Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T02:04:23.181Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Phoretic self-propulsion of helical active particles

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 October 2021

Ruben Poehnl
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Hawai'i at Mānoa, 2540 Dole St., Holmes Hall 302, Honolulu, HI 96822, USA
William Uspal*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Hawai'i at Mānoa, 2540 Dole St., Holmes Hall 302, Honolulu, HI 96822, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: uspal@hawaii.edu

Abstract

Chemically active colloids self-propel by catalysing the decomposition of molecular ‘fuel’ available in the surrounding solution. If the various molecular species involved in the reaction have distinct interactions with the colloid surface, and if the colloid has some intrinsic asymmetry in its surface chemistry or geometry, there will be phoretic flows in an interfacial layer surrounding the particle, leading to directed motion. Most studies of chemically active colloids have focused on spherical, axisymmetric ‘Janus’ particles, which (in the bulk, and in absence of fluctuations) simply move in a straight line. For particles with a complex (non-spherical and non-axisymmetric) geometry, the dynamics can be much richer. Here, we consider chemically active helices. Via numerical calculations and slender body theory, we study how the translational and rotational velocities of the particle depend on geometry and the distribution of catalytic activity over the particle surface. We confirm the recent finding of Katsamba et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 898, 2020, p. A24) that both tangential and circumferential concentration gradients contribute to the particle velocity. The relative importance of these contributions has a strong impact on the motion of the particle. We show that, by a judicious choice of the particle design parameters, one can suppress components of angular velocity that are perpendicular to the screw axis, or even select for purely ‘sideways’ translation of the helix.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic illustration of the particle geometry. The particle consists of a solid ‘tube’ with a helical contour and circular cross-section, plus two solid hemispherical endcaps. Here, we label the contour radius $R$, the helix pitch $\lambda$, the tube radius $r_0$, the local tangent vector $\hat {\boldsymbol {t}}_h$, the local surface normal $\hat {\boldsymbol {n}}_h$ and the local surface binormal $\hat {\boldsymbol {b}}_h$. For a given point on the tube centreline, the angle $\phi$ defines a point on the tube surface. In this example, the particle has a ‘lengthwise Janus’ catalytic activity profile.

Figure 1

Table 1.Boundary conditions for the auxiliary problem $(j)$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Close-up of a meshed interface for a lengthwise Janus particle under conditions of numerical convergence. The red points represent catalytically active nodes of the mesh, while the green points represent inert nodes. The area elements of the mesh are coloured by interpolation from the surrounding nodes; blue represents inert and yellow represents active.

Figure 3

Figure 3.(a) Schematic illustration of three helices with different values of pitch $\lambda$, but identical contour length $\mathcal {L}/L_0 = 57.5$, contour radius $R/L_0 = 2.5$ and filament radius $r_0/L_0 = 0.265$. (b) Variation of ${\mathsf{R}}_{33}$, the dimensionless drag coefficient for translational motion along the axis, with $\lambda$. Black circles were obtained with the boundary element method, and red circles were obtained by the SBT described in Koens & Lauga (2014). (c) Variation of the translational–rotational coupling coefficient ${\mathsf{R}}_{63}$ with $\lambda$. Note that ${\mathsf{R}}_{63} = {\mathsf{R}}_{36}$. (d) Variation of ${\mathsf{R}}_{66}$, the dimensionless rotational drag coefficient for rotation around the helix axis, as a function of $\lambda$.

Figure 4

Table 2.Experimental measurements from Purcell (1997), rescaled to be dimensionless for comparison with our BEM results in table 4.

Figure 5

Table 3.Numerical calculations from Cortez et al. (2005), rescaled to be dimensionless for comparison with our BEM results in table 4.

Figure 6

Table 4.Results of BEM numerical calculations for resistance matrix of a helix. Per cent error is calculated with respect to the numerical data of Cortez et al. (2005).

Figure 7

Figure 4.(a) Concentration with respect to the tangential position $s$ for $\lambda /L_0 = 5$ and other parameters the same as in figure. 3. The shaded grey area shows the range of values that were obtained for $c$ for a given $s$ and various circumferential angles $\phi$ (individual data points are omitted for clarity). The solid curve is a theoretical expression for the circumferentially averaged concentration obtained with SBT. The inset shows the definition of the angle $\phi$ with respect to the local $\hat {\boldsymbol {n}}_h$ at a position $s$ along the centreline, as well as decomposition of the surface concentration gradient $\nabla _s c$ into tangential and circumferential (i.e. in the plane of the helix cross-section at $s$) components. (b) Three-dimensional plot of the concentration $c$ on the surface of the particle. (c) Variation of concentration $c$ as a function of circumferential angle $\phi$ for various values of $s$. The dashed line indicates $\phi = -{\rm \pi} /2$. (d) Schematic illustration of the modification of the SBT to obtain the circumferential variation of concentration around the cross-section at $s$. To obtain the solid curves in (c), it is assumed that the local concentration gradient created by the rest of the particle induces a dipolar variation of concentration on the filament surface with respect to $\phi$. In (c), the values of $s$ are as follows: black circles, $s = -0.95$; blue circles, $s = -0.65$; red circles, $s = -0.15$; magenta diamonds, $s = -0.02$; blue diamonds, $s = 0$; magenta crosses, $s = 0.05$; black crosses, $s = 0.15$; red crosses, $s = 0.35$; blue crosses, $s = 0.65$; green crosses, $s = 0.85$.

Figure 8

Figure 5.(a) Components of the translational velocity $\boldsymbol {U}$ of a lengthwise Janus particle as a function of pitch $\lambda$ and parameters $r$, $\mathcal {L}$ and $R$ the same as in figure 3. In the main figure, the dashed line shows the value of $U_z$ for a spheroidal particle with major axis diameter $\mathcal {L}$ and minor axis diameter $2r$, as determined from Ibrahim, Golestanian & Liverpool (2018). The green curve shows a stretched exponential fit to $U_z$. In the inset, the dashed lines indicate values of $\lambda$ for which the number of turns is a half-integer. (b) Components of the angular velocity $\boldsymbol {\varOmega }$ of a lengthwise Janus particle as a function of pitch $\lambda$ and other parameters the same as in figure 3. The inset shows the peak in $\varOmega _z$. (c) The contributions of circumferential and tangential concentration gradients to $U_z$ as a function of $\lambda$. (d) The contributions of circumferential and tangential concentration gradients to $\varOmega _z$ as a function of $\lambda$.

Figure 9

Figure 6.Streamlines (obtained in the stationary frame) of flow in the vicinity of a helix with (a) large pitch ($\lambda /L_0 = 60$) and (b) small pitch ($\lambda /L_0 = 5$).

Figure 10

Figure 7.(a) Off-diagonal entries of the third row of the mobility tensor ${\boldsymbol{\mathsf{M}}}$ as a function of pitch $\lambda$, and other parameters as given in figure 3. (b) Mobility tensor component ${\mathsf{M}}_{33}$ as a function of pitch $\lambda$. Note the difference in scale from (a); the diagonal entry dominates the third row of ${\boldsymbol{\mathsf{M}}}$. (c) Translational velocity component along the helix axis $U_z$ for a lengthwise Janus activity profile as a function of pitch (all other parameters are the same as in figure 5). The full calculation that takes into account all components of ${\boldsymbol{\mathsf{M}}}$ and the right-hand side vector $\boldsymbol {b}$ shows good agreement with an approximate solution obtained as $b_3/80F_0$, where ${6 {\rm \pi}}/80$ is chosen as a characteristic value of the ‘flat’ part of the curve in (b). (d) Components of the right-hand side vector $\boldsymbol {b}$ as a function of pitch $\lambda$ for the lengthwise Janus particle.

Figure 11

Figure 8.(a) Dimensionless catalytic activity $j(\boldsymbol {x}_s)$ on the surface of a $z$-wise Janus particle with $\lambda /L_0 = 5$ and parameters $r$, $\mathcal {L}$ and $R$ the same as in figure 3. (b) Three-dimensional plot of the concentration $c$ on the surface of the particle. (c) Concentration with respect to the tangential position $s$. The shaded grey area shows the range of values that were obtained for $c$ for a given $s$ and various circumferential angles $\phi$ (not shown). The solid curve is a theoretical expression for the circumferentially averaged concentration obtained with SBT.

Figure 12

Figure 9.(a) Components of the translational velocity $\boldsymbol {U}$ of a $z$-wise Janus particle as a function of pitch $\lambda$, with parameters $r$, $\mathcal {L}$ and $R$ the same as in figure 3. (b) Components of the angular velocity $\boldsymbol {\varOmega }$. (c) The $z$-component $U_z$ of the particle translational velocity as a function of pitch, as well as the contributions of circumferential and tangential concentration gradients to $U_z$. (d) The $z$-component $\varOmega _z$ of the particle angular velocity as a function of pitch, as well as the contributions of circumferential and tangential concentration gradients.

Figure 13

Figure 10.(a) Concentration with respect to the tangential position $s$ for an ‘inside–outside’ Janus helix. The shaded grey area shows the range of values that were obtained for $c$ for a given $s$ and various circumferential angles $\phi$ (not shown), and the blue line shows the mean value as a function of $s$. The solid curve is a theoretical expression for the circumferentially averaged concentration obtained with SBT. (b) Variation of concentration $c$ as a function of circumferential angle $\phi$ for various values of $s$. The values of $s$ are as follows: blue circles, $s = -0.85$; blue crosses, $s = 0.85$; red circles, $s = -0.65$; red crosses, $s = 0.65$; green circles, $s = -0.35$; green crosses, $s = 0.35$; black diamonds, $s = 0$.

Figure 14

Figure 11.(a) Three-dimensional plot of the concentration $c$ on the surface of the ‘inside–outside’ Janus helix. (b) Components of the transitional velocity $\boldsymbol {U}$ as a function of the number of turns $N$ and pitch $\lambda /L_0 = 5$, contour radius $R/L_0=2.5$ and filament radius $r_0/L_0 = 0.265$. (c) Components of the and angular velocity $\boldsymbol {\varOmega }$ as a function of the number of turns $N$.