Stuart Elden's The Early Foucault is the third offering in a planned series of four volumes on the work of Michel Foucault. Succeeding Elden's Foucault: The Birth of Power and Foucault's Last Decade in terms of publication order, the book's subject matter is chronologically first with respect to Foucault's life, tracing his earliest thought in the 1950s up until the publication of his first major book, History of Madness. The fourth volume will be published next year and will be concerned with Foucault's archaeological writings of the subsequent decade. The entire collection of four volumes will offer a summative study of the geneses and transformations of Foucault's thought. Elden's project on the whole is truly requisite for any serious scholar of Foucault.
Elden's methodology throughout all four volumes, and especially notable in this one, is a straight positivism. He is a digger in archives. He is a collector of facts. He is a collator of minute details, variations in dates on sheets of paper, nuances of manuscript revisions, and once-thought-lost material that has come to light by digging through the multiple archives where Foucault's unpublished writings are entombed.
While it has become fashionable in critical circles to treat “positivism” as something of an epithet, it cannot be lost on any reader of Foucault that a critic's disdain for “facts” comes at the cost of a theoretical idealism of which nobody would accuse Foucault himself. For Foucault's own work is surely expressive of a deft methodological combination of the critical attitude with a severe patience for the hard work of studying the facts. We can regard this methodological combination as lying in the background of all his luminescent flashes of brilliance: his theorization of the need to witness power in its multiple modalities, his overturning of the Freudo-Marxist dogma that our relationship to sexuality is one of repression when nearly all the facts around us speak otherwise, his interest in listening to what is actually said by patients at asylums and inmates at prisons as ineliminable dimensions of the discourse that is formed around the institutional imbrication of knowledge/power.
Elden's positivistic approach to Foucault is thus appropriate to its subject matter. Nevertheless, the critically informed reader will also pose questions concerning the interpretive schema that runs through Elden's exposition of the archival materials he offers. Just as we can recognize how Foucault brought a concern with power to his studies of psychiatry and criminology in the 1970s that culminated in Discipline and Punish, we can (and should) consider those concerns that Elden brings to his study of Foucault's work in the 1950s that led up to A History of Madness.
Consider one background interpretive consideration informing Elden's book. The Early Foucault furthers a long-standing interpretive theme of Elden's that goes back to his first book, Mapping the Present: Heidegger, Foucault and the Project of a Spatial History (Continuum, 2001). In The Early Foucault one gets the fullest sense of this from chapter 5, titled “Nietzsche and Heidegger” (109–25). And Heidegger is not just there. He is present throughout the book. The only two figures from the history of philosophy who are given five lines worth of page references in Elden's index are Nietzsche and Heidegger.
For instance, Heidegger deeply inflects Elden's discussion of Kant in chapter 7 (152–65). There Elden claims not only that “Foucault was reading Nietzsche through Heidegger,” but that “he was also reading Kant through Heidegger, with the 1929 book Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics appearing in French translation in 1953” (162). Elden reports that Heidegger's emphasis in that book is ontology, but he also acknowledges that Foucault's interest in Kant is “from a more historical perspective rather than a metaphysical one” (162). And when it comes to Foucault's uptake of Kant's project in anthropology, we are told that “Heidegger is a silent presence in Foucault's examination of this theme” (162).
Some readers will want more detail on why a silent presence deserves so much emphasis given all the overt presences that Foucault frequently cites: not only Kant, of course, but also Nietzsche, Deleuze, Canguilhem, and others. Elden, alongside Hubert Dreyfus, is a foremost expositor of what we might think of as the Heideggerian Foucault. But numerous other strains of Foucault scholarship are uneasy about an overemphasis on Heidegger's role in the genesis of Foucault's thought. Some scholars, for instance, favor setting Foucault's work in the light of the critical and anthropological projects of Kant. One advantage of emphasizing Foucault's Kantian inheritance, filtered of course through the transformed Kantianism of Nietzsche, is that it provides a way of understanding Foucault's distinctive methodological contributions. In Kant one can find a clear commitment to the work of philosophy as simultaneously critical and empirical, especially if one heeds Kant's decades of lectures and research on anthropology, culminating in his 1798 book Anthropology from a Pragmatic Point of View. This, of course, is the work by Kant that Foucault translated in the 1950s, and wrote a detailed introduction for, so that it ultimately served as his thèse complémentaire. Kant's anthropology sits in stark contrast to Heidegger's ontology. There is an old joke about Heidegger's concern with the ontological and disdain for the ontic: not only would Heidegger not touch the ontic level with a ten-foot pole, but indeed he would resent even having to touch the ten-foot pole itself. While this joke might be applied to numerous other philosophers, it would make no sense to try to foist it upon an empirically attentive philosopher like Foucault or the Kant of the Anthropology.
The Early Foucault closes at the publication of Foucault's History of Madness. This was the first major event in Foucault's philosophical career. For in it are laid bare not only the thematic consistencies that run throughout all of his subsequent books (psychology, criminology, the human sciences, sexuality, literature, resistance, and knowledge-power), but also that deft methodological combination (of theoretical insight and empirical care) for which his work remains a distinctive model for subsequent philosophy. What within Foucault's academic studies and scholarly research in the 1950s can help us understand how he arrived at such a combination?
It is with respect to this question concerning the genesis of what we can today recognize as “Foucault's methodology” that Elden's book is at its most insightful. Elden advances well beyond numerous previous biographies in his clear illumination of the depth of Foucault's simultaneous immersion in the study of theoretical philosophy and clinical psychology in the 1950s. Elden reminds us in chapter 3 that a survey of Foucault's actual publications from the 1950s shows that “most were on psychology” (53). Earlier, in chapter 2, Elden recounts in exquisite detail Foucault's devotion to his first teaching assignments in Lille (where he primarily taught courses in psychology) and his later work (as an unpaid research assistant) in various clinical settings involving the use of a wide range of psychological apparatus including EEGs, Rorschach tests, polygraphs, and of course patient dossiers. Elden also quotes Foucault looking back at his work at Paris's Hôpital Saint-Anne in the early 1950s from the distance of more than a quarter century: “It was there that the question was planted: What is medical power? What is the authority that permits it?” (49). That these questions, which by the time Foucault uttered them in 1981 had already become quintessentially Foucauldian, were formed while he split his time between empirical clinical settings and more theoretical philosophical texts is suggestive of the true breadth of Foucault's research pursuits and the extent of his field sites not only beyond the canon but even beyond the archival substacks in which he so often worked in later decades.
What is most valuable about this volume, and what makes it required reading for anyone hoping to understand Foucault going forward, is Elden's ability in locating that later Foucault of the 1960s through 1980s in the archival materials of the 1950s, a decade of which it can be truly said that a young Michel Foucault, itinerant from Paris to Lille to Sweden to Hamburg, had not quite yet become Foucault.
