This book, an outgrowth of a 2002 conference held at the University of California at Berkeley, takes as a given the importance of law as an operational concept in China. Rather, the fundamental questions for investigation are 1) how, when, and to whom law matters, and 2) how to study the relationship between law and society (p. 3). Traditionally, the study of Chinese law has been the preserve of legal specialists, predominantly lawyers, who have focused their attention on the institutional development of the Chinese legal system. This book takes an alternative approach in that it seeks to broaden the scope of investigation of Chinese legal issues. The contributors are primarily young scholars in the social sciences—notably political science and sociology—who report on their recent field research in China.
A major aim of the volume is to bring an interdisciplinary approach to the study of Chinese law, making use of insights and approaches derived from social science methodology, and broadening the range of inquiry to include the interaction between formal legal structures and Chinese society. To these ends, the book makes use of three concepts as overarching themes for inquiry. First, the volume addresses the means by which law is mobilized in China, and the extent to which Chinese citizens make use of legal structures to express interests and air grievances. Secondly, the book examines the extent to which a legal culture has evolved in China, especially with reference to the question of citizens' consciousness of their legally endowed rights. Thirdly, the book assesses the status of Chinese legal institutions, raising the question of the extent to which they function independently of political controls. It rejects the view, common to the traditional legal approach, of the state as an unitary actor for a perspective that disaggregates the state into a multitude of actors, operating at different levels, often with conflicting goals.
The book's contributors tackle a wide-ranging array of issues. Neil J. Diamant, Stanley B. Lubman, and Kevin J. O'Brien (Chapter 1) set out the theoretical approach and main themes of the volume in their introduction. O'Brien and Lianjiang Li (Chapter 2) examine administrative litigation in rural China; Mary E. Gallagher (Chapter 3) investigates the impact of the 1995 Labor Law on labor mobilization; Isabelle Thireau and Hua Linshan (Chapter 4) report on the expression of labor grievances in China through arbitration committees and letters and visits to offices; Mark E. Frazier (Chapter 5) looks at China's pension reform; Diamant (Chapter 6) discusses the struggles of veterans in the 1950s and 1960s; Andrew C. Mertha's (Chapter 7) research is on the role of foreign actors in the evolution of anticounterfeiting enforcement; Murray Scot Tanner (Chapter 8) assesses police analyses of social unrest; and Fu Hualing (Chapter 9) investigates the operation of a labor reeducation institution.
The research is of a uniformly high quality, and each chapter in itself contributes to the development of our knowledge about Chinese society and the operation of the Chinese political system. It cannot be said, however, that each chapter contributes equally to our specific understanding of the intersection between legal structures and Chinese society. It seems that the legal traditionalists, despite their myopic formalistic attention to legal structures independent of their impact on society, enjoy a certain advantage in defining their subject. In contrast, the broader, more ambitious approach of the social sciences means a certain diminution of clarity of focus and the blurring of conceptual boundaries, especially between legal and bureaucratic procedures. The linkages between law and society are most easily discerned in those chapters with an explicit legal focus; this includes O'Brien and Li's research on administrative litigation, and Gallagher's and Thireau and Hua's discussions of the relevance and application of the 1995 Labor Law. Frazier's chapter on pension reform, however, seems to fit equally well within the framework of public policy analysis. Diamant's discussion of veterans also poses a challenge; in the absence of any specific legislation relating to the treatment of veterans, he is compelled to make a sort of counterargument—unsusceptible to theoretical validation—that the passage of a “veterans' law” would have made a difference in ameliorating discriminatory treatment toward veterans. Whereas the case study approach used in many chapters yields valuable empirical information, it also raises the inevitable question of the extent to which conclusions can be generalized in a country as diverse and vast as China. One wonders, for example, if veterans in more provincial regions of China were treated with as much contempt as the veterans that Diamant describes in his case study encountered in Shanghai.
Some of the themes that emerge from this volume are addressed in the introduction, but others might have been summarized in a concluding chapter. It is apparent that the endeavor to establish legal structures serves an instrumental function for the Chinese Communist Party, providing a regularized outlet for the expression of discontent. The Chinese legal system has developed in incremental steps, in the face of tremendous challenges. Nonetheless, its steady institutionalization confirms the position of the legal formalists that the codification of law, even if imperfectly and partially implemented, is important. A number of contributors also emphasize the role of legal structures in providing a structural underpinning for a transition to a capitalist economy. Gallagher, in particular, argues that the specific provisions of the 1995 Labor Law and the implementation of a labor contract system have delegitimized the social contract of the Maoist era, and undercut workers' ability to file grievances through legal channels.
In summary, this book is a valuable contribution to research on contemporary China. It can and should be read by individuals with a specific interest in Chinese legal studies, as well as by those with a general interest in state–society relations in the Chinese context.
