The growing attention that music scholarship has been paying to the social and commercial contexts of composition and performance is a rich and exciting development. Not only does it provide us with the opportunity to place the music we identify as crucial to aesthetic change within a more nuanced historical setting; it also forces us to consider the true extent to which such music was actually known and consumed by contemporary audiences. Consuming Music is a fascinating attempt to ‘help redefine’, as the editors explain in their Introduction, ‘the received notion of musical culture itself with respect to a period associated since the nineteenth century with a more absolute conception of the art form’ (p. 8). Since they are keen to explore David Gramit’s call that scholars consider ‘specific, music-producing relationships not as the contexts for great works, but as elements of a musical practice that was in itself meaningful for its participants’,Footnote 1 the books contains very few references to the composers whom we might expect to encounter in the historical period covered (a quick glance at the Index reveals just a handful of references to C.P.E. Bach, Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven). Instead, the focus here is on the musical consumer, and the lengths to which publishers, printers and critics – as well as composers and performers – were prepared to go to entice, entertain and indeed educate their audiences.
The book is divided into four sections, with chapters grouped thematically: ‘Selling Variety’, ‘Edifying Readers’, ‘Marketing the Mundane’ and ‘Cultivating Communities’. Whilst the editors acknowledge the breadth of subjects covered under these sub-headings, I wonder if it might have been easier for the reader if these chapters had been presented chronologically instead. Given the extensive time period covered by the contributions, it was sometimes a little disorienting to be jumping back and forth through different stages of institutional and commercial development, particularly since many of the chapters are largely concerned with the same geographical region, namely Austro-Germany.
Co-editor Emily H. Green provides the first of the book’s nine chapters, ‘Music’s First Consumers: Publishers in the Late Eighteenth Century’. This puts direct emphasis on two aspects of professional musical life at the time which are usually only mentioned in passing: the rarity of printed music in comparison with circulated hand-written copies – ‘printed music was a scarce, luxury item’ (p. 16) – and the highly diverse and entrepreneurial approach that composers had to take in order to ensure a living (perhaps not so different, in fact, from the twenty-first century musician’s portfolio career). Green also explores the notion of the music publisher as a ‘conspicuous consumer’, pointing out that buyers and sellers are not mutually exclusive categories, and that publishers could act as middle-men to music printers as well as taking on a patron-like role to promote their chosen composers (pp. 18–19).
This is followed by ‘Inside a Viennese Kunsthandlung: Artaria in 1784’, a masterful summary of information from the earliest surviving ledger from that company, by Rupert Ridgewell. This chapter, and indeed the volume in general, is superbly well furnished with reproductions of both images and written and printed text. Ridgewell unpacks the various aspects of Artaria’s business as documented in the ledger, from prints and books to sheet music and maps; he then uses this information to reflect on target audiences and the prices set for each demographic. The level of detail and care is admirable, with Ridgewell even considering the storing and placement of stock and how this was designed to best serve the company and its customers. One particularly fascinating aspect of Artaria’s music holdings was its tendency to catalogue works by genre, suggesting that this was a more practicable way to entice would-be buyers and their fellow amateur players than listing by composer would have been (pp. 41–42). It is a simple but powerful observation, which makes clear the importance of generic listings on the back of score wrappers. One purchases music that one might actually be able to perform according to the players available, after all, and this remains a basic tenet of music purchase even after the notion of the ‘great composer’ came to dominate musical thinking: the market for arrangements in the nineteenth century would not have flourished as it did were this not the case.
The second of the book’s four sections, ‘Edifying Readers’, brings together another pair of chapters: Steven Zohn’s ‘Morality and the “Fair-Sexing” of Telemann’s Faithful Music Master’ and Roger Matthew Grant’s ‘Eighteenth-Century Mediations of Music Theory: Meter, Tempo, and Affect in Print’. The origins of Telemann’s Der getreue Music-Meister as a serial modelled on moral weeklies and monthly miscellanies aligns it with an almost Reithian approach to cultural education. Zohn quotes the opening issue of the Universal Mercury of 1726, which aims ‘To divert and to instruct’ (p. 70), and Telemann’s mixture of witty parodies, clear instruction, the opportunity to join in with exercises, and the promise of new and diverting things to come in future instalments, was evidently a successful formula (pp. 70–72). Furthermore, Zohn points to the opportunity such a publication allowed for women to engage with this kind of study, and Telemann himself was evidently a supporter of female self-improvement (p. 86). It is sometimes a little confusing to keep abreast of the various individuals and publications scattered throughout the chapter, but the subject matter is intriguing and Zohn also provides a German–English parallel presentation of Telemann’s Preface to Der getreue Music-Meister as a valuable appendix. Grant offers an overview of the difficulties of attempting to capture details of tempo and affect in printed sources, and the intimate connection between scientific rigour and capturing the ‘passions or affections’, in Kirnberger’s words (Gemüthsbewegung) in determining the correct pacing of a performance (p. 111). Kirnberger, Heinrich Christian Koch and others struggled to adapt to new audiences who, as the market began to grow, did not necessarily have adequate training and experience to correctly interpret old taxonomies. The chapter contains numerous examples drawn from Fux, Kirnberger and others; but they are not always presented with sufficient explanation to allow for real critical engagement. Indeed, a lengthy example from Kirnberger’s Die Kunst des reinen Satzes in der Musik could have benefitted from annotation to aid clarity.
Three chapters are included under the section heading, ‘Marketing the Mundane’. Following her recent monograph, The Social Worlds of Nineteenth-Century Chamber Music (University of Illinois Press, 2015), Marie Sumner Lott discusses amateur string repertoire in ‘Musical Style as Commercial Strategy in Romantic Chamber Music’. Using the catalogues of Friedrich Hofmeister, she reminds us of the importance of reprinting existing repertoire, in addition to commissioning new works; and she discusses the music of Czech composer Václav Veit (1806–1864) at some length. An amateur composer, Veit composed a small number of string quartets which were ‘prime examples of a popular style that found favor with musical consumers through the nineteenth century’, enjoying multiple reissues thanks to his clever combinations of fashionable new material (such as Russian musical references) and Classical models (p. 133). Each work offered ‘a new adventure within acceptably familiar parameters’, as Sumner Lott so eloquently puts it (p. 134). The accessibility of the repertoire, equal involvement for all players, familiarity of style and general ideas, and simply the fun of playing such music points to a group of canny musicians (and publishers) recognizing the thirst for music of this kind. And it puts into perspective just how difficult, conceptually and practically, the contemporary works of Beethoven, Schubert and Schumann must have seemed to amateur performers who principally enjoyed repertoire such as this.
Catherine Mayes considers ‘The Decline and Transformation of the Contredanse Hongroise in the Early Nineteenth Century’, as the waltz came to dominate in Vienna and elsewhere. As with Sumner Lott’s chapter, the emphasis here is partly on the suitability of certain music for joining in (here as a dancer rather than player). Mayes identifies this as the big shift from the minuet to the contredanse, since the former was ‘performed for the enjoyment of onlookers … while the contredanse was primarily intended to give pleasure to the dancers themselves’ (p. 161). She identifies the principal features of this new democratized dance form and provides examples of scores and collections, tracing the dance’s eventual demise for the very same reason as its earlier success: its extreme simplicity. This is followed by Glenda Goodman’s ‘The Power to Please’, in which she considers the tightrope walked by female musicians who wished to court public success in late eighteenth-century America: ‘They had to create a commodified image of themselves as enticing entertainers who undermined neither American political ideals nor the nations’ changing social imperatives pertaining to gender’ (p. 177). Using Mary Pownall (1751–1796) as her central case study, Goodman considers Pownall’s career upon her settling in America, and her astute positioning of herself as a mother (even including her children in her acts), composer of simple and popular melodies, and focus on dramatic roles which emphasized a straightforward, morally upright character type. It would have been interesting to learn more about Pownall’s reception in comparison with her younger counterparts – she was already 41 by the time she left Britain and moved to New York – and whether her age made it more (or less) straightforward for her to establish herself in such a way. A longer study into the lives of such performers would be most interesting.
The fourth and final section of Consuming Music is entitled ‘Cultivating Communities’. In ‘Exchanging Ideas in a Changing World: Adolph Bernhard Marx and the Berliner allgemeine musikalische Zeitung in 1824’, Patrick Wood Uribe discusses the importance of considering the commercial context of music journals – often issued by music publishers who had strong agendas regarding the promotion and positive review of their own composers. Uribe outlines Marx’s practice of using the journal to generate debate by espousing diametrically opposing aesthetic positions by writing under a series of pseudonyms. (This also encouraged readers to become more involved in the discussion, a point that Uribe could have made even more strongly.) Given Uribe’s rightful insistence that we should pay attention to the practical and financial aspects of a commercial venture such as a music journal, his conclusions regarding Marx’s largely idealistic approach to writing, and his interpretation of arrangements as secondary and aesthetically problematic versions of large-scale works, did not seem entirely persuasive (particularly given discussion elsewhere in this volume about the importance of music written for amateur performers). Marx’s desire to educate, encourage and entice a bigger public to engage with such repertoire, however, is vividly rendered – a fitting successor, in a different literary genre, to Telemann’s Der getreue Music-Meister. The volume closes with Peter Mondelli’s ‘Parisian Opera between Commons and Commodity, ca. 1830’. Mondelli takes a definition of ‘commons’ from Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, as a term which ‘can encompass “the languages we create, the social practices we establish, the modes of sociality that define our relationships”’ (p. 224).Footnote 2 The symbolism of French opera during this period, the moral and nationalist agendas of audiences (and censors), and the business relationships of opera houses with publishers and critics are discussed. It is only a pity that the one group of individuals given no real agency in the argument are those actually taking part in the opera – as composers and librettists but also as singers, instrumentalists and dancers.
Overall there is much absorbing information and food for thought within Consuming Music, and the great variety of case studies offer rich avenues for further scholarship, as well as some intriguing parallels between topics perhaps not usually connected. The book’s back cover mentions a supplementary website, https://consumingmusic.lib.utah.edu. Whilst there is little additional material available here at present, additional content and links to relevant online resources (such as Hofmeister XIX) would be a welcome and very useful addition to this project.Footnote 3
