This collection of essays is a welcome and timely addition to the hitherto limited body of scholarship engaging with the supernatural in James's work. As Anna Despotopoulou and Kimberly Reed note in their introduction to the volume, with the exception of James's novella The Turn of the Screw relatively little critical attention has been directed toward James's use of the ghostly. Two seminal works, Martha Banta's Henry James and the Occult (1972) and T. J. Lustig's Henry James and the Ghostly (1994), are the only book-length studies of his ghostly fiction that do not focus on The Turn of the Screw. Set against this critical backdrop, the initial appeal of Henry James and the Supernatural to scholars is twofold. First, the range of target texts compassed is comparatively vast, examining both the texts traditionally categorized as ghost stories and those regarded as realist or autobiographical. Second, the volume is the first compilation of essays on the topic of ghostly James, and the range of perspectives lends to its scope. No single voice dominates; instead eleven leading James scholars offer a variety of theoretical approaches to the ways in which James's interest in the supernatural blends with his engagement with Anglo-American culture. What emerges from close reading is the productive interplay of approaches which are distinct but not exclusive, producing a critical narrative which shadows and haunts itself: a ghost story.
The organization of the essays in the volume draws attention to the development of an investigation which illuminates James's philosophical and historical situatedness, engagement with issues of gender and sexuality, and linguistic strategies. Greg Zacharias examines the ghostliness of remembered experience in James's late fiction and autobiographical writings. For Kristin Boudreau, ghosts are an ontological trope. Boudreau scrutinizes both James's essay on immortality, “Is There a Life after Death?”, and the Kantian philosophical tradition, especially its embodiment in Ralph Waldo Emerson's “American Scholar,” whose distinction between the “dead fact” and “quick thought” is an important background source for Milly Theale's corpse-like life and animated afterlife in The Wings of the Dove. Hazel Hutchison also turns to philosophy, and particularly Swedenborg's development of the house as symbol of the soul, which “pervaded the literary and religious language of the nineteenth century, establishing an accepted synthesis between internal and external spaces” (62). So James's “The Altar of the Dead” emulates his travel writing by negotiating the architectural form of religious buildings to trace the positioning of consciousness between the physical world and a theorized spiritual plane of existence. Kevin Ohi's queer reading of James's tale “Maud-Evelyn,” in which a man falls in love with and “marries” a girl who died many years ago, focusses on a different spectral space, disentangling the tale's intricate narrative configurations to reveal the concealments and absences inherent in both the epistemology of the ghost story and the closet. Further interrogations of the ghostliness of James's style are made by Gert Buelens, who turns to speech-act theory and Judith Butler's notion of performativity to answer Virginia Woolf's question, “What use is made of the supernatural [in “Owen Wingrave”]?”, and Sheila Teahan, who uses rhetorical analysis of “The Great Good Place” to reveal in the ghostly a rendering of literary writing itself. The assertion that the ghostly, which in earlier chapters is held to animate human bodies and man-made artifices alike, can also inhere in units of language effectively demonstrates the versatility of the supernatural advanced in the volume as a whole.
So mobile is the supernatural in James's work that despite the well-wrought trajectory outlined above, the subject resists finality. Indeed, Nicola Bradbury uses her epilogue to the volume to offer not a definitive conclusion, but “encouragement [to other critics] to extend the endeavor” (183). After completing the volume, some avenues for future research establish themselves as preeminent. For instance, given that Henry James was acquainted with members of the Society for Psychical Research and their ideas, his personal and literary relationship with the occult milieu needs more rigorous exploration than is provided here. Aside from some valuable work done on The Turn of the Screw by Peter Biedler (1989) and others, this remains a blind spot of Jamesian criticism. However, to highlight such ghostly “absences” in the volume under review is in a sense to evidence its success in showing the richness of the field it discusses. The range of texts compassed, and methodological approaches employed by Henry James and the Supernatural, will render the volume an illuminating read for students both of James and of the ghost story as a subgenre.
