This contribution to the growing body of work on the UN Human Rights Council (the Council) that in 2006 replaced the beleaguered UN Commission on Human Rights (the Commission) provides a neat and coherent survey of the genesis of the Council and an objective critique of its operational and ideological challenges in the context of both international law and international relations (IR) theory. The book comprises three parts; “The Human Rights Council’s mandate”, “Criteria for Assessing the Council”, and “Assessment of the Council”.
Part 1 recalls the Commission’s demise, key factors cited being that its membership included states known as human rights abusers, its failure to act in response to state-led gross violations of human rights, the making of apparently politically motivated country-specific resolutions, a lack of resources rendering it insufficiently equipped to respond to human rights crises, and the inhibiting effects of regionalism. The debates and documents that spawned the subsequent Council and its mandate are then explored. Whilst the new Council’s membership was hotly debated, Freedman observes little fundamental change in its composition compared to that of the Commission. The conclusion is somewhat bleak: politicization persists and threatens to delegitimize the Council’s work.
In Part 2, Freedman describes the Council’s “innovative approach” of focusing on the intersection of international law and politics (p. 88). She offers a concise description of five IR theories—realism, idealism, social constructivism, institutionalism, and Marxist and post-Marxist theory—concluding that social constructivism has both a theoretical and practical role to play in comprehending the work and operation of the Council, but that Marxist and post-Marxist discourses offer a useful means of exploring state and group behaviour at the Council.
In assessing the politicization of the role and function of international organizations, Freedman suggests three categories: ideological discourse, overt-politicization, and politicization through “success stories”. She thus charts various perspectives; that politicization of international organizations is not always seen as a defect but is to some extent inevitable, reflecting political, military, economic, or cultural conflict between states, and that politicization has been pursued more effectively by the developing states of the Global South—the Council’s one-state-one-vote structure precluding “strong states” from wielding collective might (p. 121).
The third and most significant part in terms of volume and content assesses the Council’s performance to date. This includes charting the US’s exceptionalism and unilateralist stance towards international organizations in general and the Council in particular (pp. 151–8). The penultimate chapter of this third part portrays a severe failing on the part of the Council in particular, and the UN as a whole, in relation to Darfur, Sudan (a theme that Freedman picks up in more detail in her most recent book, Failing to Protect: The UN and the Politicisation of Human Rights (Hurst, 2014)). In this context, Freedman explains the dangers inherent in regionalism, whereby allied countries use group tactics to pursue a common agenda, to protect individuals, or to further the national policies of individual states (pp. 197, 200). Freedman’s conclusion is less that the failure to take action in relation to Darfur is that of the Council and the UN, and more that of states (both members of Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) and non-members) opting to take a neutral stance in order to avoid being ostracized by the OIC, the result being that the Council’s “idealist principles” were “unable to withstand some states’ realist aims and power politics” (p. 251). The final chapter outlines the “innovative” mechanisms, namely the Universal Periodic Review and Special Sessions.
By illustrating the application of theory with practical examples, Freedman provides a welcome narrative that is easy to read compared to those more abstract and esoteric texts in the field. Her final conclusion is that further reform is required, particularly with the aim of depoliticizing the Council, whose legitimacy and credibility in this respect has already been seriously compromised. This text will be appreciated by politics scholars as a means to comprehend key tensions at the heart of international human rights law, whilst legal practitioners and students will find it an accessible and practical introduction to the theoretical world of IR’s intersection with the same.
