Affect, Animals, and Autists: Feeling around the Edges of the Human in Performance is an engaging, lively, and necessary exploration of the interconnections between animals and those humans deemed disabled. The book asks important, timely, and potentially controversial questions: What is human? What is animal? How do we intersect as affective beings within a binary world? To answer these, Marla Carlson engages with a wonderfully broad and eclectic range of performances that roughly spans the past fifty years of Western theatre practice and encompasses diverse voices, perspectives, and species.
Organized into six case studies, Affect, Animals, and Autists takes a thematic approach that foregrounds one element of its diverse subject matter at a time in order to “analyze the ways in which specific performances elicit categorical affects to manipulate their audiences, whether to affirm, expand, or obliterate the boundaries of the human” (13). Starting with an overt questioning of the human and what it means to take on an animal self in Chapters 1 and 2, the book shifts focus to think through autist and animal performance with live and represented nonhumans in Chapters 3–5. The book ends with a theoretical discussion of becoming animal through dance, and the ethical necessity of widening our understanding of “humanity” to encompass the label's perpetual instability and entanglement with animals. Doing so, Carlson argues, “makes it possible to move past anthropocentric privileging of the human over the inhuman, normate over anomalous bodies, neurotypical over neurodiverse ways of communicating and being in the world” (189).
This is an ethically aware and motivated book, one that is cognizant of the difficulties and pitfalls that come with placing those labeled aberrant alongside animals and the animalized. There are many potential negative implications of positioning these traditionally marginalized and oppressed groups side by side, and this book (in general) traverses this historical and methodological minefield quite well. However, there is overt hesitation in doing so. The chapters that explicitly look at autist voices and ways of being are rich with detail and provocative in their questioning, and evidently cover terrain familiar to the author. When it comes to animals, however, this book tends to struggle. While it provides a needed and beneficial exploration of autist voices and perspectives onstage, Affect, Animals, and Autists stops short of truly analyzing the interconnections between animals and the disabled as interwoven sites of shared affective experience. As such, the book does not escape its own anthropocentrism. Instead of engaging with animals in a way that is equally cognizant of their individual selves and unique ways of being in and seeing the world (as is handled well when neurodiverse people are the focus), animals onstage are often denied individuality, selfhood, and their own history, becoming instead objectified vehicles through which human affective response is generated.
For example, Chapter 2, “Performing as Animals,” focuses on plays such as Equus, The Lion King, and War Horse in order to analyze the representation of animals and their ability to create affect. Although audience responses are admirably captured, and the chapter provides fruitful inquiries into the role of technology and imagination in creating emotion, the questions of why the various species were selected and how they have been represented onstage in the way they have remain unanswered. Species matters, as does the historical and cultural context in which the represented animals lived and died, which is why Carlson's decision to discuss War Horse (written in 1982 and first staged in 2007) through the underresearched lens of equestrian imagery taken from the Renaissance through the Victorian period is an odd one. If audience affective response is important, then questioning what horses mean to them in a given context would aid in understanding their engagement with equine representation in puppetry. Similarly, as questions of the animal are always also gendered, racialized, classed, and unique to place and time, then engaging with what horses meant to an audience, and to the various people involved in the play's writing and production, would enrich the discussion. As it stands, even though a play such as War Horse is about horses, they are not adequately discussed as agents in their representation and in audience affect; the chapter elides equine individuality for the sake of audience response, but it also does not adequately analyze that response. Therefore, Carlson misses an opportunity and somewhat simplistically argues that audiences react to War Horse partially because they like horses but more so as a response to “the visible workmanship of these puppets in a manner not unlike the response one might have to artisanal cheese, craft beer, or hand-knit sweaters” (41).
Though Chapter 2 is the book's weakest chapter, questions of the animal, and Carlson's expanding of our understanding of affect and othered beings beyond the human, are admirably taken up in Chapter 4. In “Performing with Animals” Carlson takes the ethical imperatives of disability studies (such as establishing selfhood, recognizing voice, and seeing diverse ways of being) and broadens them to include animals. Engaging with Donna Haraway's animal-studies theories of “becoming-with” (117), while recognizing the subjectivity of live animals in the process of being human, this chapter is the least anthropocentric in the book. Bringing in porcine and equine selves, the chapter is an admirable and respectful questioning of what happens if we take animals as seriously as we take anomalous bodies and neurodiverse ways of being. The chapter's desire to move beyond anthropocentrism results in a powerful introduction to being human that is truly also animal, while making visible instances of nonhuman agency and expressions of selfhood.
Taken together, Affect, Animals, and Autists is an excellent first step toward asking difficult questions of bringing together the traditionally oppressed, persecuted, and subjugated. While Carlson remains hesitant in stating wider connections among case studies, and animals remain relatively absent from the text, Affect, Animals, and Autists provides an admirable analysis of disabled voices and representation in performance. The book has opened the door to the difficult arena where able and disabled, human and animal, and neurotypical and neurodiverse make up the “human” in ways that are all unique and wonderfully liberating.
