Finding something new to say about Peter Brown is tricky. His work has been the subject of a number of edited collections and retrospectives, with a particular focus on two of his most influential contributions: the invention of Late Antiquity as a period in Anglophone historiography, and the ever finer examination of the role played by the cult of saints in those late ancient societies. Moreover, as Ian Wood notes (in his contribution to the volume under review), Brown himself has been an expert exegete of his earlier work, drawing out its context and significance and offering carefully weighed correctives (18). Motions of Late Antiquity adds to these reflections by shifting focus to Brown's more recent interventions. It provides a series of studies by colleagues and former graduate students — predominantly from his time at Berkeley and Princeton — which take as their inspiration his work on conceptions of the body, the representation of power, the formation of Latin Christendom, discourses of wealth and poverty, the social location of monasticism, the fall of the Western Empire and Syriac Christianity. Originally delivered at a conference to mark Brown's last graduate seminar at Princeton in 2011, these papers largely occupy what was once marginal territory for ancient historians: the furthest eastern and western regions of the Roman world from the fifth to ninth centuries c.e. They stake a claim — implicitly, but no less insistently — for the continued validity of Brown's vision of late ancient western Eurasia as a cultural whole.
The introduction by the editors, Jamie Kreiner and Helmut Reimitz (ch. 1), engages with (though never explicitly references) the discontent expressed with this ‘long’ Late Antiquity amid the resurgence of the fall of Rome as a historiographical paradigm. K. and R. seek to move beyond this debate by suggesting that tensions between coherence and multiplicity are inherent in all historical periods. They find in Brown's work a more complex approach to historical change in the third to eighth centuries than is often allowed by his critics: the ‘strangeness to each other of seemingly contiguous epochs’, in Brown's own words (4). They also highlight Brown's desire to understand the worldviews of late ancient people (7). As a defence of a longue durée late ancient cultural history, this introduction is concise and elegant. At the same time, though, the editors’ suggested hermeneutic term for this methodology, ‘the late antique approach’ (7–9, 14–15), has to convey too many different features through its shorthand to really be useful.
The first two papers, by Ian Wood (ch. 2) and Walter Pohl (ch. 3), revisit under-appreciated aspects of Brown's work. Wood's paper begins with an erudite excursus surveying late twentieth-century historiography and academic prosopography to recapture the novelty of landmarks from The World of Late Antiquity (1971) onwards. Wood calls for a greater integration of the ‘religious’ and ‘political’ history of the early medieval West along the lines of Brown's own Totalgeschichte (21, 24), using the Grimoald coup in seventh-century Francia as a neat case study. While agreeing with the sentiment, I would suggest this synthesis is already second nature for many historians of the period. Pohl, meanwhile, tries to hit reset on the (now somewhat tedious) debates about the ‘transformation’ (or decline and fall?) of the Roman world by highlighting areas of Brown's The Rise of Western Christendom (rev. edn 2003) which could facilitate a paradigm shift. Pohl neatly historicises ‘transformation’, which he sees as stemming from a tradition of post-War structural history; like K. and R., he advocates a turn back from these structures to the agency of late ancient human beings.
The interplay of individual and (religious) community is the central theme of several papers in the collection. The outstanding example is Philippa Townsend's reinterpretation of Manichaean community formation (ch. 4) in dialogue with The Body and Society (1988). By delineating Manichaean ritual praxis and thought about the body of an individual adherent, Townsend persuasively suggests that Manichaean communities were not (at least intended) to be closed off from the world (as has often been assumed, in analogy with more straightforwardly Christian ‘sects’). Jaclyn Maxwell (ch. 5) highlights a different form of openness: the varied strata of late Roman society mixing together in the monastery of Hypatius near Chalcedon. Maxwell uses Callinicus’ Life of Hypatius to track the ambivalent attitudes towards social integration present in the community: at once levelling and marking hierarchies. Volker Menze (ch. 12) analyses a much more closed group: the monastic community of the fifth-century non-Chalcedonian firebrand Barsauma. Menze reconsiders the Life of Barsauma, zooming in on its account of a fictive Jewish ‘reconquest’ of Jerusalem under the empress Eudocia. Menze relocates this (obviously ahistorical) text to the decades after Barsauma's death, interpreting its repeated accounts of violence as an attempt to craft a defiantly outsider identity for monks proscribed in a Chalcedonian empire.
Daniel Schwartz (ch. 7) similarly treats the relationship of violence and religious identity in the late antique East, considering the sixth-century Syriac bishop Jacob of Sarug's sermon On the Fall of the Idols, often taken as supportive of the destruction of pagan cult sites. Schwartz shows how the text's description of a humble Christ's largely passive role in a cosmic eradication of satanic temples actually fed a different Christianising agenda: the encouragement of charity and individual moral transformation. Yannis Papadoyannakis (ch. 13) comes at parallel issues of personal reform and Christian subjectivity through the Quaestiones et responsiones of the seventh-century monk and troubleshooter, Anastasius of Sinai. Papadoyannakis argues that the high emotional tenor of the questions, and Anastasius’ patient and empathetic responses, bring us close to the lived experience of Christians in an era of unsettling social and political change.
Implicit in all of these papers (as in much of Brown's work) is a desire to feel the texture of late ancient life under the smooth rhetorical surface of literary texts. Such a project is the explicit motivation for Ariel López's chapter (ch. 10), which presents a series of elegant conjectures connecting the monastic literature of Egypt to the unparalleled evidence for everyday life in the region. López suggests that the miraculous meals which monasteries served up at Easter were an annual response to dearth at the end of the agricultural cycle; that monastic deaths during and after Easter show seasonal mortality associated with the Khamsin wind; and that monastic travel during the Nile flood represented wider patterns of river transport. Similar problems of literary representation attend the accounts of Roman and Persian imperial adoption and guardianship treated by Michael Maas (ch. 9). From three episodes in Procopius’ History of the Wars, Maas essays a first step beyond ethnographic tropes to ‘a complex story of the emergence of a medieval Byzantine view of cultural difference and imperial power’ (184).
Staying on the Eastern frontiers, papers by David A. Michelson and Jack Tannous highlight the crucial impetus which Brown has provided to the study of Syriac. Michelson (ch. 8) considers the influence of Basil of Caesarea on the early sixth-century Miaphysite author Philoxenos of Mabbug, as against earlier problematic views of the detachment of ‘Oriental’ Miaphysites from Greek and Latin traditions. In his chapter, Tannous (ch. 15) provides a summary and critical evaluation of the unedited Life of Symeon of the Olives, an eighth-century Syrian saint. This ‘tantalising’ text of early Islamic Mesopotamia survives in nineteenth-century manuscripts and is riddled with later interpolations. Through careful disentangling of its relationship with a ninth-century Christian-Muslim dialogue text, Tannous pulls out the likely features of the earliest version of the Life.
Papers on the Latin West likewise push far on into the post-Roman period. Damien Fernandez (ch. 6) re-examines an inscription from Merida in 484 which commemorated the reconstruction of the bridge and walls by a dux of the Visigothic king Euric at the behest of the city's bishop. Using parallel themes in the Gallo-Roman bishop Sidonius Apollinaris’ addresses to Euric as a sort of ‘control’, Fernandez suggests that the language of patronage and protection in the inscribed text reflects not only civic but also royal self-presentation in the murky first post-Roman century in Iberia. Philip Rousseau (ch. 11) takes the opportunity to luxuriate in the rich character portraits and carefully presented vignettes of Gregory of Tours’ Histories. Rousseau argues that Gregory uses the same narrative techniques to stage two very different confrontations of the old and the new: Christian conversion and the articulation of Frankish governance. Through shifts of perspective and dramatic irony, Gregory sought to induce his audiences in late sixth-century Gaul to careful reflection upon both.
Papers by Stefan Esders and Janet Nelson engage with two aspects of Brown's take on the formation of a distinctly Latin Christendom in the Frankish world. Esders (ch. 14) rethinks the origins of missionary activity in northern Gaul in the seventh century. Drawing on his wider work on the Mediterranean context of Merovingian rule, Esders traces the influence of Eastern imperial models of enforced conversion on Frankish bishops. Finally, Nelson (ch. 16) revisits (in fittingly Brownian style) her own pivotal work on the (so-called) Carolingian Renaissance in the light of recent work on proprietary churches and the use of Roman and post-Roman law in the ninth century. Taking her cue from the anthropologist Jack Goody's comparative work, Renaissances (2011), Nelson sees the potential for a new understanding of the creative use of canonical Christian and Roman legal material by Carolingian intellectuals like Hincmar of Rheims: ‘old texts were for looking back to, and also for making and mapping bursts forward’ (341).
Whether a figure like Hincmar belongs in Late Antiquity — or, for that matter, in the same world as Mani or the Persian ruler Yazdigerd — is perhaps a question for a different journal. It certainly takes a very long Late Antiquity (and one invested with a particular organising genius) to hold all of these contexts and protagonists together. But, such questions of periodisation aside, what these papers demonstrate, above all, are the fruits of the sort of rigorous cultural history which Peter Brown has practised throughout his career (and has clearly instilled in his students). This approach (‘late antique’ or not) uses often obscure texts to open up the horizons of late ancient and early medieval people: whether they are travellers on the Nile, farmers on the Bosphorus or lawyers in Aachen. In that sense, Janet Nelson's chapter provides a fitting ending. Nelson recalls Brown's inaugural at Royal Holloway in 1977 and his invocation to his audience ‘to imagine with greater precision what it's like to be human in situations very different from our own’ (343). That humane historical imagination runs through this collection. It is a testament to Peter Brown's continuing influence on our discipline.
