What do a 2009 advertisement for Sprite, the former Escuela Mecánica de la Armada (ex-ESMA) in Buenos Aires, the Punta Carretas shopping centre in Montevideo and public denunciations of human rights abusers have in common? The answer, according to Cara Levey's new book Fragile Memory, Shifting Impunity, is that each is related to the continual contestation of commemorative projects in post-dictatorship Argentina and Uruguay. Through side-by-side analyses of transitional justice, commemoration and memory in each country, with a particular focus on the placial (and, to some extent, spatial) construction of commemorative sites, Levey demonstrates the vulnerability of commemorative projects to pressure from political leaders, members of the armed forces and civil society organisations for the victims of violence.
Whereas previous literature, as this book highlights, has drawn attention to the boom of memory projects developed across Latin America in recent years, and has identified commemoration as the process by which ‘space becomes a place’ (Elizabeth Jelin and Victoria Langland, Marcas, memoriales, y marcas territoriales (Siglo XXI, 2003), p. 3), Levey takes her analysis a step further to demonstrate that commemorative places are not simply made, but are continually reconstituted, contested and imbued with new meaning by a diverse array of societal and state actors. Throughout the book, the focus on commemorative sites remains consistent, and goes beyond an aesthetic or architectural appreciation of such spaces to also incorporate the political and social significance.
Chapter 1 outlines the scope and theoretical approach of the book, and highlights the importance of commemorative sites for studying memory by drawing on the work of Elizabeth Jelin, Tim Cresswell, and Jens Aldermann (among others). In Chapter 2 Levey provides an in-depth account of the transition from dictatorship to democracy, and from impunity to accountability, in Argentina and Uruguay. For readers not familiar with the legal process of transitional justice or specific details of landmark cases, this is a useful summary which provides important context for the rest of the book. Levey is also careful to highlight that these transitions have been uneven processes, and that they remain incomplete.
The following three chapters, however, are where the key contributions of this book are located as Levey performs comparisons between Argentine and Uruguayan examples of three types of commemorative site, combining an array of photographs, interviews and details from archival research. Chapter 3 compares the Monumento a las Víctimas del Terrorismo del Estado in Buenos Aires and the Memorial de los Detenidos Desaparecidos in Montevideo (which was, allegedly, covered up whilst Sprite filmed their advertisement). In Chapter 4, Levey analyses sites of ‘state terrorism’ (p. 149) which have been reconfigured for different purposes: the ex-ESMA detention centre into a memory museum, the Punta Carretas prison into a shopping centre. Finally, Chapter 5 analyses the ‘transitory’ site of the escraches (demonstrations in which ‘participants march to the home or work place of a represor [perpetrator of human rights violations] and communicate details of their crimes … to neighbours and the general public’ (p. 200)) in both countries. This chapter in particular draws attention to the potential for non-institutional actors to influence memory and justice from ‘outside’ (p. 243) of official legal channels and commemorative spaces. Levey's analysis also demonstrates, however, the contested nature of memory within civil society, and the potential for victims of violence, radical groups and children of the disappeared to construct different versions of commemorative practice.
The book contributes to a growing subsection of the literature on post-conflict memory which sees space and place as primary categories of analysis for understanding violence and its commemoration. Levey's book is therefore reminiscent of other interdisciplinary and comparative approaches, for example Estela Schindel and Pamela Colombo, Space and the Memories of Violence: Landscapes of Erasure, Disappearance and Exception (Palgrave Macmillan, 2014) and Susana Draper, Afterlives of Confinement: Spatial Transitions in Postdictatorship Latin America (Pittsburgh University Press, 2012), which have attempted to decipher commemoration and the politics of memory through the lens of space and place. However, the author does not simply replicate or refocus old debates. Instead, Levey argues that the lieux de mémoire she analyses are not only repositories for abstract, aesthetical memories, but symbolic spaces in which opposition to impunity can be articulated, and from which legal justice can be significantly impacted.
A minor criticism of the book is that there is a slight unevenness in the way in which the terminology of ‘space’ and ‘place’ are deployed. Whereas Levey's analyses of commemorative sites tend to privilege the terminology of ‘place’ over ‘space’ in a manner which draws greater attention to the meanings attributed to commemorative sites by state actors, civil society and victims, there is focus on how space and spatiality are active participants in the construction of these narratives. Furthermore, at several points Levey makes reference to the central or peripheral role of national case studies in the global literature on post-conflict memory (p. 35), as well as to the position of the Holocaust as ‘a (if not the) universal paradigm of extreme violence’ (p. 33; original emphasis). Whilst the author is right to highlight this tension between the global and the local in studies of post-conflict memory, as well as the potentially homogenising use of ‘Holocaust metaphors and tropes’ (p. 33) to describe a panoply of experiences of violence, it might have also been useful to consider how narratives of Argentina's ‘dirty war’ have, to some extent, been used as a palimpsest for post-conflict studies in Latin America, leading to the potential argentinización of memory discourse about Uruguay, Colombia, Peru and others.
That being said, another major strength of Fragile Memory, Shifting Impunity is the way in which Levey has foregrounded her analyses of commemorative sites with discussions of the comparative political contexts in which they were created. The book is not limited to the procedural aspects of commemorative practice, yet it does highlight how landmark legal cases and trials have taken place alongside the growth of commemorative practice. The comparative element of Levey's methodology highlights the uneven development of transitional justice and commemorative practice in each country, and allows the author to pinpoint precisely how each site was produced at a particular moment. Levey's book is therefore particularly important for highlighting the ‘convoluted’ (p. 3) nature of these transitions during which, at almost any moment, the political will of particular actors has the potential to accelerate or derail the process entirely.
Fragile Memory, Shifting Impunity is therefore an important, engaging and original contribution to the interdisciplinary literature on memory and transitional justice in Latin America. Levey's work demonstrates the critical value of embarking upon comparative studies, and her reading of commemorative projects through shifting contexts of justice and impunity is a creative approach. Perhaps most importantly, however, this book argues that post-conflict memory projects remain fragile and vulnerable. Human rights activists, therefore, must be willing to defend them, to continue struggling against impunity, and to adapt to shifting political and social challenges.
