Federico Finchelstein is an Argentine professor of history at the New School for Social Research in New York. Trained at Cornell University, he is the author of numerous works, including Transatlantic Fascism: Ideology, Violence, and the Sacred in Argentina and Italy, 1919–1945 (Duke University Press, 2010), and Fascismo, liturgia e imaginario. El mito del general Uriburu y la Argentina nacionalista (Buenos Aires, Fondo de Cultura Económica, 2002). Specialising in the study of fascism, populism, Jewish history and Latin American dictatorships, he has recently published The Ideological Origins of the Dirty War. Fascism, Populism, and Dictatorship in Twentieth Century Argentina (Oxford University Press, 2014).
In The Ideological Origins of the Dirty War, Finchelstein focuses on Argentina's 1976 military government and the regime of violence and terror that it imposed. Argentina's last dictatorship is really a point of departure for his study, which actually concentrates on the dictatorship's prior causes, and more precisely on the ideological origins of the authoritarian regime. By taking this historical route, the author directly challenges alternative understandings of Argentina's military regime – or alternative ‘politics of memory’– that, in his view, have inadequately explained the trajectory of Argentina's repressive politics. These alternatives include the human rights narrative that prevailed during Raúl Alfonsín's government, in the period of ‘transition to democracy’ that took place during the early 1980s. In that reading, the problem of violence appeared to be limited to the existence of two opposed and extreme factions, one made up of military officers and the other of guerrilla activists. This reductionist approach left most members of society as mere spectators of a brutal dispute carried out by others. Another failed alternative reading was the politics of reconciliation and pardon promoted by Carlos Menem's neoliberal government during the 1990s. In this version, history disappeared altogether: forgetting the past appeared to be the price to be paid in order to achieve peace. A further unsuccessful approach to authoritarianism was that pursued for over a decade during Néstor and Cristina Kirchner's presidencies from the early 2000s. According to Finchelstein, the Kirchners presented themselves as ‘warriors against absolute evil’ – despite the fact that neither one had played any relevant role in the fight against the dictatorship – and the years of terror and torture as a period of a war between ‘heroes and villains’. This was, in the end, just another inaccurate reconstruction of violence in Argentina that, like previous interpretations, denied history.
Against those flawed approaches, Finchelstein begins his research with a question that reveals his historical interests. The question is: how is it possible that such atrocities could occur in a country that was ‘born liberal’? In the author's view, if Argentine officials did what they did, this was because they considered that what they were doing was the right thing to do. And, if they believed that what they were doing was the right thing to do, this was because they were motivated by an ideology that had profound roots within Argentine history: a fascist ideology.
To better understand the country's last military government, Finchelstein dedicates a good part of his book to tracing the genealogy of Argentina's fascism. His exploration begins in the twentieth century, more precisely in 1930, when Argentina's first military coup took place. The author locates ‘the origins and development of fascism and anti-Semitism in Argentina’ in those years, and particularly in general Uriburu's military government, which was characterised by nationalist ideology and close ties with the Catholic Church: the old alliance between ‘the Sword and the Cross’ then took control of Argentine politics. Finchelstein locates the second fundamental step in this history of authoritarianism in 1943. In fact, in 1943 Argentina suffered its second military coup, in which Juan Domingo Perón was one of the main ideologues and activists. Thanks to the broad social support that Perón had won during his initial years in the government – particularly among a growing working class – Perón managed to become elected President in 1945, through fair and democratic elections. In the book, Perón's government is described as authoritarian and populist, as an administration that succeeded in expanding social rights at the cost of restricting political and civil rights.
Perón, and the regime that he inaugurated in 1945, play a crucial role in Finchelstein's narrative. For the author, Peronism represents a key political movement within Argentina's contemporary history – a movement that made a significant contribution to the fusion of fascism and Catholicism that came to characterise Argentina's public life. In fact – the author claims – the far-right movement Tacuara, prominent during the 1960s, had its origins in Peronism, as did guerrilla groups such as the Montoneros (the Montoneros had strong ties with both Peronism and the Church), and even para-military groups, such as the Triple A (many of whose members later played active roles in the 1976 dictatorship). Here we can clearly see the thread that ties together the early nationalist, right-wing, Catholic and anti-Semitic movements with the latest military dictatorship.
Perhaps, Finchelstein could have gone even further back in his exploration of the roots of Argentine authoritarianism. Instead of beginning in 1930, he could reasonably have begun his narrative in the independence period. Or he could have gone even further back to the colonial period (the moment when the alliance between the Church and the military – the Cross and the Sword – first appeared). This alternative approach to Argentina's dirty war(s) would not be built around the experience of fascism, but it would probably be more properly descriptive of its origins. Similarly, in the search for the ultimate origins of Argentine authoritarianism, Finchelstein could have concentrated less on cultural and motivational sources, and more on the material basis of political oppression. This route would have led him to dedicate more space to the study of inequality and the fight for maintaining privilege. This reading, again, would be faithful to Finchelstein's basic purposes – to discover the origins of Argentina's authoritarian traits – even though it would have taken him in a direction different from the one he pursues in his book.
Finchelstein has written a rigorous, erudite and passionate book which challenges current accounts of Argentina's dirty war. Through his important contribution, the author urges us to understand Argentina's latest dictatorship not as an exceptional, extreme and disgraceful moment within the country's history, but rather as the most dramatic episode within a much longer political history that includes several ignominious episodes. Federico Finchelstein has become one of the leading scholars in the region studying and explaining fascist ideology and practice beyond Europe. This book is testament to the quality and importance of his work.
