Fixed in the gleaming majesty of the famous sixth-century apse mosaics of San Vitale in Ravenna, or in the glittering prose of the panegyricist, late antique courtiers appeared to surround the emperors, in Mark the Deacon's shining phrase, ‘like stars which have come down to earth’ (VPorph. 47). These were brief glimpses of Heaven where the dreams of saints and holy men envisioned angels dressed in the magnificent official robes of high-ranking dignitaries. Heaven was politically stable, at least after the expulsion of Satan and the rebel angels. In the earthly realm, the regulation of the powerful — the detailed rank-order of the early fifth-century Notitia Dignitatum or the elaborate protocols of the much later De caeremoniis — offered moments of stillness in the unceasing competition at court: ‘the space around a ruler within which access to imperial favour is negotiated’ (Andrew Wallace-Hadrill in J. Duindam et al. (eds), Royal Courts in Dynastic States (2011), 97).
Gaining and Losing Imperial Favour in Late Antiquity offers nine studies of this courtly world from early-career scholars (four at time of publication were postgraduates). Together they explore the ‘diffuse and variegated’ court politics of the fourth and fifth centuries a.d. ‘where personal contacts played a pivotal role’ (6). Seven essays focus on particular texts or themes. Vedran Bileta considers Ammianus Marcellinus’ striking image of those nearest the emperor (proximi) locked in combat like gladiators and wild beasts in the amphitheatre — ut bestiarii obiceremur intractabilibus feris (15.3.23). Bruno Marien carefully reads a series of Symmachus’ letters in support of the disgraced Nicomachus Flavianus. Kamil Cyprian Choda considers John Chrysostom's attack on the Empress Eudoxia as a latter-day Herodias, arguing that, despite later fabrications, the abuse took the form of a sermon whose exegetical framework likely followed that of a homily on Matthew delivered in Antioch in 390 (no. 48 on Matt. 14). Maurits Sterk de Leeuw looks at Cyril of Alexandria's ‘blessings’ (his bribes to influential courtiers after the Council of Ephesus in 431). Martijn Icks gathers a useful set of examples of the hostile rhetoric of imperial seclusion. Fabian Shultz cleverly exposes the polemical representation of the Emperor Jovian by Athanasius’ orthodox supporters in the Petitiones Arianorum. Regina Fichera tells the story of the rise and fatal fall of the poet, grammarian and magician Pamprepius of Panopolis (440–484) whose prophetic insights into the politics of Zeno's reign finally failed to work out.
Taken together, these essays offer some interesting approaches to thinking about competition, confrontation and conflict between those closest to the emperor. Of course, a more cynical reader (or one more adept in the courtly arts) might prefer a less sympathetic reading of some of the texts studied here. Two examples. The letters of Symmachus, posthumously published by his son, are an undiluted act of filial piety. As Marien rightly notes, they present Symmachus as the key player in the rehabilitation of Nicomachus Flavianus. But why believe this version of Symmachus’ own (self-)importance? Perhaps Stilicho neither believed, nor was much moved by, the fulsome praises of Ep. 4.4; perhaps he did not particularly welcome these lengthy congratulations (119–21)? At least no particular need to think that Symmachus was able to dull any objections by writing letters ‘skilfully avoiding to mention what Nicomachus could be reproached for’ (122). It seems a safer assumption that Symmachus’ powerful addressees knew how to read, and react to, silences. Perhaps too one should be tougher on John Chrysostom than Choda. Rather than excusing Chrysostom's attack on Eudoxia as an unfortunate mis-step, the ‘inopportune’ actions of an Antiochene parvenu-cum-holy man unaccustomed to the complex conventions of court society in Constantinople (126, 147), it might be that Chrysostom was fully aware of the risks — and miscalculated.
For the editors, this volume's claim to originality rests on its application of sociological approaches to the workings of the late antique court (5). Two sociologists, in particular, are paraded in the introduction: Georg Simmel (1858–1918) for his thinking about the workings and effects of competition and Bertram Raven (1926–2020) for his Power/Interaction Model of Interpersonal Influence (2). For the most part, the majority of contributors to this volume struggled — dutifully, honestly — to show how their reading of texts was indebted to Simmel or Raven (e.g. 148, 159, 162–3, 202, 204, 214, 236). In truth, Raven seems to have had much less of an impact on the formation of key ideas. For all its merits, Raven's socio-psychology has not proved attractive to historians, and, as the editors note, there are methodological problems with Raven's own ventures into history writing (5 n. 12).
By contrast, the two opening essays (Isabelle Künzer and Christian Rollinger) engage thoughtfully and productively with Simmel's Soziologie der Konkurrenz, especially its emphasis on ‘triadic’ competition: ‘competitors do not compete directly over a scarce resource but rather fight to gain the “favour” (Gunst) of a third party (Dritter) which has the power to allocate this scarce good’ (38). Künzer, building on her important work on aristocratic competition in the Principate (Kulturen der Konkurrenz. Untersuchungen zu einem senatorischen Interacktionsmodus (2016)) emphasises the difficulty of establishing a ‘stable and transparent internal hierarchy’ (28) based on closeness to the emperor. ‘Competition at the Late Roman court occurred not so much because individuals might be temporarily unable to get close to the emperor, but because stakeholders could never be certain of their place’ (32). In turn, Rollinger notes that competition amongst rival courtiers also compelled them to cooperate (45), forming alliances in the scramble for ‘aulic’ or ‘courtly’ capital (64) and ‘the most sought-after resource of all: Kaisernähe and favour’ (66). In an uncertain courtly world, grand titles and ostentatious ceremony ‘were the prime medium by which success or failure in the aristocratic competition for status was communicated’ (63). Complex rituals ‘thus functioned as a finely-graded indicator of the totality of one's position’ (64). They were carefully posed snapshots of courtly life which exposed (as at San Vitale) the centrality of the emperor as ‘the fulcrum of aristocratic competition’ (37) and underlined (as in the Notitia Dignitatum) the importance of imperial favour as the key arbiter of prestige and reward.
Of course, images of imperial majesty were projected far beyond the narrow confines of the court. (It was the particular privilege of those close to the emperor — like angels before God — to behold him face-to-face.) Emperors and Emperorship in Late Antiquity offers nine essays from established scholars seeking to understand wider issues in the presentation and perception of imperial power. The focus is on Constantine (three papers), Julian and Theodosius I (two papers each). Each contribution aims to tease out a particular conjunction of imperial representations, visual and textual, in order to ‘disentangle the complex web of propagandistic formats that converge in the figure of the emperor’ and to explore (in an image clumsily re-purposed from Hans Christian Andersen's ‘The Emperor's New Clothes’) the ‘ideological wardrobe at the service of each emperor’ (8).
In Part I on Constantine, José B. Torres surveys images of purple in Pan. Lat. VI(7) and XII(9) and Eusebius’ Life of Constantine. In the first of two papers on the Arch of Constantine, Ignazio Tantillo notes the open display of civil conflict on the fourth-century panels which do not differentiate between the (Roman) armies of Constantine and the defeated Maxentius in two decisive battles in 312, at Verona and the Milvian Bridge. This brutal, internecine imagery is likely unprecedented in the city of Rome. (Torres's argument will need some adjustment if recent suggestions by C. Brian Rose (Journal of Roman Archaeology 34 (2021), 175–210) are accepted: that the fourth-century panels, with the exception of the Verona scene, are recycled from a monument honouring Diocletian.) T. is also right to draw attention (following, most recently, A. Maranesi, Koinonia 41 (2017), 211–27) to the condemnation in the Arch's dedicatory inscription of the (unnamed) Maxentius as a tyrant: tam de tyranno quam de omni eius factione (CIL VI.1139). ‘Before Constantine, in official documents or inscriptions, tyrannus had never been used for designating political adversaries of the reigning emperor’ (28).
This is all the more striking if, as Diederik Burgersdijk emphasises, the Arch was originally planned by Maxentius to celebrate the anniversary of the foundation of the city and his own decennalia (58, 65). Burgersdijk thus cautions against seeing the Arch as key to understanding the newly Christian Constantine's ‘propagandistic self-expression’ (54, 57). Some of the re-purposed relief sculpture, spoliated from monuments to Trajan, Hadrian and Marcus Aurelius, may originally have been selected to elaborate a different ideological programme. ‘Many of the Arch's ornaments might have had a different significance, possibly the choices of Constantine's defeated enemy who was his predecessor’ (58). From that point of view (here going further than Burgersdijk), the whole Arch can be understood as both the appropriation and the erasure of a rival. The Arch, dedicated in 315, now celebrates Constantine's decennalia, a ten-year anniversary of accession only possible in Rome if — as Mark Humphries pointed out (Journal of Late Antiquity 1 (2008), 95) — Maxentius’ reign (306–312) is expunged from history as the illegitimate rule of a tyrant.
In Part II on Julian, María Pilar García Ruiz offers a useful introduction to the Symposium/Caesars, especially the denigration of Constantine as a godless (literally) libertine and lover of luxury: ‘how did you so far forget yourself to lead the life of a pastrycook and hairdresser?’ (Jul. Caes. 335B). Álvaro Sánchez-Ostiz reads Ammianus Marcellinus’ astronomical excursuses, on rainbows, eclipses and comets, as establishing an interpretative framework in which Julian can be seen to accept his cosmic fate in contrast to Jovian and Constantius II who ‘failed to interpret the warnings and to properly react upon them’ (129).
Part III (‘From the Valentinians to Theodosius’) opens with Fabio Guidetti's handsomely illustrated survey of the stylistic choices in fourth-century imperial portraits. The block-like images of the tetrarchs ‘in which every element of the emperor's face takes on an autonomous role as the formulaic expression of an imperial quality’ (142) give way to the remote classicising harmony of the ageless and serene Constantine. The fuller portraits of Valentinian and Valens reach back to the smiling corpulence of fat-faced tetrarchs (notably Maxentius and Licinius), an image — in Guidetti's view — of ‘a vigorous, down-to-earth, accessible ruler’ (147). By contrast, the idealised and beautiful Theodosian images pushed the Constantinian model even further, ‘presenting the emperor as a super-human being, detached from earthly concerns, acting as an intermediary between God and the human world’ (169–70). María Victoria Escribano explores the rival images of the Christian emperors Valentinian II and Magnus Maximus — previously a usurper and after his defeat a tyrant — in Ambrose, Ep. 30 (staunchly pro-Valentinian) and Collectio Avellana 39 (an undiplomatic communiqué from Maximus to Valentinian in Milan in late 386). Alberto J. Quiroga Puertas reviews the contrasting claims of Christian (Ambrose and John Chrysostom) and non-Christian writers (Libanius and Zosimus) for credit in transforming Theodosius’ anger following the Riot of the Statues in Antioch in 387 into repentance and forgiveness. Particularly interesting is Quiroga's observation that anger in the Christian accounts does not simply give way to superior expressions of imperial virtue, but rather is itself presented as ‘a desirable emotional state if it led to the implementation of Christian virtues such as repentance and forgiveness’ (214).
Emperors and Emperorship in Late Antiquity closes with a fine essay by Daniëlle Slootjes who looks in detail at some of Theodosius’ interventions in the territorial definition of prefectures and dioceses, especially in Illyricum following the disastrous defeat of the Roman army at Adrianople in 378 and in Gaul after the overthrow of the (now) tyrant Magnus Maximus in 387. This is a paper — almost defiantly — without any glittering images, either material or textual. Rather, it is an attempt to exemplify how ‘the close connection between individual emperors, administrative structures and empire-wide developments’ (219) might be worked out for one emperor. Slootjes's paper shapes a thoughtful conclusion. It is a reminder that a full understanding of imperial power — alongside the helpful insights offered in these two volumes into the endless rivalries of proximi at court and the complex and varied strategies of imperial representation — must also embrace the often tedious and unglamorous day-to-day business of appointing officials and administering an empire.
