not for lack of a tonic, but from overabundance of tonal centres (C-sharp major, G major, D major, B minor; C major, F-sharp major, D-flat major and B-flat minor), which emerge now and then amidst ever-transitioning, sliding chords, arpeggiated in the left hand. Punctuating the more stable areas is a simple yet lovely melody.
The fourth is the work's most ambitious movement, both technically (it is Lisztian in its demands) and compositionally. Though in sonata form, it has none of the stasis of the first movement. Its PT is conceived as a simple, duple-metre folksy (Slavic) dance in four phrases, each heard twice, with registral displacement upon reiteration. The first phrase is solidly in the tonic B-flat minor, though upon repeat Balakirev harmonizes its ending in D-flat major, and it is in that key that he then proceeds to state the next phrase – melodically an inversion of the first. Built into the theme, then, is peremennost’ (mutability) – that oscillation, usually between two relative keys, so characteristic of much of Balakirev's music. The third phrase, rhythmically derived from the first but now with leaps, offers some contrast, before the grand statement of the opening is heard. Balakirev constructs the Principal Theme Group (PTG) as ternary form. Its fortissimo middle section tonally unsettles the theme, necessitating a virtuosic retransition, which itself leads to a much more active, highly embellished restatement of the opening unit.
Since the relative major was prominently featured in the PT, Balakirev's choice of key for the ST is D major. The theme has a decidedly exotic character, and here one can safely use the word ‘oriental’, because, despite its motivic proximity to the third phrase of the PT, the theme seems to originate in another work altogether – in Glinka's Ruslan, specifically in the section of Lyudmila's first aria in which she addresses Ratmir, using the exoticized musical idiom that Glinka associates with the Khazarian prince and thus with the ‘orient’. Even Balakirev's key here matches Glinka's.
The dualism between Balakirev's ‘Slavic’ PT and the ‘oriental’ ST augments and intensifies the Romantic understanding of the gendered relationship between themes within sonata form. Whether these musical topics engender a broader extra-musical discourse across the movement is less clear. Nor should my labels, ‘Slavic’ and ‘oriental’, be taken to suggest that this work (or any other in the set, for that matter) projects some nationalist agenda or a sense of national identity. If anything, listening to the set as a whole makes one realize just how European Balakirev was, by which I mean that his music trades in every Romantic cliché, largely undefined – or unmarked – by specific geographic location. I highlight this ‘Europeanism’ not to express any surprise, but to underscore that exposure to Balakirev's piano works en masse might unsettle some listeners’ expectations of the music's ‘Russianness’. I question the degree to which Walker's liner notes emphasize the Russianness of this music. He writes that Balakirev was creating a ‘quintessentially Russian sonata’, ‘that would express the entire history of Russia – her peoples, landscapes and culture’ (Grand Piano 636, pp. 5–6). Thus, for Walker, the first movement's PT – its fugal exposition, of all things! – evokes ‘deepest Rus’; musical ‘detail is piled upon detail in an almost medieval fashion, inspired by Orthodox Christianity – think of mosaics and iconostases!’ (6); the Finale ‘dies away peacefully in a most striking manner, rather as Russia herself stretches endlessly eastward through steppe, taiga and forest’ (6). I certainly cannot help it if this music conjures up such imagery for Walker, but I can forewarn any listeners who are allergic to the mystique of Russianness and the essentialist rhetoric that it precipitates.
To return to the lyrical ST of the Sonata: its first appearance is accompanied by quick, arpeggiated chords in semiquavers but displaced (i.e., offbeat) by a single semiquaver, with a stunning effect. One hears the ST three times back to back in varied form, the last being its climactic utterance. Such frequent nocturne-like sections in Balakirev's music inevitably call to mind Chopin, but without the latter's contrapuntal intricacy that fills in the distance between the melodic and harmonic domains. In rendering these lyrical sections, Walker has an excellent sense of Balakirev's melodic sweep – his phrasing is exceptional. What at first sounds like a codetta to the STG signals the beginning of the Development, the music gradually shifts to unstable G minor, and, before long, a quiet statement of the ST mutates into the music of the Intermezzo, with its keys of C-sharp major and G major. Obviously Balakirev is aiming for the obligatory Romantic cyclicity within the sonata as a whole. Suddenly, the listener is pulled back into the PTG (starting with its contrasting middle), but now in B minor – a false recapitulation of sorts, rotating much of the earlier material. The Recapitulation proper commences a bit later in reverse order: ST in all its glory in D-flat major followed by PT in B-flat minor. The latter is revisited with some bluster – rapidly alternating double chords in both hands (à la Islamey). In general, the rhetorical intensification owes much to the corresponding build-up of virtuosity as the movement unfolds. Walker rises to the technical challenges of the movement, particularly in the Recapitulation, with aplomb – nothing ever sounds difficult, even if the music approaches the limits of playability. But the sonata ends in a different rhetorical register altogether – by withering.
I dwell on this sonata because it encapsulates the rest of the collection, capturing as it does Balakirev's pianism and his style in all its mature, but by this point depressingly obsolete, glory. One witnesses the process of its formation 50 years earlier in the other two sonatas on the same disk. Although independent works, the three sonatas have two prominent elements in common: their shared mazurka material and their common key of B-flat minor (one of Balakirev's favourites, and one that – as we saw above – inevitably manifests three others, D-flat major, B minor, and D major, at various structural levels and in different configurations). Hearing these works side by side allows one to appreciate Balakirev's mastery of sonata form, though not the trajectory of its evolution, for which one must turn to Balakirev's orchestral output.
Balakirev wrote his ‘Grande Sonate’ at the age of 18 in early 1855, while he was still living in the provinces. He dedicated the work to Glinka, whom he was to meet for the first time later that year in St Petersburg. Whether the sonata was composed and dedicated in anticipation of that meeting is unclear; nor do we know whether Glinka ever heard the work. If he did, it is hard to imagine him approving, and one has to wonder whether it was the older master's critique that prompted Balakirev to reject the piece. The sonata was conceived in five movements, the last being a fugal epilogue, based on the main theme from the Mazurka, which Balakirev never completed. The work was almost certainly inspired by Chopin's B-flat minor Sonata, with which Balakirev became acquainted shortly before his own experiment in the genre. The Sonata opens with a ‘ferocious’ waltz. Its sonata form is subsumed by virtuosic variations on the catchy main theme, with things like rapid repetitions on a single note, full chords, octaves, duplets and triplets, rapid scales, melody divided between the hands – anything and everything from the virtuoso's toolkit. The movement is bulky and bombastic, but considering Balakirev's age and inexperience of working in large-scale forms, it is impressive. All four movements showcase the composer's potential for original melodic invention and development of his material. The Mazurka, discussed earlier, leads to the lyrical Larghetto, which is lovely if a bit tedious. The sonata-form finale is a much lighter but harmonically more inventive movement than its counterpart that opens the work.
Balakirev's next piano sonata, written a year later, already in St Petersburg, where he was establishing himself as a virtuoso pianist and rising composer, is a far more mature work. The first movement is its most impassioned and dynamic. It opens with a slow and unstable introduction, based on two elements: the ‘fate’ motive (triplet of three short notes followed by a long note) and the descending chromatic line in octaves (anticipating the movement proper's main theme, where it is rhythmicized). Meandering through hazy tonal regions, the introduction finally settles on the dominant of the home key, as Balakirev sets up the eruption of the Allegro assai feroce. In terms of its technical demand, material and harmonic progressions, the movement owes much not only to Chopin but also to Liszt, and, in its overall conception, Beethoven. The tempestuous, chordal and very chromatic PT gives way to a codetta theme that stabilizes the tonic before rapid passagework (octaves, cascading triples, etc.) leads to A-flat major. If one is expecting the ST in D-flat, none is forthcoming. Treating A-flat as G-sharp, and relying on common-tone modulation, the composer shifts to E major (enharmonic F-flat major), presenting one of his gorgeous, purely diatonic, themes against arpeggiated nocturne-like accompaniment – all subsequently enhanced through variation and piquant harmonic touches. The loveliness of the STG soon dissolves as the CT, based on the music of the PT, transports listeners to C-sharp minor (enharmonic D-flat minor), in which this three-key exposition ends. Compared to the first movement of the earlier sonata, this work's opening movement's formal and melodic drama – realized even more fully in the Development and Recapitulation sections – is far more effective.
The Mazur movement in D major, already considered, offers not only a nice contrast, but a much-needed moment of repose. But the third, slow, movement in G-flat major flops. Having completed the movement, Balakirev halted his work on the sonata. The same year he attempted the sonata, he experienced his first of many creative crises, questioning his worth as a composer (anxiety perhaps brought on by his encounter with Beethoven's Ninth Symphony). Whether this sonata contributed to the crisis or whether it was the crises that made Balakirev reject the sonata is unknown, but like the first sonata, the second never fully materialized.
Whatever their shortcomings, listening to these early large-scale works, it is hard not to be impressed by Balakirev's mastery of the instrument and of musical form, especially considering his lack of formal training. He was a true autodidact, who became a composer by osmosis – hearing, studying, playing and emulating others. In his early days that meant mostly Mozart, Beethoven, Glinka and Chopin. Significantly, Beethoven is rarely, if ever, invoked as influence on Balakirev's music, early or not. Perhaps this is where the first CD, with its three sonatas, makes its biggest contribution, highlighting Balakirev's familiarity with and reliance on Beethoven as a model. Balakirev knew all of Beethoven's sonatas already by the age of 17 – he would play them to his patron, Alexander Ulïbïshev (Oulibicheff), as the latter was working on his famous monograph, Beethoven: ses critiques et ses glossateurs (1857). It was likely in the music of Beethoven that Balakirev first systematically encountered sonata form, with his own sonatas becoming the earliest attempts to come to terms with that form. Listening to the sonata-form movements in the three piano sonatas should put to rest the persistent myth of Balakirev's (and in general, Russian composers’) inability to ‘develop’ material (in the Germanic sense). There is no shortage of motivic transformations and processual constructions. But from the start, he clearly had options: development, as traditionally understood, coexists with other methods of melodic treatment (like Glinka variations), which are often subsumed by the sonata-form framework as well.
What distinguishes Balakirev's sonatas on the first CD from the music on the other two disks are their large-scale conception and less salon-like qualities. The remaining works are in the tradition of drawing-room music, but intended for a virtuoso pianist. The second disk offers mostly waltzes (seven) and nocturnes (four), while the third focuses on mazurkas (seven), interspersed with a few character pieces. Experimental these works are not. Except for the music that originates in the 1850s, which, like ‘Mazurka No. 1’, tends to sound fresh, exciting, and, at times, charmingly awkward, everything else in the set projects a sense of a reminiscence. Reinforcing this sense of things past are Balakirev's obvious musical influences: Chopin and Glinka in his choice of genres, Berlioz in the music's tonal angularity, Liszt in its brilliant virtuosity, and Schumann (of piano works) in its emotional dryness and even academism. That impression of dryness is particularly difficult to shake off, and one struggles – in vain – to pinpoint its source. Was Walker, perhaps, trying to capture, or channel, Balakirev's own pianistic style, which was noted for its lack of Romantic excess – it was virtuosic but always restrained (lacking variety of attack)? Or was it the music itself, its emotional potential diligently filtered out by the composer, who, perhaps, wanted to keep his listener's emotional engagement at arm's length? And is it this lack of music's emotional immediacy and expressive abundance that makes one hear it as passé? For anyone interested in tackling these dilemmas, this collection should give much to ponder.
