This book collects a selection of twenty-two articles that Jérôme France first published over a period of twenty-five years, from 1991 to 2016, as well as his post-doctoral dissertation (Paris, 2002) on the staffing of the Roman Empire's financial administration. The volume is divided into four parts, introduced by a short preface which sets out very clearly F.’s main thesis, which runs through the chapters that follow. In essence, F. rejects the so-called theory of Roman domination, which claims that the imperial administration in general, and tax extraction system in particular, were just a sophisticated mechanism designed to profiteer from the conquered provincials, to the exclusive benefit of the Italian elites. Contrary to this view, the author argues that the imperial financial apparatus did effectively contribute to an original form of association between core and peripheries. Since taxes ensured the payment of the army, which guaranteed in turn some degree of territorial protection, taxation became tolerable to the subjected populations.
This interpretation is not new, but it has been argued and revised many times. Its most successful formulation was probably the ‘tax and trade’ model elaborated by Keith Hopkins in the 1980s. However, the ‘tax and trade’ model went beyond the ‘protection in exchange for taxes’ equation by assuming that taxation was the main engine of production, exchange and wealth distribution. For his part, F. retains the idea of co-operation between central power and provincials, based on the exchange of taxes for protection, but argues that taxation, rather than being the motor for economic growth, served as a useful indicator for the degree of monetisation, the volume of exchanges and market development. Based on this, F. contends that the market ruled the Roman economy. The central government's tax policy could perhaps affect or redirect its development, but it could not alone generate economic growth.
This ‘minimalist’ function of tax explains why the first section of the book (Portoria) deals with indirect taxation instead of direct levies. In most tax systems, the latter are the main source of revenue, providing about 80 per cent of total tax revenue. F. does not reverse these figures for the late Republic and the early Roman Empire, but argues that taxes on trade and transactions were of great relevance, being the tools by which the central government could affect the economies of local communities. By imposing or modifying the tax burden on commercial transactions, or even the tax share designed to fund local finance, the central government could favour some cities or communities rather than others.
Another major function of taxing transactions, which F. does not mention but which seems inherent in his reconstruction, is that indirect taxes served as a measure for evaluating the oscillations of market prices (of goods, but also of land and slaves). This implies that even in the absence of a land tax inventory, the assessment and collection of direct taxes, as well as the profit that tax collectors derived from their function as intermediaries, strongly depended on this fiscal device.
The question of profit in the management of taxation brings us to the second section (Officia), which consists of an analytical examination of the financial offices and their personnel. In this part, F. offers a learned presentation of the evolution of the various financial offices, as well as of the status and function of the personnel allocated to the collection of taxes and management of revenues. Of great interest is the classification of the legal status of the actors involved: slave, freedman or free. F. shows how the modalities under which and the extent to which these individuals could gain profit from their activities, either for themselves or for their superiors (dominus, patronus or locator), depended on each actor's degree of legal autonomy, as minutely regulated by Roman law. Expanding on this, the author contends that, whatever their individual status, these actors were organised in companies (societas publicanorum) which signed contracts with the state for the collection and the management of taxation. They extracted profit from the difference between the amount established by the state and the sum they were able to collect from the taxpayers. This system implied a certain amount of risk, but also the possibility of great profit. Thus it is worth asking to what extent the profit gained by the contractors depended on the variations in market prices, or, put otherwise, on the power of tax collectors to impose arbitrary tax rates.
The essays collected in the central part of the book deal with direct taxes (Tributa). F. thoroughly describes the nature and function of the two main direct taxes: the land tax (tributum soli) and the poll tax (tributum capitis). The principal novelty of his reconstruction concerns the system for distributing the global tax burden. The author argues that the distribution was effected through pre-established tax contingents from the top to bottom levels of the fiscal administration. In this context, the local communities not only had a relevant role in the operation of tax collection and redistribution (say, in the spending of taxes), but also in the assessment of taxes, which remained indeterminate prior to reaching the local level. The flexible nature of the poll tax is a clear example of how this system could have functioned.
In the last section (Privata), F. examines a series of epigraphic documents describing artisanship and commercial activities in the north-western imperial provinces. By drawing attention to these economic sectors, the author convincingly argues for the existence of a ‘precocious capitalism’ in the Roman Empire. This assessment further reinforces his central idea that taxation on transactions played a crucial role in the continued functioning of imperial infrastructures.
To conclude, notwithstanding the need for further discussion of some of F.’s theses, this is a stimulating and well-researched book that should be seen as a point of reference for any scholar interested in the history of the financial and fiscal organisation of the late Republic and early Roman Empire.
