Standard forms of publication work well for many topics and materials, while others are better suited for museum exhibits or other modes of presentation. Here we have an exhibition published online, openly accessible and luring us in with striking images. This is just the sort of approach we need to add to the history of science, and this exhibit does the job well, introducing us to substantive discussion but not inundating us with too much text.
The collection focuses around eight sections corresponding to stages of development – development of embryos but also of our understanding. These overlapping stages include ‘Unborn’ (1300–1800s), ‘Development’ (1770–1800), ‘Learning’ (1800–1860), ‘Evolution’ (1860–1930), ‘Remodelling’ (1870s–1910), ‘Standards’ (1900–1960s), ‘Monitoring’ (1900–1980s) and ‘Intervention’ (1960s–2000s). Each includes pictures that helped make embryos visible, with short descriptions and a bit of contextualization to help with interpretation. The list of resources provides further research material. The organization makes sense, and the illustrations are instructive.
For a general audience, this exhibit offers a useful introduction, and the resources section points to selected publications (just a few among many on the topic). Yet this collection remains very much a standard exhibition, of high quality but relatively static. It does not take advantage of the Internet's capabilities for linking to other materials or even for leading the viewer more easily to see how themes fit together. The result is more a series of snapshots than an essay or narrative. That is fine, as a start, but the relatively narrow scope of the project limits the potential broader impact.
For example, in the section on ‘Development’ there are just five entries: ‘Introduction’, ‘A blind spot in anatomical images’, ‘Temporalizing pregnancy’, ‘Collecting embryos’ and ‘Picturing development’. They centre on just a few images, mostly related to the German anatomist Samuel Thomas Soemmerring (1755–1830). These are wonderful pictures, which show the process of acquiring information as well as presenting it to the public. The selection might suggest that this was the only, the most important, or in some way the most representative work. Yet we do not get a sense of whether that might be the case, and if so what it might mean, and the exhibit does not include the selection criteria used to determine what is included or not – and why.
It also remains unclear just who the target audience is. There are enticing pictures and brief textual descriptions, but that may not be enough for the general audience that might be attracted to the pictures. The material is quite familiar and accessible to scholars in the history of embryology, though it is nice now to have the pieces all in the same place. Perhaps the greatest interest will come from scholars who are not familiar with the history of embryology and who are attracted to studies of development because of so much recent emphasis on that topic. There is a little something for everyone, even if we wish for more.
The collection draws on Nick Hopwood's publications, and makes available to a wider audience some of the scientific practices and images introduced in those works. Not surprisingly, this makes the result somewhat idiosyncratic, so that we learn more about controversies surrounding Ernst Haeckel's use of comparative embryology than we might expect in an exhibition that is said on the home page to be about human embryos.
Despite some observations about possible improvements, I support the innovative approach of this collection. It is hard work to put together even a simple-seeming collection of images, and the result is a service for the rest of us. We can hope that this is just the beginning. The Embryo Project Encyclopedia, which I direct, provides another way of working through a relational dynamic database, to which the exhibition refers (http://embryo.asu.edu). Together, drawing on multiple different approaches, we can expand the materials available to anybody, anywhere. We can juxtapose images, texts and interpretations. We can pool our limited resources and develop rich collections. Ideally, we will make materials openly available rather than protected behind closed doors – but that is not always possible, as this exhibit acknowledges.
This exhibit shows us what is possible now, and we can begin to imagine what even greater advantages could accrue as we grow and connect such projects through federated searching strategies and shared ontologies. Such projects are under way, and this is a fine introduction to what is possible. It seems to have attracted positive attention from bloggers and viewers, and it is a virtue when others are brought to the history of science to learn of the rich materials and perspectives we find there. I therefore applaud Tatjana Buklijas and Nick Hopwood for providing a valuable starting point for the digital dissemination of knowledge about embryos.
