Property regimes, long a staple of the development literature, have been out of favor for some time as a topic of inquiry in Japanese history. Fortunately, this has not dissuaded Philip Brown, who has made a career of challenging conventional wisdom in this area. Brown's early work highlighted the unevenness of the land surveys that underpinned the early modern political economy. His new book exposes a related anomaly: the phenomenon known as warichi, or “dividing the land,” whereby landholders (or their overlords) periodically redistributed some or all of their farm plots. Reallocation systems of this kind—typically determined by lottery—were surprisingly widespread during the early modern era. According to Cultivating Commons, upwards of a quarter to as much as a third of Japanese arable may have been subject to periodic redistribution in the Edo period, and in some places the practice persisted as late as the 1970s. These are stunning figures. If historians have not paid much attention to joint ownership in the past, we surely have reason to do so now.
Nor is the author's claim on our attention purely academic. As Brown contends early on, “study of Japan's experience reminds us that nonmarket and nontechnological social solutions have been viable and may still be viable today. . . Well-designed social institutions can make useful contributions to solving contemporary policy issues; they can provide a measure of security and equity for participants in dealing with natural hazard risk” (p. 5). This security-and-equity framework provides the analytical vocabulary of Cultivating Commons.
The book begins with a concise review of origin theories and environmental context (chapter 2), a discussion of sources and methods (chapter 3), and a three-fold typology of warichi systems (chapter 4). Employing what he calls a “trilevel approach,” Brown shifts the scale of analysis more than once, beginning with a brisk national survey and then considering two domainal systems (Satsuma and Kaga) before honing in on village-level data. The village cases, which make up the meat of the book (chapters 5, 6, and 7), are drawn primarily from Echigo Province (central Niigata Prefecture) on the Japan Sea Coast, where the sources are particularly rich. In terms of the typology elaborated in chapter 4, Echigo's village systems conform to the most common variant nationwide: one in which fields were exchanged on a per share (rather than a per family or per capita) basis.
Of the many issues addressed in these core chapters, two receive detailed treatment: the relationship between warichi and environmental vulnerability, and the question of social equity. To test the vulnerability relationship, Brown maps the distribution of warichi villages—and the periodicity of their redistribution schemes—against the likelihood of natural hazards in their locales. The hypothesis is straightforward: if joint ownership was primarily a mechanism for coping with floods and other calamities, the frequency of reallocations should correlate with the riskiness of the local environment. After painstakingly plotting his quantitative data on a dozen digital maps (whose legends and color-schemes, incidentally, might have been better designed), Brown comes to a negative conclusion: “natural endowments do not directly determine redistribution intervals” (p. 144). Instead, he reasons, different communities—like different individuals—appear to have had different degrees of risk-aversion.
The data on social equity reveal another gray area. At least in Echigo's Iwade village (Brown's best-documented case), “hints of inequities” abound. Powerful parties—village headmen, district chiefs, and temples—routinely received special exemptions (hikikuji) that allowed them to exclude some or all of their lands from the lottery. (Excluded lands were often also tax exempt, ostensibly as compensation for public service.) The most powerful landlord family in Iwade, the Satō, repeatedly exercised hikikuji priviliges to retain control over specific paddy fields it desired (p. 148). Even for fields that were entered in the lottery, the records show that the Satō often maneuvered after the fact to exchange whatever lot they had drawn with that of another family in order to continue cultivating their customary fields (p. 162). Brown can only speculate as to “the incentive or social compulsion that underlay these exchanges” (p. 163). But as he dryly acknowledges in his conclusion, “the discussion in this chapter leads to the impression that there was a measure of inequity in the operation of warichi in Iwade” (p. 169). Indeed.
After tracing the long trajectory of joint ownership under successive Japanese governments until its ultimate demise in the postwar period (chapter 8), Brown concludes with a far-reaching series of “Final Reflections” (chapter 9). Of the many chords struck here, three may be of particular interest to readers of this journal. First, resonating with his earlier characterization of the Tokugawa shogunate as a “flamboyant state,” Brown contends that the widespread presence of warichi in early modern Japan “speaks persuasively about the limitations of political power at both the national and even the domain level. If Hideyoshi and his followers sought to impose a nationally uniform system of land tenures, it clearly failed” (p. 191). Second, he revisits the rural research of an earlier generation, led by Thomas C. Smith. The presence of joint ownership regimes, in his view, “does not challenge [Smith's] story of low-level change in economic behavior that laid the foundation for Japan's modern economic transformation.” But it “does mean that we must envision a more subtle and diverse set of mechanisms through which that story unfolds” (p. 195). Finally, Brown strikes a blow against simple cause-effect models of social change. Given the hard fact that neither the presence of warichi, nor its persistence, nor the frequency of redistribution bears a clear correlation with environmental risk, mechanistic explanations have to be ruled out. In their place, we are left with open-ended musings about the likely importance of leadership, trust, and small-group dynamics at key points in the evolution of any given village system (“history matters, even if we call it path dependence!” [p. 208]). Ironically perhaps, this careful social-scientific study culminates in a cautionary word about the limits of social-scientific explanation.
