According to its author, Michael Heller, “the goal of this book is to examine histories and discourses surrounding New York's so called ‘loft jazz era,’ one of the least-understood periods in jazz histories” (3). Heller defines the loft jazz era as “a dense network of musician-run performance venues established (mostly) in and around the former industrial buildings of lower Manhattan” (3), which includes venues such as Sam Rivers's Studio Rivbea (24 Bond St.), Rashied Ali's Studio 77/Ali's Alley (77 Greene St.), and Hakim Jami and Joe Lee Wilson's Ladies’ Fort (2 Bond St.). His work responds to jazz survey texts which portray the 1970s as a time of dissent and contentiousness and corrects this tendency by following in the footsteps of Scott DeVeaux, Robin D. G. Kelley, Ingrid Monson, Eric Porter, Ronald Radano, and Guthrie Ramsey. He foregrounds stories of solidarity, organization building, self-sufficiency, collaboration, and friendship in jazz while demonstrating how loft organizers pursued “a diverse range of artistic and social priorities that were not always evident to the listening public” (6).
To reconstruct a history of the loft jazz era, Heller relied on two main methodologies. He conducted close to one hundred interviews with loft jazz participants including multi-instrumentalist Cooper-Moore, bassist Steve Tintweis, and saxophonist Mark Whitecage. He also engaged with loft organizer Juma Sultan's private archives. As Heller acknowledges, loft jazz sources “survive as singular, unpublished, hidden artifacts that remain in private hands. Since these sources are not generally accessible in record stores, and have not yet been catalogued in libraries or posted online, a deep engagement with private archives is necessary in order to reconstruct the loft period” (8).
Heller divides his book into two separate sections. The first section, “Histories,” provides a relatively chronological history of New York's loft jazz and its predecessors in Ornette Coleman's Artist House (131 Prince St.), James DuBoise's Studio We (193 Eldridge St.), and the organization of the New York Musicians’ Jazz Festival in 1972. Heller also refers to the works of George Lewis, Benjamin Looker, and Steven Louis Isoardi, who have documented other collectives in Chicago (Association for the Advancement of Creative Musicians), St. Louis (Black Artists’ Guild), and Los Angeles (Union of God's Musicians and Artists Ascension). In particular, he focuses on the ways that musicians’ collectives, combined with the deteriorating economic conditions of Manhattan and the Lower East Side, helped facilitate the rise of jazz venues in former industrial lofts.
Each of the chapters in the second section, “Trajectories,” focuses on a different aspect of the loft scene: freedom, community, space, and archive. In Chapter 4, Heller describes the multiple, and sometimes conflicting, ways loft musicians articulated freedom. As one example, Heller notes that musicians sometimes adopted Arabic, Swahili, or African-inspired names (such as Ali Abuwi and Ahmed Abdullah); converted to Islam or engaged in transcendental spirituality, lived “off the grid”; and/or performed dense, “sonically intense” music. Similarly, drawing upon his interview data, Heller observes that loft performers defined “community” in four different but overlapping ways: pay, place, space, and race. Pay discourses arise when musicians identify economic strategies as the distinguishing feature of loft community; play discourses describe loft collectivity in terms of musical practices; place discourse emphasizes the role of geography, particularly the Lower East Side of Manhattan; and race discourses overtly connected loft practices to concerns of the black community and/or the civil rights movements. Heller argues that the loft jazz scene ended in the 1980s when all of these four systems gradually broke down and failed to hold meaning. Rising rents made it difficult for loft organizers to stay afloat economically (pay) while neo-traditionalist musicians such as Wynton Marsalis gained popularity and avant-garde styles moved out of the lofts into non-loft venues (play). Gentrification pushed many artists out of their spaces (place), and 1960s-style nationalist rhetoric gave way to a new generation of white avant-gardists such as John Zorn and Eugene Chadbourne (race).
In Chapter 6, Heller shows how loft musicians described loft venues as large, raw spaces. He refers to sociologist Sharon Zukin's 1988 book Loft Living, which describes the nostalgic reasons many upper-class residents moved into industrial lofts during the 1970s and 1980s. Heller shows, however, that loft performers emphasized the liberatory potential of blank spaces, as opposed to nostalgic echoes of industrial space, when describing their venues. In addition, they viewed their venues as domestic spaces that blurred both public/private and male/female boundaries. In Chapter 7, Heller looks at private archives, like Sultan's, and the advantage and limitations of different storage material: audio tape, paper, and human memory. He suggests that historians should look at archives as a generative force rather than a passive repository.
Heller is, without a doubt, the leading scholar on New York's loft jazz community. In Loft Jazz, he provides an engaging, in-depth, and long-awaited study of the period, although he admits “this work makes no attempt at providing a comprehensive treatment of the loft era” (13). He provides some possible avenues for future studies on loft jazz, such as “the politics of gender, the development of specific musical techniques, the commercial discographies of loft artists, and the scene's connections with other experimentalist communities in lower Manhattan (from minimalism to punk rock)” (14). These are all wonderful suggestions, but I would like to add one more.
As Heller shows, loft musicians benefited generously from state and federal organizations such as New York's Department of Cultural Affairs and the New York State Council on the Arts. However, he does not tell us why governmental officials might have chosen to subsidize loft musicians or how their subsidies impacted the musicians and contributed to the gentrification of Lower Manhattan. A good point of departure for pursuing this line of inquiry might be Iain Anderson's This is Our Music: Free Jazz, the Sixties, and American Culture, which discusses free improvisation and nonprofit sponsorship of the arts in detail.Footnote 1 Notwithstanding these few concerns, Heller has written a succinct, lean, and focused book that provides a substantive foundation for exciting new scholarship in free jazz and experimental communities.
