Kierkegaard was a prolific writer. He published more than twenty books during his lifetime and his collected journals and papers are even more voluminous than his published works. Few scholars have had the patience to familiarise themselves with the whole of what is, to many, Kierkegaard's unmanageably large corpus. Sylvia Walsh is one of these few.
Walsh has produced a number of valuable works on Kierkegaard including Living Poetically: Kierkegaard's Existential Aesthetics (Penn State University Press, 1990), Feminist Interpretations of Søren Kierkegaard (Re-Reading the Canon) (Penn State University Press, 1997) and her recent translation of Fear and Trembling for Cambridge Texts in the History of Philosophy (Cambridge, 2006). Living Christianly is arguably, however, her most important work yet. The real depth of Kierkegaard's philosophical insights has yet to be plumbed. There is no denying Walsh's claim in the introduction, though, that ‘Kierkegaard's foremost concern as a writer was to delineate how to become Christian and what the existential qualifications of Christianity are’ (p. 1). Kierkegaard's views on these two crucial issues are often difficult to decipher because of what has seemed to more than one reader to be the perverse and abstruse manner in which he develops them. It is not that Kierkegaard is difficult to read. He is an extraordinarily gifted prose stylist. It is that he is difficult to understand. He does not write in the straightforward axiological style typical of scholars but uses a variety of parables and literary personae to get his point across.
Walsh deftly guides the reader in piecing together the puzzle of Kierkegaard's authorship. ‘Kierkegaard's purpose’, asserts Walsh, ‘in depicting the existential qualifications of Christianity was more evangelical than theological’ (p. 5). That is, his primary concern was not the communication of information relating to the doctrinal essence of Christianity, though much of his authorship is concerned with just that. Kierkegaard's main objective was to facilitate spiritual conversion.
Many readers are alienated by Kierkegaard's often harsh portrayal of the demands of Christian existence. Walsh argues, however, that Kierkegaard's view of Christianity was not really as harsh as it can sometimes seem. She maintains that Kierkegaard was reacting to what he considered a watered-down version of Christianity that had made the demands of Christian existence so lenient that, in his mind, it actually did away with the need of the central message of Christianity: grace. Kierkegaard often stressed the demands of Christian existence to an extreme that can seem inhumane. Walsh explains that Kierkegaard's ‘foremost intent was to assert the positive in and through the negative, not to advance a purely negative characterisation of Christian existence’ (p. 160; emphasis added). Dialectic, Walsh asserts, is central to Kierkegaard's thought. Every passion, according to Kierkegaard, including religious passion, has its own dialectic (cf. e.g. Either-Or, trans. Howard V. Hong and Edna H. Hong. 2 vols. (Princeton University Press, 1987), vol. 1:159). She asserts that, according to Kierkegaard, ‘[i]mitation is thus used dialectically in Christianity to train Christian strivers in the need for grace so that they may effectively flee to it in faith and not use it in vain (Søren Kierkegaard's Journals and Papers, trans. Howard V. Hong and Edna H. Hong, assisted by Gregor Malantschuk (Bloomington and London: Indiana University Press, 1967–78), vol. 1:692; 2: 1785, 1905, 1906)’ (p. 158). ‘Thus Christianity’, she explains, ‘may be seen as consolation and mildness only as or after its rigor is imposed. The law becomes’, she continues, quoting Kierkegaard, ‘“the greater the rigorousness, the greater the consolation” (JP 3:3502). Christian consolation’, explains Walsh then in her own words again, ‘is primarily intended to relieve the Christian striver's anguished conscience over his or her sin’ (p. 142). In short, the demand must be presented as so great that one cannot help but fail in one's efforts to meet it. Kierkegaard, unlike Kant, clearly thought that no matter how close one came to meeting an absolute demand, no matter how much progress one might feel he had made over time relative to meeting this demand, to fail to meet it entirely was to fail utterly. This failure, Kierkegaard believed, would bring with it an anguish so excruciating that only the Christian promise of forgiveness could relieve it.
The Christian demand of moral perfection, or of the imitation of Christ, was not in Kierkegaard's mind something he manufactured to facilitate the sale of an otherwise useless Christianity to religious consumers. The requirement of moral perfection was, for Kierkegaard, as it was for Kant, built into the contents of human consciousness. The difficulty, Kierkegaard believed, was that the anguish of imperfection was so great that people were naturally afraid to confront it in the manner required to obtain the cure. Much of Kierkegaard's authorship, even while it is therapeutic, is thus not designed to make the reader feel better, but to manoeuvre him into a position where he will be forced to acknowledge just how wretched he feels in the hope that he will then reach out for what Kierkegaard believed was the only possible restorative.
Walsh follows these efforts from the period of the publication of the Postscript in 1846 until the very end of Kierkegaard's authorship with his death in 1855. Living Christianly is a substantial scholarly achievement. It will be an invaluable resource to scholars and an inspiration to those who have resisted the view that Kierkegaard's conception of Christian existence became increasingly negative towards the end of his life. Now, finally, we have some of the most crucial pieces of the puzzle of Kierkegaard's authorship firmly pressed into place. Readers will be pleased, I believe, with what they see.
