Jeffery Webber makes a provocative argument about contemporary Bolivian political economy. He says that, despite all its anti-neoliberalism rhetoric, Evo Morales' government has continued many of the features of Bolivia's neoliberal past, instituting what he calls ‘reconstituted neoliberalism’. The liberatory potential of the early 2000s, when indigenous and radical Left forces combined in mass mobilisations to overcome both racial and class exploitation, has been lost as Morales' MAS party has moved away from mass politics to electoral politics. Webber catalogues a disappointing slide to reformism, arguing that the ‘revolutionary epoch’ did not produce a true social revolution, but rather a ‘neo-structuralist’ development model that reinforces existing class and capitalist structures.
Webber stakes a strong claim that the Morales government is anything but post-neoliberal. While he acknowledges the importance of the nationalisation of gas as a massive source of state revenue, and the effects of modest redistribution to the poor through the bonos, or cash transfers, he argues that the basic composition of Bolivia's economic structure has not changed. The state continues to support the exploitation of raw materials by transnational corporations and agricultural production by a privileged lowlands elite. The state has not used the huge revenues from oil and gas sales to bring down the poverty levels or increase social spending. Worse, he suggests that instead of focusing on job production, the MAS has used these transfers ‘to construct a consensus among workers to submit to the imperatives of export-led capitalist development’ (p. 207).
Webber is aware that his interpretation of events in Bolivia will go against the grain for many on the Left, who hoped Morales would bring about the ‘cultural and democratic revolution’ he promised. Yet he argues forcefully for a reading that goes beyond discourse and rhetoric to a careful accounting of what the Morales government has actually done. We agree wholeheartedly with the need to pierce the discursive veil. Morales and his MAS government have been incredibly savvy, clothing their political and economic agendas with a powerful discourse of decolonisation that is too often reduced to a ‘folklorisation’ of indigenous culture. But Webber argues that the failed revolution is the result of the MAS government's artificial separation of the politics of indigenous liberation from revolutionary socialist transformation and its decision to push socialism to the back burner. Webber argues that this is a fatally flawed strategy because the ‘majority of the indigenous population also constitutes the bulk of the working classes and peasantry, whose full emancipation cannot be realised under capitalism, even a capitalism cloaked in an Andean-Amazonian guise’, a reference to the hybrid model put forward by Vice-President Alvaro García Linera. Here we see Webber's Marxist strategy of stripping away the ideology to show the supposedly hard realities of political economy beneath.
While this approach correctly points out that Bolivia's poor have not yet improved their lot, it fails to see many other aspects of Bolivian life that have changed significantly for the better. The government efforts towards ‘indigenous liberation’ that Webber dismisses as insignificant have in fact made great inroads against racism and produced a deeper sense of participation and citizenship among Bolivia's majority indigenous population. Most importantly, Webber does not give a clear picture of why the government has chosen the path it has or why the people of Bolivia, who have shown themselves capable of overthrowing presidents, continue to support it. We suggest that there are ongoing tensions between multiple objectives: development and redistribution, on the one hand, and overcoming the old regime of racism and privilege, on the other hand. These are not unconnected, as Webber suggests, but deeply intertangled such that any path forward feels contradictory. One may disagree with the choices the government is making, but it is clear that for the vice-president, at least, decolonisation can only be accomplished through industrialisation and redistribution. And many poor Bolivians agree. Webber focuses his lens on miners and workers, who have indeed had a rough time of it in the MAS years, but fails to include much analysis of the important efforts by social movements of indigenous people and women, in the Constituent Assembly and since, to push the government's agenda. Solidarity with the Bolivian people, it seems to us, requires recognising their agency in engaging these issues, as well as the many contradictions among them, rather than assuming they have been betrayed or duped.
This book will be a significant intervention to the ongoing scholarly discussion about post-neoliberalism, as it clearly articulates the ultra-Left critique of Morales' administration. In academic circles in the North Webber's assessment may seem surprisingly critical, although perhaps not as much as he seems to imply: many academics studying Bolivia have expressed cautious critiques all along. In Bolivia, however, critiques abound. Recently, a group of intellectuals and activists, many of whom had previously supported or worked for the Morales government, issued a ‘Manifesto for the Recuperation of the Process of Change’. They make many of the same arguments Webber makes: that the profits from the nationalisation have not produced real change, that the government's development model ignores the realities of the indigenous and peasant populations, and so on. Vice-President García Linera responded with a scathing ad hominem attack, accusing the ‘dissidents’ of being privileged NGO workers whose racist arguments support the positions of the Right and the neoliberals.
This points out the complex discursive field into which Webber's argument falls. Political actors who share Webber's desire to support the ongoing struggle for socialism echo his interpretation, but many other observers we have interviewed come to other conclusions. Many agree that Morales and friends are creating a tightly controlled state-centric form of national development. But who is benefiting? Few see the creation of a new national bourgeoisie based in indigenous communities, as promised under the government model. Rather, many argue that this centralisation is closer to Stalinist industrialisation during the 1930s. Others characterise it as a new form of colonialism, especially as the MAS government ignores the protests of indigenous people whose lands are being sacrificed for highways and resource extraction. People in Santa Cruz disagree strongly with Webber's claim that the Morales model benefits capitalism in general or the lowlands elite specifically. Instead, neoliberals and ‘anarcho-capitalists’ in the lowlands complain that the government development projects are disasters driven by politics rather than smart market decisions.
Clearly, the Morales revolution is being contested at every level. Webber's book gives us more to think about as we observe this fascinating political process.
