An ambitious and greatly needed book, Latin Numbers: Playing Latino in Twentieth-Century U.S. Popular Performance by Brian Eugenio Herrera illustrates and contextualizes popular performance in the United States during the 1900s through several case studies to which Herrera refers as “Latin numbers.” Arranged to examine the century loosely by decades, Herrera's historical analysis is both engaging and informative, constantly showing the reader how Latina/o bodies and characters performed in specific political contexts and influenced popular performance. Herrera (re)introduces each performer and character, including his or her individual heritage and path to the spotlight, all with pointed humor and a sense of storytelling. I was continually drawn in by Herrera's threading of the political setting and scaffolding of political and social movements from one chapter to the next.
In its prologue, the book introduces several new terms whose usage exemplifies a gap in identified language for “playing Latino,” though Herrera certainly acknowledges the prior work of Latino studies and performance studies scholars, such as Philip J. Deloria, Henry Bial, David Román, and Alberto Sandoval-Sánchez. In one explanation of his terms, Herrera defines Latin numbers as marking “the discrete historical moments in which a briefly intensified media interest queries the ways in which Latinos might soon be important within US culture, life, and politics” (4). The author further points to the ways in which producers brought each Latin number to its audience as new and exotic, often (though not always) for the appetite of non-Latina/os, and often as if to introduce non-Latina/os to the “Latino” experience. Herrera includes five chapters, each illustrating one or more Latin numbers from the twentieth century, contextualizing the examples in relation to one another and within their own historical and political context. Herrera argues that examining the decisions around the performance, the public demand on certain performances, the casting of certain actors, and the reception of a performance offers a fuller understanding of the evolution of the Latino/a character and body onstage.
Chapter 1 focuses on the conga as a musical form that made its way to the stage through many avenues, but ultimately in the 1930s became a recognized Latin number on US stages. The chapter also explores the Good Neighbor Policy, introduced by Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the same decade. Herrera argues that the policy deeply influenced and echoed a “recurrent phenomenon of fleeting fascination with Latin-ness within US popular performance” (21). In Chapter 2, Herrera examines the “stealth” Latino performer, meaning those whose Latina/o identities were obscured by producers, casting agents, the actors themselves, or others. Focused mostly on the 1950s and giving more attention to film in this decade, Herrera offers insight into how Latina/os found ways of making their work legible. The chapter specifically highlights the careers of Ricardo Montalban, Juano Hernandez, and Mel Ferrer and chronicles how these actors, through very different methods and in very different contexts, “rehearsed the racial limits of the color line in US popular performance” (56).
Chapter 3 examines the racialization of the Sharks in West Side Story. With more prior scholarship from others on which to draw, Herrera offers here a comprehensive though concise analysis of the political context in which the stageplay was first developed and then the rationale and challenges of representation in the film adaptation. Specifically, Herrera illustrates how the story and storytelling in both media reified and challenged the treatment and characterization of Puerto Rican Americans; he argues that the arrangement of songs and the depiction of the Sharks in the film “install[ed] the ‘Latin gang member’ as a racialized stock character in American popular performance” (127). Chapter 4 brings us back to stage performance broadened beyond a specific show or performance style, examining performative stereotypes from the Frito Bandito to the work of Teatro Campesino. The chapter spans the 1960s and 1970s, a time when, Herrera contends, Latina/o stereotypes were not just “unyielding antagonist[s] in a sustained battle over the discursive features of representational truth” (138); rather, performers “enacted the stereotype so that they might eviscerate the stereotype” (139).
The final chapter focuses on the Totem International doll Carlos, boyfriend of Billy, the first “out” homosexual doll available commercially. Herrera situates the coming out (pun intended) of both dolls during the AIDS epidemic and other political challenges in the LGBTQ community, such as “Don't Ask, Don't Tell.” Herrera uses Carlos to explore the myriad gay couples depicted in 1990s US popular culture. Herrera doesn't help his reader transition into this chapter in the same way he does in previous ones, however, perhaps explaining why this chapter feels a bit disconnected from the others. An additional factor that makes this chapter feel removed from the rest of the book is that Herrera stays focused here on nonstage performance. An epilogue returns to examining live performance, this time with a 1999 New Yorker cartoon depiction of a band called Los Latinos del Momento dressed in stereotypical “Latin” clothing and with stereotypical “Latin” instruments and moustaches. Herrera interprets that the fictional band, created by the cartoonist, is finally moving to “‘play Latino’” after abandoning other styles of music. He further argues that the band members “embody the perpetual novelty status so frequently accorded Latinos in US pop culture” (192–3). This snapshot of popular culture smartly coalesces Herrera's arguments and offers a last bit of canny humor, echoing Herrera's own wit inscribed throughout the book.
Latin Numbers is a critical work, grappling with greatly undertheorized subjects and ideas. Herrera opts for depth rather than breadth, perhaps purposely offering only a nod to some noteworthy Latina/o performers of the 1990s instead of in-depth examinations. A book about twentieth-century Latino popular performance could easily feel unnecessary, belated, or even irrelevant. This book, however, is both a pleasure to read and significant to understanding the historical steps leading to Latina/o representations in popular performance. It also provides ways to consider similar works in today's cultural landscape. The Latin number, after all, is not only a thing of the twentieth century, but a twenty-first-century term and lens for looking at popular Latina/o performance. The book will undoubtedly affect the work of future scholars, who can pick up from where Herrera has now brought us.
