Melody Mohebi's The Formation of Civil Society in Modern Iran: Public Intellectuals and the State is a succinct yet informative read. Mohebi's goal is to analyze the role of “reformist public intellectuals” in amplifying the notion of “jame'e-ye madanī” (civil society) during the presidency of Mohammad Khatami (1997–2005). In constructing her narrative, Mohebi first broadly defines civil society as the process by which citizens monitor the state and the monopoly of power within the country, and then successfully summarizes both the theory behind the formation and specifications of civil society, as well as the civil society's nuanced and versatile presence in 20th-century Iran, in particular, after the 1979 Islamic Revolution.
The book begins by outlining major themes and discussing methodology, and moves on to explore the theoretical underpinning of the concept of civil society and social movements. Mohebi then explores the “relevant historical context” (p. 45) of Iran as it relates to civil society, where she draws on social movements and organized activities that took place in Iran in the 20th century. She argues that the formation of a rentier state—where the state's income is obtained through means other than taxation, such as sale of oil—and the predominance of a religious welfare system through the practice of charity and taxation in Shiʿi Islam effectively traded the function of the state with that of the religious establishment prior to the Islamic revolution. Support from the religious establishment was vital for the success of social movements in 20th-century Iran—from the success of the Tobacco Protest, reinforced by religious edicts, to the fractioning of the National Front, in parts, as a result of disagreement over religious law. Mohebi focuses further on the intellectual discourses such as those promoted by the Tudeh party, as well as public intellectuals such as Jalal Al-i Ahmad and Ali Shariʿati, which contributed to the maturing of civil society between the 1906 Constitutional Revolution and the 1979 Islamic Revolution.
Mohebi looks at other significant public intellectuals such as Abdulkarim Soroush and publications such as the Kiyan Journal, which initiated discourse about civil society prior to the reform period under Seyyed Muhammad Khatami. In conjunction with the influence of these intellectuals, Mohebi explores the role of “typical, conventionally recognized civil society ‘practitioners’” (p. 99), looking at both their participation in civil society and the formation of nongovernmental organizations, which transformed the Iranian populace from passive observers to active participants. Finally, Mohebi discusses the dichotomy of the conservative figures’ twofold approach to civil society. The conservatives capitalized on the language and structure of civil society through establishing Islamic foundations, the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, and the Basij. At the same time, they rejected civil society as a Western concept, and argued that it is detrimental to the Islamic Republic. Mohebi concludes by pointing out that varying definitions of civil society in Iran as offered and practiced by the different political factions resulted in differing implications vis-à-vis its emergence in the country. This in turn introduced complexity in both form and function to Iranian civil society, where the reformist nongovernmental organization and the Basij can both be considered key participants. The author advocates as well that focusing on the role and influence of key individuals—as “agents of social change” (p. 152)—on society's reception and perception of civil society will help us better understand the “political dynamics of [Iran's] civil society” (p. 152).
One of the unique features of the book is the author's use of personally conducted interviews with reformist public intellectuals, students, women's rights activists, journalists, and a number of conservatives. Excerpts from the interviews are used as primary source material to substantiate or supplement her argument. Mohebi is critical of the scholarly literature's use of inappropriate definitions—either too scholarly to function in real life or offered by donor agencies in justifying their work. Instead, she often includes the definitions of concepts provided by the interviewed reformists alongside the prevailing theory and ideology, which certainly aids the reader in understanding the concept from the perspective of the reformists. In order to protect the identity of the interviewed individuals, the author introduces them with an alphanumeric codename. While it is possible to offer a few educated guesses as to the identity of a number of the characters, many of her informants are reduced to what the author tells us about them, which may or may not be accompanied with excerpts from interviews. Therefore, in the absence of supplementary full-text interviews, the reader cannot know the context within which a statement was placed nor the intention behind it. As such, it is impossible to form an independent opinion of the meaning the interviewed subjects intended to convey, and whether or not the excerpts can be used in the context that Mohebi uses them.
At times, the author forgoes an opportunity to successfully make her point and instead uses theory she has already introduced earlier in the book. One such example is the case of the revival of city councils during Khatami's presidency. Mohebi states that the conservatives were against the formation of city councils as they saw them adding no value to their political project while being significantly costly. However, Mohebi quickly moves on without further analyzing the situation. The inclusion of city councils into the Iranian constitution as the local arm of the legislative branch was due to the insistence of Ayatollah Taleghani who believed in the importance of public participation in politics. Although city councils had already formed in some cities (such as Marivan and Sanandaj) with the death of Ayatollah Taleghani in September of 1979, the idea was completely abandoned. The struggle of the new government to centralize power in the middle of a war with Iraq, while putting down unrest caused by regional demands in areas populated by ethnic minorities such as Kurdistan, Azerbaijan, and Baluchistan, further contributed to the abandonment of the idea of city councils. The councils were meant to serve as public spaces where the authoritarian power of the state could have been challenged and potentially curtailed through the election of individuals over whom the central government had little control. In Kurdistan alone, the initial round of elections for city council put in charge locally known and politically involved individuals whose activism stood at stark opposition to that of the government and ushered in what Mohebi earlier calls “a shift away from centralized administration to local oversight” (p. 94). That many of these individuals were later executed during Ayatollah Khalkhali's sojourn to Kurdistan in August of 1979 is evidence of the government's reluctance to place such administrative power in the hands of individuals over whose election they had no oversight, and which in turn demonstrates that abandonment of the councils was necessary to maintain power in the hands of the central government.
The book has a few editorial slip-ups. There are a number of transliteration mistakes, the most striking example is the transliteration offered for the word “varied” as matnoo (p. 72) which I can only guess is a misreading of motanave. The Persian ezafeh (denoted as –ye) is often absent from the transliterations. Hossein-Ali Montazeri is first referred to as Hossein Montazeri (p. 63) and later by the correct full name (p. 69).
Despite these issues, Mohebi offers unique insight into the fostering of a public sphere during the eight years of reform. This book is ideal for assigning in an undergraduate course.
