A difficult concept for American students to grasp in political science courses is the importance of the mechanism by which a democracy translates votes into representation. American students are typically surprised that there are multiple ways in which a democracy can accomplish this very important task with varying results, regardless of the fact that there are different electoral systems at work in the U.S. It is difficult for them to comprehend different electoral systems and the representation that results largely due to a lack of experience with other systems (and too often with their own). Without this experience, it becomes difficult for students to make qualitative assessments of electoral systems. To aid my introductory American government students in gaining some experience in this regard, I have developed a simulation in which different proportional-based electoral systems and the resulting representation are compared with a single-member plurality electoral system with which most of them are familiar.
While developed for an introductory American government course and especially suited for instructors who teach from a comparative angle or who emphasize reform, the simulation would be suitable for other introductory courses such as introduction to political science or comparative politics. Research on learning styles has suggested that it is especially important in introductory courses to utilize “activities that provide concrete and active experiences for students, since lower division students indicated a greater preference for these styles than upperclass students” (Fox and Ronkowski Reference Fox and Ronkowski1997, 736). This simulation, however, could also be adapted for upper-level courses on Congress, elections, or political parties. This classroom activity does more than simply expose students to different ways of arriving at representation. In the approximately two dozen times I have conducted this simulation, I have found that it is an excellent way to illustrate various concepts students have been introduced to in the introductory American government course from the areas of Congress, political parties, electoral behavior, public policy, and campaigns and elections. Accordingly, I end the semester with this particular activity because it encompasses multiple areas of the course and serves to tie together concepts that students previously may have viewed discretely. In what follows, I will discuss the objectives of the simulation, the way it is conducted, and a brief evaluation of it. Instructors will find that this simulation is useful if they are searching for a way to insert a brief experiential activity into their courses. In addition, certain aspects of the simulation are adaptable so that it can be tailored to fit the needs of individual instructors.
An electoral system is the way a political entity chooses to translate votes into representation. How one translates votes into representation—the rules of the game—is very important for it will affect the representation one gets. Electoral systems are made up of several key factors, the most important of which are the electoral formula, the ballot structure, and the district magnitude (Lijphart Reference Lijphart1990; Riedwyl and Steiner Reference Riedwyl and Steiner1995; Reynolds, Reilly, and Ellis Reference Reynolds, Reilly and Ellis2005). The electoral formula deals with the method used to arrive at how the seats in the legislative body will be allocated. The ballot structure concerns whether voters vote for a single candidate or a party slate and if voters have one or multiple votes and whether they can register their preferences (and intensity of those preferences), or not. Finally, district magnitude refers to how many representatives a constituency will be electing.
For the purposes of the simulation, students experiment with three electoral systems: a winner-take-all system and two systems of proportional representation (PR). Winner-take-all systems function on the principle that the entity with the most votes wins. The winner-take-all system utilized for the simulation is the single-member plurality (SMP) system currently in use to elect members of the U.S. Congress, as well as most other legislative seats in the U.S.Footnote 1 Systems of proportional representation (PR) function on the principle of proportionality in multi-member districts. The absolute winner does not take all and other vote getters are rewarded with legislative seats. One PR system in the simulation uses the single-transferrable vote (STV) mechanism for proportionally translating votes into seats, and the other uses a cumulative voting (CV) mechanism. Finally, for purposes of comparison, students are also exposed to a PR system that utilizes a party list in the debriefing of the simulation. Classroom conditions, however, are not conducive to incorporating a party-list system into the simulation. See Table 1 for the key aspects of the electoral systems used in the simulation.
Key Components of Electoral Systems Used in Simulation

a Magnitude may fluctuate depending on number of simulation participants. A general rule of thumb is a representative for every 10 students.
OBJECTIVES
The overall objective of the simulation is to expose students to some of the different electoral systems democracies use to select representatives, giving students a foundation on which to base qualitative comparisons. There are more specific objectives as well. First, the election is conducted around a single public policy issue, chosen by the instructor because it is a policy that has a direct impact on students. One objective is that each “voter” will develop an informed position on that policy issue.
Second, the simulation exemplifies how the electoral system in use affects the composition of the legislature elected. From the use of three different systems using the exact same candidates, electorate, and issue, one typically arrives at three legislatures that are different in composition, allowing students to assess the representation each system produces. A third objective is that the views of the elected legislators can be compared with the public opinion of the class of the policy issue, thus illustrating this link (or lack thereof) to students.
Finally, the simulation will help illustrate concepts previously covered in the class, such as types of representation (trustee and delegate), issues of representation (descriptive and substantive), parliamentary systems, the relative weakness of American political parties, issue voting, campaigning, and aspects of public policy formation.Footnote 2
SIMULATION
The actual simulation is designed to be conducted in two to three class periods (one week). Portions of two additional class periods are needed, one for a lecture on key aspects of the chosen policy area, several weeks before the actual simulation takes place, and a second one for a lecture on the nature of the electoral systems and simulation instructions. The minimum number of students needed is approximately 25, but there is no maximum; I typically conduct it with about 35 students. All students will play the role of voter; additionally approximately 10 students will be needed to run for seats in the legislatures, but this may vary depending on the number of seats to be elected.
The first step in the simulation is for the instructor to decide on the policy area around which the election will take place. To simplify the preparation that is necessary on the part of students, I limit the campaign and election to one policy issue. The policy issue should be one that has a direct impact on students' lives. In addition, the policy issue ideally should be one on which there is no broad consensus and is actively under consideration. I have used several different policy areas, including education policy and health care policy. Most recently I have used the issue of Social Security reform with great success. It tends to be an issue about which students know relatively little (and what they think they know is often wrong). There is a wide consensus that reform is needed, but there has not been a broad consensus on what reform should look like; and, it is very easy to illustrate to students how the program directly impacts their lives. About mid-semester, I distribute a detailed writing assignment. In this assignment students are asked to research the policy area. They are initially exposed to the policy area through reading assignments. The brief writing assignment asks them to research the policy and form a position about what future policy should be. They are required to address both the pros and cons of their chosen policy position. Several weeks before the writing assignment is due, I will give the students background information about the policy area. On the date that the actual election simulation begins, students are required to turn in their completed writing assignments. Thus, all students are theoretically made into informed issue voters. The likelihood of this is also increased because there are no party labels used in the simulation.
In the week before the simulation is scheduled to begin, students are given a handout that details the steps they need to complete. First, they each must formulate a position on the issue at hand, which they should already be in the process of doing through the writing assignment. Second, students are asked to sign up if they would like to run for office. This is done on a volunteer basis. Students are induced with an extra-credit opportunity.Footnote 3 Approximately 10 students will be needed, but this can vary based on class size and needs. Finally, students must be present during the simulation so they may participate. On the day before the simulation, I give a brief lecture on the three different electoral systems that will be used, their key aspects (pros and cons), and examples of their use. Once the students understand the systems, I explain how the simulation is going to go forward when class next convenes.
On the day the simulation begins, all students will have established their position on the issue and will turn in their written assignments. Once assignments are turned in, each voter is given a very simple, anonymous survey that asks, “Which of the following options best represents your view on [the policy issue]?” followed by a list of choices. In this way, I can summarize the views of the electorate for the second part of the simulation when representation is assessed. The survey can be made more extensive if it fits the needs of the instructor. The candidate names are written on a chalkboard when students enter the classroom, divided into districts for the SMP election. In assigning the candidates to districts, I am careful to make one of the districts have only two candidates (to better illustrate lack of choice); the remaining districts have any combination of three or four to fit the number of candidates (which may serve to illustrate the plurality nature of the SMP system). The voters are assigned to districts by having them number off. Before beginning the campaign speeches, students are reminded that in the first system, their choices will be constrained depending upon their district assignment. But, in the following systems, they will have the full range of candidates from which to choose. Therefore, it is important that the students pay attention to the positions of all the candidates, who will only give their campaign pitches once. At this point the ballot for the SMP system is distributed to all students, who indicate their districts on the ballot (see Figure 1).
Ballots for Simulation

The candidates begin by giving short (two to five minutes) campaign speeches about their positions on the issue. Candidates are free to campaign as they wish. Some will make signs, some will distribute candy or other incentives for voters, some will construct a video, but most will simply stand up and make statements about their positions. Questions from voters are allowed, but only for the purposes of clarification, not for the purposes of debate. It is important for the timeframe of the simulation that this not turn into a free-for-all discussion. However, should an instructor wish to make the simulation more involved, this could be conducted in a debate format. Once District 1's candidates have concluded their speeches, the students in District 1 are asked to vote and turn in their ballots. The next district's candidates then proceed, and so on. Once all candidates have delivered their speeches, and all of the SMP ballots have been collected, the STV ballot is distributed (see Figure 1). Voters are reminded that their choices are no longer constrained by district and they can choose from the entire slate of candidates, as well as rank their preferences. They are also reminded that the order in which they indicate their preferences is important. Once the STV ballots are cast and collected, the final CV ballot is distributed and students are reminded that the distribution of their votes is important (see Figure 1). They may indicate the strength of their preferences. At this point, the first part of the simulation is complete.
Before the next class meeting it is important for the instructor to compile the results of the public-opinion survey, as well as count the ballots to determine the composition of the legislatures.Footnote 4 A handout is prepared for discussion with these results (see Figure 2 and Table 2).
Class Opinion

Election Simulation Results

EVALUATION
The final class session of the simulation exercise is devoted to discussion and debriefing. The students, led by the instructor, enter into a broad and often wide-ranging discussion about what was learned, in what ways the simulation deviates from reality, and an assessment of electoral systems. Since students now have hands-on experience with three different systems, it is at this point that I introduce them to a PR party-list system,Footnote 5 and I point out its prevalence in democracies worldwide. With knowledge of four different electoral systems, and hands-on experience with three, the evaluation of the simulation takes place.
First, the three legislatures' compositions are examined. It has never failed that this election simulation has returned at least some difference in composition, and often differences in all three legislatures. Thus, the point is made that voters, the issue, and candidates were all held constant and the electoral system varied. The difference in composition can be attributed to the different electoral systems used to elect each legislature. The rules under which votes are cast and counted affect representation. Next, the issue stances of the various legislators in each legislature are compared with the overall class opinion in order to assess substantive representation. Which system best reflects class public opinion? With the issue of Social Security reform, this is best examined two dimensionally by simplifying opinion into those who favor some form of privatization and those who are opposed to some form of privatization. It is typical that the SMP system over-represents majority opinion; minority opinion, however, is typically proportionally represented in the PR systems. In looking at the composition of the legislatures, it may also be possible to discuss the descriptive representation that was returned in the election results; typically, the PR systems are better at returning descriptive representation.
The instructor should also note for the class some things that may have been observed through the counting of ballots. For example, it has been my experience that even though I attempt to make all students issue voters by requiring them to become informed on the given campaign issue, I note in counting ballots inconsistencies that would likely not occur if that were really the case. For example, I will encounter PR ballots that include candidates who had diametrically opposed positions on the same ballot. What, therefore, might account for these discrepancies? Often, students indicate inducements offered, friendship, or campaign performance that might have caused them not to be consistent on the issue. In addition, one can often observe interesting behavior on the CV ballots, which allows the intensity of a voter's preference to be registered. It has been my experience that one side of the Social Security debate (the side that perceives itself to be in the minority as a result of campaign speeches) will often respond by registering its intensity by concentrating its votes for one or a few candidates. The side that perceives itself to be in the majority does not typically respond in the same fashion, more evenly distributing its votes among candidates (see Guinier Reference Guinier1994).
It is also important to ask students to reflect on how the simulation deviates from reality. For example, most actual voters are neither issue voters nor are they well informed; the simulation attempts to force voters to be both. However, even though I attempt to make all students become issue voters, as noted above, there are always some who will base their votes on something other than matching their positions with a candidate's position. Further, real electoral situations are not focused on a single issue. It is a lot of work to be an informed, issue voter (which is why most Americans aren't). The simulation also is nonpartisan. Students should note the use of partisan cues in the American electoral system that is absent in the simulation. Finally, it is often worth pointing out that the apportioning of voters to districts in the simulation's SMP system was done randomly; this is not the case in American states.Footnote 6
Finally, I ask students to offer their assessments of different electoral systems. Which system do they like best, which least, and why? Which ballot did they prefer? Which ballot required voters to convey the most information and the least information? Which ballot required the most information of voters? Would a party-list system work in the United States? Why or why not? Under what circumstances might we see electoral reform? I typically bring in examples of states and localities that do use different electoral systems in the U.S.Footnote 7 Most of my students being Iowans, I also point out that the Democrats in the Iowa caucuses allocate delegates through a form of STV.
As the class reflects on what they have learned, instructor flexibility is important. Not all of the possible concepts may be illustrated each time the simulation is conducted. For example, the simulation may not offer a good example of the way in which PR systems generally improve upon descriptive representation. Further, students may or may not include a discussion of American political culture as a reason why a party-list system would not be acceptable to most Americans. Instructors should not only be prepared to have a core set of points to make during the debriefing in terms of what students should take away from the simulation, but also be flexible and allow student discussion to be wide ranging; it can be surprising where the discussion will go.
In the more than 20 times I have conducted this simulation, student reaction has been very positive. In what is typically a lecture-oriented course, students appreciate a change of pace that allows them to express opinions and offer judgments about the representation one gets given different rules of the game. Furthermore, as an instructor it is rewarding to see students engaging in a hands-on activity that helps illustrate that how a representative democracy translates votes into representation is not a one-size-fits-all proposition.



