Bret Harte, the founding editor of the Overland Monthly, and Anton Roman, its original owner, had very different goals for the magazine. Roman wanted it to promote “the material development of this Coast” and feared with good reason that Harte would “lean too much toward the purely literary articles.” In fact, Harte resisted Roman's brand of civic boosterism and joked in his editorials, for example, about the earthquake that struck San Francisco in October 1868. According to Noah Brooks, Harte treated the topic “with a levity which some of the dignified dons of the city found unbecoming.”Footnote 1 He was much more interested in earning a national reputation than in promoting the commercial prospects of the West Coast.
Unfortunately, Stephen J. Mexal in Reading for Liberalism ignores this fundamental disagreement over the purposes to which the magazine might be put. On the contrary: Mexal asserts that, like Roman, “Harte had a vested interest in encouraging migration and tourism to the West” (x) and insisted “that the magazine serve the economic, political, and intellectual development of a liberal California public” (24), and that they shared a “stated goal of development” (64). Not true. The error is but one of many comparable mistakes: e.g. that “Harte's subject matter – the West – did not really change” throughout his career (3); that Mark Twain “would not publish his wry critique of Cooper” until 1895 (135), whereas he publicly excoriated so-called “Cooper Indians” as early as chapter 19 of Roughing It (1872); that during the late nineteenth century, “the dominant generic modes of American fiction began to shift away from romanticism and toward literary realism and naturalism” (189), a gross overgeneralization; and that Harte's “The Luck of Roaring Camp” is a “little political fable, in which the presence of an outsider ushers a loose aggregate of state-of-nature individuals into liberal–republican modernity” (216), a conclusion that overlooks the fact that by the close of the story the camp is destroyed by a flood of biblical proportions.
Put another way, Mexal's study fails to transcend its origins in the dissertation he completed at the University of Colorado in 2007. His implicit contention that there was an “Overland group” (232, 247) of writers, editors, and publishers who promulgated western “liberalism” over a period of sixty years often seems forced and contrived and, at best, fails the “so what?” test. His repeated discussions of “liberalism,” indeed, are mostly distracting. (The interested reader ought to skip the first chapter entirely.) He concedes that “liberalism can mean different things to different people at any particular moment in time” (11); that is, “liberalism” means pretty much whatever Mexal wants it to mean. His argument is not advanced by his occasional descents into Stengelese, the private language of Casey Stengel, one-time manager of the New York Yankees, as in this statement: “If American liberalism comes from Locke, and Lockean natural law places modernity, liberal civil society, and civilization into a binary opposition with premodernity, the violence of Hobbesian freedom, and ‘savagery,’ then liberalism itself cannot be decoupled from the opposition” (10).
To the extent that Mexal's book succeeds, in my opinion, it does so not as a thesis-driven analysis of the political and philosophical values that circulated in the Overland Monthly but as a history of the magazine. Mexal should be commended for recovering selections of Noah Brooks's short fiction, John Muir's early nature writing, and Ina Coolbrith's poetry – a modest but sufficient accomplishment.
