This book edited by Thomas Sikor and his colleagues originated from a workshop held in Hanoi in 2007 on the theme: ‘Montane choices and outcomes: Contemporary transformations of Vietnam's uplands’. The contributors' main goal was to go beyond the general scholarly assumptions that ‘natural differences [exist] between uplands and lowlands’ (p. 1). The book comprises eleven chapters regrouped in three different sections logically organised around the three main points it wishes to address.
The first section is the ‘Historical constitution of the uplands’, detailed in the first two chapters written by Salemink (chapter 1) and Sowerwine (chapter 2), which lay the foundation for the rest of the book. Contributors here shed some light on the social processes, especially historical ones, which have led to current understandings of the Vietnamese uplands. The second section addresses the ‘process of authority formation and their effects on the uplands’ (Sikor, p. 16), that is, how the successive states (colonial and then independent) have gradually controlled the upland areas, through various kinds of interventions, including more recently an ‘environmentalization of policy and research on the uplands’ (p. 17). Four case studies examine aspects of this transformation: common property (McElwee, chapter 3), state resource policies and market forces (Hoang, in northwest Vietnam, chapter 4; and Leisz and colleagues in Nghe An province, chapter 5) and land allocation (Sikor, chapter 6). The third part of this book relates to production and exchange. The (last) five chapters focus on market relations (Nghiem and Yanagisawa, chapter 7), cultural politics of agrarian change (Sowerwine, chapter 8), land market (Tô, chapter 9), livelihoods and migrations (Winkels, chapter 10), as well as changing labour relations (Duong, chapter 11). The book concludes with Tania Li's short postscript in which she pulls back the zoom to establish comparisons with Indonesia, her main field of research. She identifies similarities in the process of building ‘uplands’ in relation to marginality, power relations and production. She insists on the still active land frontiers in both countries, though this ‘safety-valve’ should not ‘be overstated’ (p. 261). Tania Li also evokes two distinctive elements of the Vietnam situation, compared to Indonesia or other countries in the region with similar issues. The weight of French colonial investment in the highlands (I have myself insisted on this period as the ‘setting of the table’ on which the eventual two independent Vietnamese states constructed their intervention into the highlands — see Steve Déry, La colonisation agricole au Viet Nam, 2004) as well as the socialist legacy which still resonates with current land management and governance (p. 261).
This being said, this skeletal summary does not do justice to the richness of this excellent book. Grounded in empirical evidence, with no false unity, all necessary efforts have been made to extract as much as possible from the combination of this collection (see Sikor, introduction), as well as to make each chapter talk to each other. Here, I would like to examine two issues raised from this reading: the geographical settings and the external forces related to national state building.
The geographical settings. Given the authors' intentions, there is a notable lack of nuance when addressing the geographical settings, especially when attempting to deconstruct it from perceptions. The first thing to do would have been to explain how the Vietnam uplands are anything but homogeneous. Yet, in his introduction, Sikor shows a series of maps (from Michael Epprecht and Andreas Heinimann, Socioeconomic atlas of Vietnam, 2004) which he uses to give a general portrait of Vietnam, showing how issues such as poverty, infrastructure and deforestation are interrelated, comparing lowlands and mountainous regions (pp. 4–11). Elsewhere, only Leisz et al. (chap. 5) and Sowerwine (chap. 8) give the geographical settings of their case studies. Most of the time, altitudes are not even mentioned. When we acknowledge that distance in the mind is often a product of distance on land (and various ways to measure it — kilometres, hours of travel, etc.), this issue is of the utmost importance. For example, Leisz et al. present a telling anecdote about how it took two years for news of Đổi Mới reforms to reach Cần hamlet in Nghệ An province (p. 119)!
External forces. The book analyses forces that are transforming the uplands, insisting on how the uplands have also shaped the lowlands; but in the end, most of the chapters simply demonstrate how current transformations of livelihoods and processes, dynamics, modes of production and access to land, are being modified by external forces, mostly the state and market/capitalism. Nonetheless, it is really the conjunction of state crafting and market integration that is bending uplands trajectories: all local people in the highlands are positioning themselves with regard to the market or to state endeavours: from ‘active participants’ seeking opportunities to the most marginalised and dispossessed at the other end of the spectrum (see for example, Sikor, p. 20, as well as chapters 7 and 8), through a rainbow of people more or less actively negotiating the terms of their involvement with the market and with the various authorities. Thus far, the centres of state and market power have been located outside the realms of the Vietnamese uplands.
