These three volumes present selected papers from the July 2012 ‘Social Work and Social Development 2012: Action and Impact’ conference jointly hosted by the International Associations of Schools of Social Work, International Council on Social Welfare and International Federation of Social Workers in Stockholm.
Volume I highlights human rights and social equality as key agendas for social work today. This general theme is emphasized by Swedish human rights activist Thomas Hammarberg who argues that more equal and cohesive societies are most conducive to protecting the principles and norms of human rights. However, South African social work academic Vishanthie Sewpaul cautions that in order to be effective human rights advocates, social workers need to move beyond micro practice with individuals and small groups to engage in macro political activism that challenges unfair economic structures.
Further chapters apply these human rights criteria to specific practice areas. Some of the issues covered include partnering with people with a disability to facilitate inclusion, progressing active and dignified ageing and the prevention of abuse of older people, promoting a systemic and holistic approach incorporating community development ideas to protecting children at risk, dealing with aggressive parents in child protection work, assisting vulnerable young people, combating violence against women, supporting equal rights for lesbian gay bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people and opposing discrimination, facilitating access to health care for minority groups such as asylum seekers and proposing harm reduction policies for illicit drug use.
Volume II extends the discussion to environmental change and sustainable social development. A number of contributors urge social workers to add a concern for environmental justice to the existing person in the environment paradigm. Fred Besthorn argues that environmental issues were neglected historically in social work, but adds that there has encouragingly been a flowering of interest in recent years. Lena Dominelli proposes a form of green social work that highlights action to address environmental degradation, and promote sustainable forms of social and economic development. Surprisingly, neither of these authors refers to broader Green perspectives on the welfare state by key researchers such as British academic Tony Fitzpatrick.
The authors target the connection between social work and the management of natural disasters such as floods, earthquakes and tsunamis. Citing case studies from Thailand, China and Sri Lanka, they suggest that social work's systems approach can play a key role in assisting individuals, families and communities to recover from these traumas. Reference is also made to social workers potentially playing a key role in facilitating access to clean and safe drinking water. Further practice areas addressed in this volume include social work participation in social enterprises, global social work education models and action to address discrimination (via inequitable government funding in areas such as education and health) against indigenous children in Canada and other English-speaking countries.
Volume III addresses the role of social workers in global social transformation and social action. British academic Malcolm Payne argues for global solidarity to achieve equality and justice for human beings everywhere. Two authors from Morocco and Tunisia analyse the positive social policy consequences of the Arab Spring in terms of promoting greater freedom of speech and expression, and respect for gender and cultural equality. Other contributors refer specifically to the social activism of social workers in the USA, Brazil and South Africa, whilst British academic Sarah Cemlyn analyses the value challenges faced by immigration social workers attempting to balance the rights of young asylum seekers and the demands of immigration law. Walter Lorenz warns that social workers must defend the rights of users to welfare support in the face of government policies that attempt to privatize the welfare state.
Another British academic Michael Lavalette argues that professional social work has always been an ideologically contested project divided between a conservative minority who engage in social control of service users, the majority who at least advocate some form of social reform, and a progressive minority who favour radical change via an alliance with wider social movements. He charts the history of what he calls ‘popular’ social work based on recognising and addressing the public causes of private pain, including Jane Adams and the settlement movement in the USA, and the activities of the Labour Prime Minister Clement Attlee in Britain.
He then turns his attention controversially to the Palestinian West Bank where he documents a number of effective individual and community-based interventions with young people traumatized by the conflict with Israel. However, some of his rhetoric unfortunately slips into unqualified endorsement of extreme Palestinian nationalist agendas, such as the so-called Right of Return which sits light years away from internationalist social justice values. In contrast, Kay Hoffman's chapter on social sustainability praises the UK Children of Peace group, which includes both Israeli and Palestinian children suffering from the violence associated with the conflict.
Two other contributors provide useful guides for social workers seeking to promote change at the micro and macro levels. Sarah Banks and Kirsten Nohr offer a number of case studies of conflicts between social work values and rigid organisational rules or unfair laws that block the fulfilment of service user rights. They suggest that ethical practice requires social workers not to act as robots, but rather to be creative in breaking or bending rules to progress social justice. Idit Weiss-Gal and John Gal argue the case for all social workers not just policy experts to be involved in social policy activism or what they call ‘policy practice’. Based on a recent comparative study of policy practice in eight countries, they note that social workers can influence policy by a number of means, including involvement in professional social work associations, civil society organisations, academic research and via submissions to parliamentary committees.
Overall, the volumes are rather uneven in both quality and length. Some read as academic journal-type papers, whilst others are very superficial and seem to be little more than conference presentation notes. I personally think Volume III works best as most of the contributions explicitly address the theme of social work and social action. In contrast, many of the papers in Volume I seem merely to target a number of random practice areas. It may perhaps have been better either to publish all conference papers via general proceedings, or alternatively to include a smaller number of peer reviewed papers that considered the key conference themes in depth.
The editor Sven Hessle states an aspiration to appeal to policy makers, practitioners, researchers and academics, but I think given the above limitations the major audience is likely to be students and practitioners. However, these caveats aside, the three volumes confirm that whilst social work as an international profession incorporates a diverse range of practice methods and values, it nevertheless retains a core universal commitment to social justice and human rights.
