No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 January 2005
Ten years in the making and keenly anticipated, the five-volume Oxford Encyclopedia of Economic History is now available. The casual reader of sales brochures may by now feel that the present spate of historical encyclopedia-writing is excessive, an attempt to squeeze a few more dollars from the university library budget before the system collapses. But anyone who has lapsed into this cynical state of mind should make an exception for this one. The edifice that Joel Mokyr and his team have constructed is indeed a monumental achievement, justifying the publisher's claim that it is “a truly remarkable work of scholarship.” The members of the editorial team, who deserve to share in the glory, are Maxine Berg, Loren Brandt, Erik Buyst, Louis P. Cain, Jan de Vries, Paul E. Lovejoy, and John H. Munro.
The volumes contain nearly 900 articles written by 800 experts. The entries are not structured according to any one historical schema or framework, which would have been quite constraining. Instead, a set of eight major topic groupings generated a heterogeneous mix of titles. The list of these Category 1 headings conveys a sense of the whole: Geography; Agriculture; Production Systems, Business History, and Technology; Institutions, Governments and Markets; Macroeconomic History and International Economics; Labor; Natural Resources and the Environment; and Biographies, a category with subheadings for Inventors and Writers on Technology; Entrepreneurs, Bankers and Labor Leaders; and Economists and Economic Historians. The articles are richly illustrated, and intended to be accessible to general readers as well as to specialists, and supplemented with generous bibliographies and cross-references. The fifth volume contains more than two hundred pages of reference material, including a directory of useful internet sites.
A seven-page preface by Mokyr reviews the project's guiding philosophy, emphasizing the effort to escape “Western-centric biases” in the choice of topics, and highlighting the coverage of institutions—broadly defined—as a distinguishing feature of economic history. In this respect the work is true to the editor's word. Inevitably the majority of the detailed contributions deal with European and American topics, reflecting the research specialties of the field. But clearly a conscientious effort has been made to extend the geographic coverage to the far corners of the earth, primarily in useful surveys of national and regional economic histories, but also in novel topical entries such as the Diandi (a Chinese term for pawning land) and the Waqf (an Arabic form of property). These articles will make valuable references for students, and for scholars seeking information outside of their own specialty. Also informative are articles that address relatively abstract concepts with historical applications, such as Custom, Entrepreneurship, and Taboos, to say nothing of Feudalism and Capitalism.
It hardly need be said that such an encyclopedic work poses a challenge to the reviewer. The volumes are meant to be consulted for reference, not read from start to finish. If the overall construction represents an implicit commitment to a particular theory or conceptualization of economic history, such a subtext has thus far eluded this reviewer. Readers of this Journal may be assured that anyone in our field can while away many happy hours pleasantly and profitably by browsing through the articles and following the trail of clues suggested by the numerous cross-references.
My one concern is how well the volumes serve those who are not in our field. In an effort to gain the perspective of an outsider, I undertook a small experimental spot check. Before examining the Table of Contents or the Index, I asked a colleague in British history to come up with a short list of questions on which historians might want to consult an encyclopedia of economic history. The result was the following list:
These seem to be informed and intelligent questions, possibly somewhat dated; but it is reasonable after all to expect an encyclopedia of history to update readers on older concepts and controversies. How well does the Oxford encyclopedia do by this standard? The batting average is about 0.500. (A similar exercise with an Americanist yielded similar results.) Here is a rundown:
1. Good. There are no entries for Empire or British Empire, but a search under Imperialism leads the reader to an informative 11-page essay on Economic Imperialism by Gareth Austin, covering the past 500 years. This includes a paragraph on the Davis-Huttenback thesis and subsequent debate.
2. Again Good. Clearly the Editor in Chief thinks the Industrial Revolution is a useful concept, because he assigned the article to a leading expert, namely himself. The essay concludes: “The significance of the Industrial Revolution in economic history cannot be overestimated” (Volume 3, p. 55).
3. Here my informed outsider might come away disappointed. The index entry for “living standards” contains just one subheading for Industrial Revolution, which leads the reader back to Mokyr's essay and a paragraph on human suffering caused by industrial restructuring. The index refers the reader to Volume 4, p. 48, for material on Wages and Labor Income by Charles Feinstein. But p. 48 is actually only the last page of a Feinstein essay on Investment and Savings (pp. 41–48). The essay on Wages and Labor Income by Leandro Prados de la Escosura and Joan R. Roses (pp. 48–52) surveys trends in several countries, beginning in 1856. Another essay by Peter Scholliers on Wages (Volume 5, pp. 203–10) discusses limitations of real wages as measures of living standards. But the venerable debate about real wages and living standards during the Industrial Revolution itself does not receive direct attention.
4.5.6. I think it is accurate to say that these questions are not directly covered. To be fair, the expression Great Depression of the Nineteenth Century is obsolete, and Mark Casson's essay on Entrepreneurship does include a good review of the debate on British entrepreneurial decline (Volume 2, p. 214). But the subject matter of Barry Supple's essay on British decline as myth does not seem to be represented, and I could find no attention to the trajectory of Keynesian economics as an aspect of economic history—though there is a biographical entry on Keynes by D. E. Moggridge (Volume 3, p. 218).
Can we learn anything from this hasty exercise? Perhaps only that historians and economic historians have different primary interests, something we probably knew already. One must also recall that my two consultants and their questions are distinctly Western, whereas the editors were at pains to extend their reach into non-Western topics. Perhaps most basically, one can hardly ask contributors to survey the state of present knowledge in subject areas where little economic history scholarship exists. Yet when all these mitigating factors are acknowledged, it might still be reasonable to suggest that more market research among potential nonspecialist consumers could be useful in designing future encyclopedias of economic history.
Let me return in conclusion, however, to my theme of celebration. We should all be grateful to the editors, and especially to the 800 contributors who have performed a valuable service for the collective profession, for which they will receive precious little professional reward. By all means urge your library to purchase this landmark reference. If you can get a good discount, you might want to invest in a set for your personal library. Otherwise, you can hold out either for the paperback or the on-line edition. Some sample chapters are already available at the Oxford University Press web site.