This well-crafted, eminently readable study offers a “new trajectory” in the historiography of Palestine by exploring “the development of two of its most important cities: Jaffa, one of the oldest cities and ports in the world, and Tel Aviv, called the ‘first Hebrew city in the modern world,’ which was born alongside and ultimately overthrew Palestine's Bride of the Sea as the economic and cultural capital of the country” (p. 2). As a “critical reading of modernity as it unfolded in Palestine/Israel and the Larger Levant” (p. 5), Overthrowing Geography is a welcome addition to the growing literature that for the past twenty or thirty years has challenged “foundational myths and (mis)understandings” that have long dominated the historiography of Palestine.
In the years after Bonaparte's destruction of the city, Jaffa became the most important port along Palestine's coast, attracting newcomers from surrounding regions, Egypt, Syria, and Lebanon. Arab Jews (from North Africa) began arriving in the 1820s and the first European Jews in 1839. Jaffa served as the entrance point for Jewish and Christian pilgrims. LeVine illustrates “three interrelated matrices of modernity”: Jaffa's cosmopolitan Mediterranean modernity, the “exclusivist-colonial modernity that arrived with Zionism,” which was facilitated by the British, and the “non-modernities” within and surrounding the space of Euro-modernity in Tel Aviv. By this latter matrix LeVine means “Jaffa and its surrounding villages ‘erased’ by Tel Aviv's development and expanding imaginary and geographic domains.” With these he brings into play a second “mutually constitutive fourfold matrix of discourses—modernity, colonialism, capitalism, and nationalism” (p. 2).
The stage is now set for a fascinating depiction of the founding and early history of Tel Aviv, first called Ahuzat Bayit, by middle-class Zionist Jews from Jaffa. LeVine unweaves the complexities and contradictions surrounding the purchase of the plot of land they had chosen (called Karm al-Jabali, “the vineyard of the Jabali family”) with admirable skill. “Whatever its claims to creation ex nihilo. . .Tel Aviv was born into. . .a complex ecosystem of neighborhoods, ‘colonies,’ farms. . .vineyards, orchards, dunes” (p. 81). LeVine is clear about what inspired the people of Ahuzat Bayit, quoting a Jewish National Fund handbook from 1909: “[We seek] to constitute, in our own country, as soon as possible, not only an economic force, but a political one. There is no doubt that we will not be able to own the country if we do not own the land” (p. 62).
Chapter 4 forms the logical next step. LeVine delves into the Mandate period and dissects the way intercommunal relations in the “Jaffa-Tel Aviv region” developed. On 15 May 1936 the Mandate government gave permission for a separate port to be built in Tel-Aviv, which had become an autonomous local council in 1921. The goal of “settlement,” LeVine relates, citing Zionist sources, was to take “spaces that were inhabited or used by both communities and transform them into exclusively Jewish territory” (p. 104). Highlighting the binary opposites of the Zionist “discourse of erasion,” the author gives us Chaim Weizmann claiming that same year that the widening conflict represented the “forces of civilization” struggling against “the forces of barbarism and the desert” (p. 112). For “widening conflict” read the instances of intercommunal violence that increasingly marked the Mandatory period. LeVine's description of how the Royal Air Force “destroyed large swaths of Jaffa's Old City as retribution for the continued support of the [1936] strike by Jaffa's residents” brings to mind similar recent Israeli actions in the towns of Al-Khalil/Hebron and Nablus, especially when he adds that the idea was to “clear out wide new roads through the densely built Old City, which could then be more easily patrolled by British troops” (p. 112). LeVine ends this chapter by concluding that “it is in the colonial city, more than in other ‘modernist’ cities, that the inability to recognize and accept the past. . .leads to the desire to erase the existing human geography of the place—the ‘most othering moment of colonialism’” (p. 117).
Most readers will know in what “erasing the existing human geography” in 1940s Palestine resulted. LeVine puts their expectations on hold as he returns to his theme of “A Nation from the Sands” (Chapter 5), looking at images of Jaffa and Tel Aviv in literature, poetry, and prose, whose recurring themes and images he hopes will help us better understand “the motivations and strategies [of] leaders and ordinary citizens in their decades-long struggle to develop their city [both Jaffa and Tel Aviv] and to gain control over the land, water, and resources of the region” (p. 121). In Chapter 6 he elaborates further on town planning and architectural discourses, “a unique lens through which to investigate the unfolding relationship between the Zionist enterprise and the indigenous Arab population of Palestine” (p. 154). Dense on new detail, much of it felicitous, he nevertheless arrives at conclusions that by now sound familiar: “Jaffa had been engaged in a decades-long process of economic and cultural ‘modernization’ by the time Tel Aviv was founded” (p. 179) and “Tel Aviv possessed many of the characteristics of a colonial city. . . [the] goal [being] the physical separation of the newly arriving and the indigenous populations” (p. 180). In 2003, the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization declared the “White City” of Tel Aviv as a World Heritage Site for the way its concentration of International Style (Bauhaus) architecture represents a “synthesis of outstanding significance of the various trends of the Modern Movement. . .adapted to the requirements of a particular cultural and geographic context” (p. 152). What that context entailed LeVine spells out one more time when he writes, “Zionism, not having the burden of empire, never needed to ‘conquer the natives' hearts’; it needed to conquer the land and the economy, which is what ultimately transpired, not just in Jaffa, but throughout Palestine” (p. 181).
At one point in July 1936 Ben-Gurion wrote in his diary (quoted on p. 104), “I would welcome the destruction of Jaffa, Port and City. . . .This city, which grew fat from Jewish immigration and settlement, deserves to be destroyed for having waved an ax at those who built her and made her prosper. If Jaffa went to hell, I would not count myself among the mourners.” The destruction came on 13 May 1948, two days before the end of the Mandate. LeVine gives no details except to remark that the “surrender . . . followed the flight of all but 3,500 of the city's pre-war Palestinian Arab population of 70,000” (p. 215). By then the Zionist forces had already taken over Tiberias (18 April), Haifa (forcefully expelling the city's 74,000 indigenous Palestinian inhabitants within two days, from 21 to 22 April), Safad (1 May), West Jerusalem, Acre, and Beysan (the first week of May). In fact, before the end of the Mandate, the ethnic cleansing had engulfed 250,000 Palestinians whom Zionist forces drove from their homes and villages across the borders into Lebanon and Jordan. By October 1949, when the onslaught came to an end, another 500,000 people had been expelled, leaving barely 100,000 Palestinians within the borders the “Zionist enterprise” had succeeded in carving out for itself over close to 80 percent of Palestine. The “discourse of erasure” at work here is absent from LeVine's book. Instead we read, “[A] mortal weakening of Jaffa's public sphere with the flight of the city's bourgeois elite in late 1947 and early 1948 made inevitable [!] its conquest and takeover by Tel Aviv and the continuing inability of the Palestinian Arab community to engage in successful collective action” (p. 245). His final chapter simply skips ahead to the 1980s and 1990s and returns to the “symbolic and discursive functions of Tel Aviv and Jaffa within the Zionist enterprise” (p. 218). It is about the gentrification of what remains of Jaffa, exemplified by the so-called Andromeda Hill project—“We didn't use real stone. . .but rather a man-made material called GRC [fibreglass reinforced concrete], which is fake stone” (p. 232)—and by Peres's vision of how the “now-defunct Oslo process. . .would help bring the Palestinians, ‘a group who had never been a people,’ into the status of peoplehood at the dawn of globalization” (p. 236).
LeVine has written an engaging book about the economic and discursive roles architecture played in Jaffa during the years 1880–1948 and the overgrowing geography that turned it into Tel Aviv-Yafo. However, “overthrowing Jaffa” is not overthrowing Palestine, and as the Peres quote makes clear, a fairer subtitle would have been “Jaffa, Tel Aviv, and the Struggle for Israel.”
