Despite the canonical dominance of European traditions in theatre history, the variety of performance practices that occurred during the Middle Ages—that thousand-year period between the fall of Rome and the era of Shakespeare—remains little known and less understood. For this reason, the essays curated by Philip Butterworth and Katie Normington in Medieval Theatre Performance: Actors, Dancers, Automata, and Their Audiences mark an important contribution not only to the scholarship of early performance but also—and especially—to our field at large.
In their brief introduction, Butterworth and Normington note that Medieval Theatre Performance emerged out of a particular challenge: the problem of addressing not the contexts of past performances but “performance itself” (1). This challenge will be recognizable to scholars of performance across divisions of geography, culture, and time. What “performance” means in this collection is various, and the editors observe that “the separation of the disciplines of theatre/dance/puppetry/automata is a fabricated one” (3). Only a quarter of the chapters focus on theatricality within dramatic forms; the rest consider primarily genres that involve dance, built spectacle, puppetry, automata, or some other form of bodily representation or presentation that confounds definition. The essays incorporate innovative methodologies and respond to theories of theatre and performance from Richard Schechner to Carrie Noland. Furthermore, the performances examined are not likely to be well known to most readers. Some highlights include an account of the late medieval frenzy of continental dance epidemics, a collective silent and naked miming of the Crucifixion in a Welsh monastery, and a semiautomaton Christ who/that can move his/its lips and eyes, perhaps while the parish priest speaks next to him/it.
Many of the essays contemplate problems of archive and repertoire. The late Claire Sponsler, to whom the collection is dedicated, revisits material from her 2014 monograph and reformulates it into a stand-alone essay, “From Archive to Repertoire: The Disguising at Hertford and Performance Practices.” Though focused on a particular English court performance, Sponsler considers broadly “the impact of both the problem of evidence and the problem of methodology” for interpreting past performances, including textual remains, similar performances, and practice-based research (21). Do not be surprised if this essay becomes a syllabus staple for graduate methodology and historiography courses. Other chapters also grapple with what may have been supplied by social, cultural, religious, and/or theatrical custom but is absent in the evidence. David N. Klausner investigates English, Welsh, and Irish records in which “drama without text or action … may be the most likely explanation of some situations that seem otherwise puzzling or inexplicable,” such as the case of the naked, miming cruciform monks (107). Tom Pettitt formulates a theatrical idea of intertextuality, which he terms “interaxionality” (53), in order to recover the meaning of the “intrusion of visit customs into medieval English plays” (57), from those that explicitly represent the formal custom to those that present it more as presentational gaming. Both Bart Ramakers and Femke Kramer address quandaries arising from the growth of detailed stage directions in the Netherlandish Rhetoricians’ plays, the “equivalent of the sixteenth-century moral play” (35). Ramakers foregrounds the genre's theatricality by attending to the Pausa—the interlude between scenes—as well as “the visually entertaining actions of the dress-change, the banquet scene, the bedroom scene and the scene of trial and retribution” (51). Kramer addresses how equine sequences were “performed in a strongly language-controlled acting mode” even as the “representation of horses clearly belonged to the tacit and largely undocumented set” of onstage horse play (170).
A trio of essays focuses on material conditions of various types of theatre. Katie Normington sheds light on costuming practices, something that is well documented but little studied. An examination of dramatic records, networks of labor, sumptuary laws, and conduct books shows that costuming, not modes of acting, signified character roles. Nerida Newbigin's essay on the “collective process” (93) of the hymn-singing confraternities of fifteenth-century Florence uncovers the technological innovation of staging heaven for the Ascension and Pentecost as well as the traditions of communal “ownership” (104) that sustained the production of these grand spectacles. Philip Butterworth examines archival documents and medieval mechanical knowledge in order to attempt a “speculative reconstruction” (219) of a semiautomaton of Saint George and the Dragon, including seven drawn recreations of the device. For those of us who have hoped for scholarship on historical scenography that is both exciting and appropriate for our undergraduate theatre history and M.F.A. design students, these are true gems.
This collection succeeds in addressing performance beyond theatre as well as the relationship between performers and spectators. Jennifer Nevile considers both the stability of the social makeup of audience/performer groups as well as the fluidity between those groups in elite danced spectacles developed in the Italian and French courts, including princely acrobatics. Kathryn Emily Dickason draws on anthropological trance theory to avoid “re-pathologising Choreomania” (143) and, instead, to view dance maniacs as active agents in cultivating “religious experience normally unavailable to them” (152). Max Harris convincingly argues for a recognition of the “interpretive versatility” (196) of the Palmesel, a wheeled statue of Christ on a donkey used in Palm Sunday processions, through ethnographic observation of two contrasting twenty-first-century Austrian ceremonies coupled with a wide-ranging examination of similarly dissimilar examples from medieval Poland to Prague to Zurich. Finally, Leanne Groeneveld approaches the Boxley Rood of Grace, a semiautomaton of Christ on the cross, by considering how audiences “responded to and read animated sculptures” (197) as well as the difficulty of accounting for how the object itself performed to/for various “conjunctions of identities and events” (210) both before and after the Reformation. These chapters, focusing on dance and object–human interaction respectively, demonstrate unique methodological agility, and they serve as models for how case studies of past performances might exist in dialogue with present topics and theories of performance.
Drama was but one of many forms of European performance practice, and these essays offer a constellation of terrifically interesting analysis and sometimes strange subjects to balance out the Everyman version of the Middle Ages. As a collection, the twelve essays offer fresh perspectives on early performance, and they do so with a consistent and admirable clarity for both medievalists and scholars of theatre and performance studies in general.
