Written by a well-known and respected team of authors, The Western Medical Tradition 1800 to 2000 certainly fulfils many of the promises of its title and mission statement: to describe key trends, events and people in the medical history of the last two centuries, and to explain how one system of medicine became a central part of global life – social, economic and political. The volume contains a useful thematic introduction (written by Hal Cook) and four substantial chapters, each covering roughly fifty years and following fairly standard periodization for the history of medicine. Each chapter examines medical institutions, medical education, the processes and effects of professionalization in medicine, medical knowledge and knowledge production, and interactions between medicine and the state, and also between doctors and patients. All are to a greater or lesser degree comparative, addressing continuities and differences in the ‘Western medical tradition’ as it developed in North America and western Europe. Britain provides the bulk of exemplary material (just), but aspects of medicine in France, Germany and the United States are well addressed, and other nations and regions also appear, including the Soviet Union and, in snippets and broad overviews, Canada, China, Japan, Australia and a handful of African and South American nations. It would be easy to quibble about this; in the last twenty years scholars in a variety of fields, including the history of medicine, have clearly sketched out the reciprocal and enduring relationship between medicine in the ‘West’ and medicine around the globe. But no volume, however compendious, could treat every aspect of a field this broad with equal attention. Every chapter is supported by a bibliographic essay. Generally these do a fine job of pointing out the canonical texts in the field and highlighting some less-familiar gems; Hardy and Tansey commendably cross disciplinary boundaries to incorporate some sources from medical anthropology. Inevitably, many newer works are left out, particularly in relation to twentieth-century US medicine and Western medicine in the non-Western world. Combined with the complete absence of footnotes, this will hamper non-expert readers and students wishing to explore in greater detail those topics (and regions) that are necessarily covered only in passing in the main text.
Despite sharing much, the chapters differ substantially from each other. Understandably, changes in the nature and historiography of medicine, as well as the specific interests of the authors, produce noticeable differences in the thematic content covered in each chapter. More problematic are significant shifts of tone and expected audience between chapters. Notably, Stephen Jacyna's chapter, the volume's first, is rather a different kettle of fish from those that follow it. While the historiographical argument which dominates ‘Medicine in transformation, 1800–1849’ repays the attention of a specialist reader, I am less certain of its value to a general readership. This chapter will benefit new lecturers far more than their students. Its very brief bibliography only accentuates the problem. Under these circumstances, it is perhaps useful that the subsequent Bynum chapter substantially overlaps with Jacyna's. Elsewhere, however, the volume would have been strengthened by a firmer editorial hand eliminating repetition and maintaining consistency between the chapters.
Nonetheless, as well as the expected useful overview, painted in the expected broad strokes, there are delightful surprises to be had in this book: Jacyna's interesting observations about the Sanitarians and about scientific medicine's demands for new social forms among its practitioners, Bynum's skilful use of career sketches to explore ‘The rise of science in medicine, 1850–1913’, excellent sections on Soviet and Rockefeller medicine in Lawrence's chapter ‘Continuity in crisis, 1914–1945’, and not one but two perspectives on the WHO in Hardy and Tansey's ‘Medical enterprise and global response, 1945–2000’. The chronological tables, though undoubtedly valuable to students and teachers alike, are sometimes wilfully quirky, particularly in their coverage of events contemporaneous with medical developments. Should we really get three references to the Beatles, but not one to the enfranchisement of women, for instance? And a date for the introduction of ‘the Pill’ would not have gone amiss either (although it is given in the body text). Then again, while The Western Medical Tradition 1800 to 2000 notes the history of women and of female bodies in medicine, it does not really address the role of either gender or race in the Western medical tradition (class comes off significantly better). These omissions, along with the near-total absence of other topics, sometimes make the book feel a bit old-fashioned. For example, neither alternative medicine/self-help traditions nor patient activism get much attention in any chapter. Recent work by scholars in the history and social studies of science and technology could have added much.
Given Western medicine's dizzying variety and transformative impact in the last two hundred years, the authors set themselves a huge task in preparing an overview. In The Western Medical Tradition 1800 to 2000 they have made a substantial contribution to the field, not least by flagging up areas newly of interest to historians of medicine and to medicine itself. The new medical internationalism and the roles of the environment and the media are just three such areas among many. Hardy and Tansey's chapter will undoubtedly be a first port of call for scholars moving into the history of post-war medicine, and the volume as a whole will be invaluable, particularly to teachers of the history of science, technology and medicine. In many ways, the greatest virtue of this volume lies in the fact that it points the way ahead, through its weaknesses as much as its strengths. Clearly, the history of medicine in the twentieth century must incorporate (as this volume begins to do) resources from the social studies of science and technology, medical sociology and medical anthropology. Equally, it demands a thoroughly global, as well as interdisciplinary, approach.
