Martin Bucer ‘between’ Luther and Zwingli − or ‘alongside’, or ‘in contrast to’, or ‘beyond’? That is the perpetual prepositional question in pondering the relationship between Bucer and the two primary reformers. The task is not easy since the relationship was never static as Bucer, the Strasbourg reformer, was (or became) relatively more flexible and elastic than the others. Hence, older historiography portrays him at best as an idiosyncratic ‘mediator’, a half-way house figure between Luther and Zwingli, at worst as deviating from the poles represented by the other two and so aberrant and ‘sub’-normative. Modern research has, however, argued for a relatively distinctive and autonomous theological stance. This was not so much a ‘middle way’ (whether between Lutherans and Zwinglians, or between Catholics and Protestants), as an alternative ‘third way’. Bucer acknowledged the prophetic priority of Luther and Zwingli, and eventually acknowledged elements of authenticity in Catholic tradition – but for him the question became ‘Where do we go from here, and how?’ if the rift in the Church, provisional in his view, was not to endure. Bucer therefore evolved as a theologian of ‘unity’ (in diversity), theological, ecclesial and ecclesiastical – in a manner alien to both Lutherans and Zwinglians. For them, confessional or dogmatic affirmation had precedence over notions of interim concord and fellowship, which Bucer envisaged as a prerequisite for eventual reintegration.
The book's eight studies give a flavour of this tantalising Bucer. The co-editors represent two of the locations for the modern textual editing of Bucer's writings, namely Strasbourg and Erlangen (the others have been Münster and Heidelberg). This nexus relates to the continuing edition of Bucer's correspondence, notably volumes 4 (2000) and 5 (2004), following volumes 1–3 published by Jean Rott in 1979−89. This collection focuses on volume 4, covering most of 1530. This year represents a turning point in his development from being an irenical churchman to a negotiator seeking substantive theological agreement. Initially this referred to Protestant sacramental discord. Bucer's early sympathies were with the Zwinglians but, following a Luther tract in 1528 on the subject, he came to believe that things were clarified in a way offering the prospect of resolution. However, his experience at the Diet of Augsburg in 1530 helped concentrate his mind even more. There, both the Augsburg Confession and the alternative south German Tetrapolitan Confession were rejected. Not only that, Bucer was cold-shouldered by the Lutherans, though his persistence resulted in potentially positive contact with Melanchthon. This initiated a six-year process climaxing in 1536 with the formal restoration of communion with the Lutherans.
During this process, in 1533–4, Bucer's outreach began to extend to the Catholics as part of a larger vision of general reintegration. Accordingly, a study in this book by Volkmar Ortmann deals with Bucer's ‘Endeavours for Reformation and Church Unity at the Religious Colloquies 1540/41’. He saw these as the continuation of business aborted at the Augsburg Diet of 1530, and so provided further opportunity. These did yield advances, but no wider acceptance. Ortmann underlines that Bucer's motivation was grounded not just in church politics, pragmatic toleration, formulaic accommodation and compromise (faced with the threat of military coercion), but also in the conviction that in all churches a vital precondition was already at hand, and on which he (vainly) pinned his hopes. This was the dispersed existence of Christians of ‘good will’ who are ‘searching for the truth’ − by a third way, so to speak. Generally, Bucer's advocacy of goodness and higher truth transcending dogmatic formulae did not gain significant support.
Another important article in the book has bearing on this, by Berndt Hamm on Bucer's thinking on ‘Toleration and Heresy’, with particular reference to the dedication of his Gospels Commentary to the Marburg Academy in 1530. The context is Bucer's concern with inner-Protestant solidarity despite diversity, grounded in Christian fellowship. This challenges the Lutheran (and Catholic) antimony between doctrine and love, which held that, when doctrine is adjudged to be wrong and so erroneous or heretical, love to its adherents is cancelled. Bucer develops a concept in which love is paramount, holding that true doctrine is defective if it is detached from true love, in attitude and in practice. The quasi-Erasmian flavour of this is acknowledged, but Bucer advances beyond this, since he stresses an un-Erasmian ‘seeking for truth’. His willingness to parley with Lutherans, Anabaptists and Catholics in a non-adversarial manner is explicable in this light. And Roland Liebenberg's study on the linkage in Bucer's mind between commitment to unity among Reformation churches (at least) and the honour of Christ as the expression of a theology of (Christian) love adds to the understanding of his overall motivation. Generally, however, research remains to be done on Bucer's epistemological preconceptions as a key to his mind.
The other essays reflect further key themes in Bucer's correspondence of 1530. Two deal with his eucharistic theology: Reinhold Friedrich examines the reformer's notion that much of the controversy was peculiarly semantic, and Annie Noblesse-Rocher probes the medieval and scholastic imprints in Bucer's approach – not just relics, but positively functioning elements derived from his early via antiqua background. Matthieu Arnold compares and contrasts the views of Luther and Bucer on the intersection between human, personal history and divine providence in relation to the Ausgburg Diet. Andreas Puchta then analyses Bucer's attitude to images, and confirms that his opposition to them was based not on seeing them as ‘idolatry’, but on pastoral concerns about their popular abuse. The last essay by Nicole de Laharpe is on the Bucer-image in Luther's Table Talk.
While one might have looked for more on Bucer's relationship to Zwingli in this book, the studies give a welcome, high-quality boost to strongly source-based Bucer research. They remind us that many layers in the ‘Reformation’ still need to be excavated and explained.
