Much has been written in recent years about Jewish contributions to twentieth-century US theatre history, yet few have considered the position of Jews on the American stage prior to the Civil War. With Hideous Characters & Beautiful Pagans: Performing Jewish Identity on the Antebellum Stage, Heather S. Nathans has made a remarkable contribution to American Jewish theatre scholarship. Referencing a dazzling array of heretofore unexamined primary sources and documents, Nathans presents a comprehensive history that vividly brings to life this period, its stage Jews and Jewesses, and its complex and often contradictory depictions of Jewish integration into American culture.
As the first book-length study of Jewish Americans onstage in the pre–Civil War period, Hideous Characters & Beautiful Pagans is that rare book that cracks wide open an almost completely unknown chapter of theatre history. A reader examining previous scholarship might be forgiven for concluding that Jews were but a footnote to US theatre history until the late nineteenth century. This book presents a necessary corrective by demonstrating, quite convincingly, that Jews played an important role in American theatre from its very inception. Moreover, their position on the eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century American stage was far more nuanced and interesting than previously acknowledged. Nathans takes up the prevailing scholarly notion that Jews were solely depicted as one-dimensional “venal villains” (1) on the antebellum American stage and skillfully dismantles it. Instead, Nathans argues, Jewish stage representations were multifaceted and ever-shifting during this period, and they reflected the push–pull cycle of embrace and rejection that characterized how Jewish Americans were treated offstage. Jewish characters, she writes, can thus be understood as “useful indices” (3) for understanding the relationship between Jews and American culture at critical historical junctures.
Nathans employs an impressive variety of sources to make her case, including theatre reviews, diaries, letters, poems, political documents and speeches, legal rulings, cartoons, portraits, tax records, and records of rumors. Her goal in using such a wide range and number of primary sources, she tells us, is to “listen for the ‘echoes’ of vanished audiences” (4). Hideous Characters & Beautiful Pagans offers a valuable new model for how theatre historians can approach audience capture. Rather than trying to ascertain the precise demographic or social breakdown of theatre audiences of the past, the historian might instead follow Nathans's model and “listen” for historical “echoes” of audience response across a wide array of sources, gradually piecing those echoes together into a composite picture.
Hideous Characters & Beautiful Pagans has six chapters, each of which addresses a different aspect of Jews in American theatre in this period. As Nathans is careful to note, the chapters are not intended to create a progressive or linear historical arc, but rather to track a series of related historical phenomena. The first chapter considers “the often contradictory representations” (20) of Jewish male identity on the early American stage. Nathans considers the earliest American productions of The Merchant of Venice against the backdrop of the fluctuating legal status of Jewish American men from the colonial period through 1826. Chapter 2 takes up a related topic: how Jewish men negotiated masculinity onstage and off between 1826 and 1861. Nathans examines a series of well-known father–daughter conflicts onstage alongside a group of famous and highly theatrical duels and trials that centered around issues of Jewish masculinity. The third chapter considers how migration helped to develop antebellum Jewish American identities and takes up the “Wandering Jew” (83) archetype alongside histories of actual itinerant performers. Chapter 4 looks at how Jewish performers traveled across the American frontier and asks what role artists’ Jewish identity played in shaping how audiences perceived them. The fifth chapter examines the figure of the “stage Jewess” (137), which Nathans calls American drama's first “taboo female icon” (16), and considers how this figure helped theatregoers to understand the role of Jewish women in American culture. The last chapter looks at how Judaism and Jewish holidays, traditions, and rituals were represented on the antebellum American stage.
One of the most salient features of this book is its embrace of paradox in the historical record. Nathans offers a rich portrayal that does not shy away from historical contradictions, such as the ascent of sympathetic Jewish fathers on the American stage at the same time as Shylock became a popular villain, or articles defending Jews’ humanity appearing in the same newspaper that wrote of malevolent Jewish stage villains. “Positive and negative characters circled in orbit,” writes Nathans, “each exerting a strong gravitational pull on the other, and each inevitably shaping the other as well” (12–13). This approach is welcome and refreshing. It is also well suited to the book's subject matter. By the end of this book, the reader is left with a rich sense of how complex, multifaceted, and thoroughly contradictory American portrayals of Jews onstage were during this period.
As its title suggests, Hideous Characters & Beautiful Pagans is a delight to read, and contains within its pages the stories of colorful historical characters, fascinating plays, and bizarre historical occurrences that readers likely never have encountered before. Nevertheless, these figures, this repertoire, and these events, as Nathans demonstrates, had a remarkable impact on the history of American theatre. This book is a must-read for any scholar interested in the history of Jews and theatre. It is also essential reading for anyone interested in the historical development of the American stage and its nonlinear, complex, and ever-fluctuating relationships with the immigrant populations that shaped it.
