Jordt's timely book, published soon after the Burmese monks' mass demonstrations in September 2007, provides a new opening to the discussion on the socio-political culture and political legitimacy in contemporary Burma. By drawing on her fieldwork experience as a long-term researcher (Jordt has worked in Burma since the late 1980s) she examines the close relationship between the construction of power and manipulation of religious symbolism in Burmese politics. Her quest derives from the realisation that although disapproval and fear of the government is widespread in Burma, there is something that is common and shared between the regime and its people. And whilst exploring the process in which the state and society ‘engage in the production of social, economic, and political arrangements…’ (p. 125), she unravels how Buddhism has deeply infiltrated the Burmese national psyche.
The book is composed of five chapters and a summarising epilogue. Jordt starts by examining the development of Mahasi Tahthana Yeiktha (MTY), one of the largest networks of meditation centres in Burma, describing it as a new institution for the laity breaking with the normative relationship between the sangha and society. In contrast to U Ko Lay (an eminent Burmese Buddhist scholar) who saw the rise of the mass lay meditation movement as a particular kind of cultural response to British colonial dominance and the dismantling of Buddhist kingship in the nineteenth century (p. 23), Jordt sees it as a ‘potential’ base for social action in providing new spiritual orientation and an unifying identity for the Burmese people.
In chapter 2, Buddhist teachings are expounded building on the analysis of how Vipassanā meditation is instructed at MTY. She describes how its practice transforms the ‘conventional’ realities of yogi practitioners in their perception of the phenomenal world. This is liberating for many as it allows them to become freed of social and political constraints, and the process of which is egalitarian as everyone living in a transient world (anicca) is subject to mortality (dukkha), and ultimately reduced to insubstantial components of the self (anatta). Nonetheless, what is intriguing is what happens on the ground. In the following chapter, she describes how people, both men and women, as well as the military junta, engage in elaborate merit-making (dāna) activities to be part of the social process that produces patron-client ties and social networks. Here religious performances for the regime are seen as much more than ‘covert political acts’, since those in positions of power are under constant pressure to make themselves morally accountable in pursuit of the appearance of legitimate political rule.
Chapter 4 is especially insightful as Jordt explores the ‘alternative action sphere’ where people can remain critical of the coercive power of the military junta in an environment where the development of public opinion is almost impossible. It is here where an anti-regime discourse is communicated albeit covertly, and also where other forms of indigenous strategies are developed. Meditation is counted as one of the practices that allow the lay practitioner to remain autonomous and hopeful in a society where people are under surveillance. This chapter can also be read as a critique of western scholarship that often applies uncritically its oppositional model of ‘civil society against the state’; this is simply inadequate in furthering our understanding of a country like Burma.
In the last chapter, she tackles the key question that underpins the whole book: how has the military junta retained its power base for more than four decades without encountering an open and effective opposition from within the country, despite widespread international criticism. She compares and contrasts the reigns of U Nu and U Ne Win in their respective quest for political legitimacy; the former ‘on the basis of his personal morality’ and the latter by undertaking ‘demeritorious actions for meritorious end goals’ (p. 198). She looks at how both drew heavily on the rhetoric of Buddhist kingship and attempted to legitimate themselves through their association with the sangha in different ways. In this discussion, however, it is necessary to envisage a society that is still in a feudal state where one cannot discern a historical separation of church and state. This can nonetheless be confusing for the general reader who is used to the western discourse that sets the criteria for regime performance, based on the post-enlightenment ideals of human rights, equality, democracy and justice.
It seems to me that the overall impression Jordt gives of the Burmese lay meditation ‘movement’ that can resist and ‘stand against the state’ (p. 199) is rather optimistic. Whilst acknowledging that Vipāssanā meditation practised in MTY centres have helped the laity in accepting their daily suffering on an epistemological level, it may also have catered for the needs of the establishment to vent the frustration and unhappiness of the general public. Moreover, one cannot confuse the conceptual distinction between this-worldly issues (loki) and other-worldly soteriology (lokuttara), which is much more pronounced and prevalent in Burmese Buddhism (due to political intervention from the colonial times) than in other Buddhist countries in Southeast Asia.
Furthermore, it is doubtful how much actual interest the generals take in the kind of canonical Buddhism Jordt has expounded in the book, as they dabble in the ‘dark arts’ of astrology, the occult and numerology, and practise Samatha techniques (not Vipassanā) to acquire supernatural powers. Many of their activities seem to be aimed not only at harnessing Buddhism for political legitimacy, but more at capturing the rich ‘potency’ embedded in sacred sites, in saintly monks, and the moral communities surrounding them so that they can retain their position of power.
Finally, although Jordt describes women as important agents in creating an alternative sphere for practice and resistance, I find it problematic that she continues to take at face value Spiro's assertion that ‘women do not have pon’ (p. 162). I have come across a growing number of senior Buddhist nuns and lay women in Burma who find themselves in an authoritative position that allows them to assert their pon. It is about time that we question his notion of ‘innate Burmese male superiority’, perpetuated in academic writing for more than four decades, since attributing an essentialist value to this concept is not only unhelpful but also causes our discussion on contemporary gender relations in Burma to stagnate.
The book has given us a deeper insight into our attempt to understand the interface between Burmese religious culture, power politics and the notion of legitimacy, and will undoubtedly revitalise the debate on various aspects of social and political issues in contemporary Burma.
