In For Labor to Build Upon: Wars, Depression, and Pandemic, William B. Gould IV offers a concise but thoughtful examination on the state of labor in the United States. Through a careful review of labor history and the development of labor law, Gould gives the reader much to consider about how labor can best deal with some of its current and most-pressing issues. Gould sees labor struggles—past, present, and future—as part of a larger effort to bring democracy to the workforce, which he argues is “an essential part of democracy itself” (p. 1) and is “central to the survival of a democratic society” (p. 2).
Early in the book, Gould makes clear that he sees any revival of labor’s current fortunes as tied to unions themselves, which he argues need to invest more of their resources into organizing workers. (Later in the book, he argues that as much as 30% to 50% of their budgets go to organizing, which is comparable to investments made in the 1930s; see p. 143.) Gould is less supportive of the more widespread belief that U.S. organizing laws largely explain declines in union membership, and that labor law reform is the primary answer for the labor movement to thrive as it once did. In his words, “the law is just one of the reasons for decline. Ultimately the law is a subordinate consideration” (p. 20).
To support his position, Gould provides historical background, going as far back as the Civil War period and the presidency of Abraham Lincoln. As the second chapter progresses, he covers other Republican presidents from Theodore Roosevelt through Herbert Hoover, concluding that “during this period, Republican presidents were not fundamentally different from their Democratic predecessors on some labor legislation” (p. 14). Nonetheless, Gould observes that “union trends oscillated wildly” at that time and were “reversed only by new emergency conditions … in the form of the Great Depression and the advent of [Franklin Roosevelt’s] New Deal” (p. 18). He summarizes, “Borrowing from constitutional principles of the post-Civil War era, the FDR administration ushered in new policy” (p. 19), which included the National Labor Relations Act. Gould, however, cautions that “change did not come simply through the statute itself. It was triggered through the willingness of organized labor and spontaneously activated worker groups to engage in audacious strikes” (p. 19).
Passage of the Taft-Hartley Act in 1947 made major changes to the National Labor Relations Act by adding restrictions to union activities, but Gould again warns against accepting the narrative that this is what caused labor’s eventual decline. He points out that “the Taft-Hartley amendments did not retard organized labor and lead to a decline in [union] membership … Quite the contrary, the labor movement continued to expand through 1955 and 1956” (p. 33).
Searching for a more satisfying answer to labor’s weakened position in recent decades, Gould takes the reader through more history in Chapter 3, examining the problems that health care policy and civil rights law sometimes presented for unions and their collective bargaining agreements. In Gould’s view, collective bargaining agreements often protected a “relatively limited number of the workforce” and “collided with the objectives of more effective legislation” (p. 40). This disrupted what Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. referred to as “unity of purpose” (p. 49), which damaged the labor movement.
In Chapters 4 and 5, Gould offers a more complete history to explain how crises – from World War I to World War II to the Korean War—all played a role in union growth. He then connects that history to the present-day COVID-19 crisis. The pandemic, in Gould’s view, has created another crisis environment that has the potential to bring about an increase in union membership if labor puts forward a serious enough effort to organize workers. In Chapter 6, Gould moves us into a more contemporary discussion on the emergence of the gig economy, delving into California’s Proposition 22, which gave app-based transportation and delivery companies the ability to classify their drivers as independent contractors as opposed to employees. This is a foreboding development for labor that seems likely to spread to other states.
Chapter 7 covers the student-athlete movement. It is in this chapter that Gould fails to dig into some of the complex issues that lie ahead for college sports. While the chapter offers a fine summary of recent legal challenges, including the landmark Supreme Court decision in NCAA v. Alston (2021), Gould never uses his intimate understanding of sports-labor issues to inform the reader of what the future might look like for university athletics, specifically if that future includes collective bargaining.
Indeed, in the Alston ruling, Justice Brett Kavanaugh raises the prospect that a fair way to determine revenue sharing between universities and players might come through the collective bargaining process. It then seems fair to ask: How exactly would this collective bargaining process work? What would the bargaining units look like? Would the bargaining unit be athletes in one school and on one team (as Northwestern football players attempted)? Or, would it be a much larger bargaining unit in which athletes in one sport at multiple universities bargain with their athletic conference or even the NCAA? Could the bargaining unit be even larger, representing all college athletes in all sports?
Put another way, if college athletes are to have a voice in the workforce—recall Gould’s point of emphasis that “democracy in the workforce is an essential part of democracy itself” (p. 1)—then how should the student-athlete movement proceed as it enters a new era? Will it be as a single voice for all college athletes? Or will it be a voice in which college athletes in high-revenue sports, such as college football, in the big money conferences such as the SEC and Big 10, speak for themselves and with the loudest voices in the collective bargaining process, while other athletes have a weaker voice or virtually no voice at all? Gould’s observations here would have been extremely valuable, particularly given his experience as a former NLRB Chairman who played a role in ending the 1994–1995 Major League Baseball strike, and would have added a much-needed layer of thought and analysis to what is a somewhat underwhelming Chapter 7.
These shortcomings aside, the book is still a success overall. As noted earlier, Gould’s central observation about the importance of workers’ voices to building a more equitable and democratic society is worth remembering. Too often, discussions about labor focus only on bread-and-butter issues, such as wages and benefits. Gould is correct in pointing us to something bigger.
He also provides a well-grounded perspective on what labor’s past can help teach us about its present and even its future. He sees no easy panaceas and avoids recycling some of the same tired and unworkable suggestions common among some labor scholars, such as forming a labor party, that too often find their way into otherwise well-written labor books. Gould’s practical assessment of labor’s past, present, and future is ultimately the book’s real accomplishment, and one that makes it worthy of recommendation for any student or scholar interested in learning more about and understanding the legal, political, and economic challenges that face today’s workers and labor movement.
