Those of us who write books concerned with contemporary politics tend to be haunted by an often irrational concern: that once the manuscript is complete, the page proofs are returned, and the book is finally in press, world events will shift so dramatically as to render the final product suddenly outdated. At first glance, this is what appears to have happened with Eva Wegner's valuable new work, Islamist Opposition in Authoritarian Regimes. Soon after its release in 2011, the “opposition” Islamist party that is the book's focus—Morocco's Party of Justice and Development (PJD)—swiftly, and in many ways unexpectedly, became a governing Islamist party.
Yet despite this turn of events and the book's dated title, Wegner's work could not be more timely, relevant, and important. As Islamist movements across the Middle East and North Africa continue to develop into political parties, and as these parties shift their focus from opposition to governance, careful, field-based research is needed to better understand their political behavior. Wegner's book, which is based on interviews she conducted in 2003, 2004, and 2007 with PJD members of Morocco's parliament, begins to fill this void. The author seeks to explain why Islamist parties have developed in the ways that they have; how they have acted in opposition; what factors have influenced their decision making; and, finally, how they have related to the authoritarian regimes that once dominated the politics of the region (and, in some cases, continue to do so). To accomplish these goals, she develops a heuristic model of Islamist party development, showing how these parties’ choices have been shaped by their complex organizations, by institutional constraints, and by their relationships with their founding movements. Here, Wegner successfully situates Islamist parties not as analytically anomalous, but rather within the study of political parties writ large. The author constructs her model around a detailed case study of the PJD, and the four main chapters of the book are dedicated to understanding different aspects of the party's politics and development. Chapter 5 offers a comparative look at Jordan's main Islamist party, the Islamic Action Front.
While the world paid far more attention to revolutionary protests in nearby Tunisia and Egypt in 2011, Morocco experienced its own version of an “Arab Spring.” Attempting to stave off larger protests, King Mohammed VI proposed constitutional reforms, acquiesced to new elections, and, most importantly, agreed to bestow the coveted position of prime minister upon the winner of those elections. In December 2011, the PJD dominated the parliamentary elections, the first since 2007, winning 107 of 395 seats in parliament.
Perhaps the most valuable contribution Wegner makes relates to the organizational evolution of Islamist parties, a subject that is the focus of Chapter 2. When we write about and talk about groups such as the Muslim Brotherhood (the movement which PJD once sought to emulate) we tend to conceptualize them as unified, whole organizations. Wegner shows that reality, of course, is far more complex. In the PJD's case, its history with its now allied but once founding group, the Movement of Unity and Reform, suggests just how multilayered and diverse these movements actually are. Thus, Islamist parties do not suddenly appear sui generis, but rather as a “direct product” of an affiliated or external movement. And the influence of this external movement on the eventual party, she argues, will depend on the “party's degree of formal and informal dependency” on it (p. xxxvii). Indeed, her study provides a good jumping-off point for those who may want to think about the relationship, for example, between the Egyptian President Mohammed Morsi's Freedom and Justice Party and its affiliated movement, the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood.
Readers could have benefited from more attention to the complex religiopolitical contexts in which the PJD originated and still competes, from a broader analysis of key thinkers, and from the voices of the party's rank and file. But these are quibbles, especially because what makes this study valuable is its sharp and singular focus on one party and one set of concerns.
In the end, Wegner shows that the PJD's rise was not inevitable, and she maintains that the party's failure to win the 2007 elections was due both to the fact that it had pulled too far away from its founding movement and to a perception that it had been co-opted by the regime, thus creating a “credibility trap” (p. 121). But as recent events suggest, the party seems to have taken a different lesson. The PJD chose a close ally of the monarchy as its new leader, and when some of its competitors on the left and the right mobilized against the regime in the protests of 2011, the party remained largely on the sidelines. It solidified its decision to seek power through the country's existing, albeit imperfect, political processes, and that calculus, at least in the short term, seems to have paid off. While the party may have swallowed some of its pride, its candidates now occupy the prime ministership and a substantial number of cabinet posts.
But the story does not end here. The PJD's experiences in government thus far—particularly its struggles for some semblance of independence from the monarchy and its vast apparatus—pose new sets of problems for both Islamists and for the scholars studying them. When parties play by the (stilted) rules of the game to procure power, how likely is it that they can resist those rules once in power? And will voters ultimately punish these parties because the reality of their rule could never possibly fulfill their promises?
These are dilemmas that policymakers and scholars of the region will continue to grapple with, and Wegner's detailed book is a useful place to begin. Her theoretical analysis will be of interest to those engaged in the investigation not just of political Islam but of political parties more generally. Thus, Wegner's book—which proves once again that Islamist parties do not exist in analytical bubbles—will certainly stand the test of time.
