In The Patagonian Sublime, Marcos Mendoza provides a detailed and convincing analysis of the workings of the green economy in Argentina. With its rigour and insightful treatment of its subject matter, this book is a welcome addition to the still-fragmented scholarship on conservation in Latin America. It achieves at least two significant contributions for which it deserves a wide readership. First, it goes to great lengths to situate the contemporary conservation efforts in Patagonia within the broader political economy of Argentina and beyond. It thus provides a clear analysis of the scalar dynamics of conservation, effectively showing how events on the ground are conditioned by economic, cultural and political dynamics elsewhere. Second, it delivers a detailed account of the local configurations of the conservation economy. It is not a standard conservation monograph focused on rural dispossessions and displacements. Instead, Mendoza meticulously leads the readers through the different groups involved in the production of the so-called green economy. Combined, this makes for a book which is compelling in its argumentation and style, innovative in its approach to the field, and yet accessible by virtue of the flow of language. The accompanying photographs throughout the book enhance the overall impression of a rewarding and generous book.
The Patagonian Sublime consists of four parts and an introduction and conclusion. Part 1 examines the sphere of tourist consumption. It focuses on two groups, which have come to shape the tourist geographies in El Chaltén, the northern tourist hub in the Glaciers National Park of Patagonia. First, the mountaineers, who may be few in number, but whose presence and perseverance contribute to the production of the idea of the Patagonian sublime. This refers to the imaginary of pristine wilderness and human bravery so crucial to the conservation-tourism landscape. Second, the trekkers, who in their search for experiences of the sublime add substantially to the region's tourist economy through their engagement in ecotourism. Part 2 directs attention to the sphere of service production. Mendoza divides service production into two groups, dedicating a chapter to each. First, the entrepreneurs who come to El Chaltén to invest and set up businesses. Second, the golondrinas, or seasonal labourers, who come to the area to provide labour but often also to join the wilderness experiences of the area. Part 3 turns to the role of conservation in the green economy of Patagonia. By looking at community-based conservation and land management, the first chapter of this part highlights how scientific sustainability discourse is used by the park management to produce a public whose interests coalesce around conservation. The second chapter turns to the role of the active educational policing of the park rangers which aims to produce a particular ‘conservation’ subject position amongst tourists. The fourth and final part serves to tie the three spheres together in a discussion of the politics of the green economy as it plays out in the constitution of community in El Chaltén and its links to the broader political economic project of presidents Néstor Kirchner and Cristina Fernández de Kirchner and, thus, the convergence between the seemingly contradictory economic projects of extraction and protection in contemporary Argentina. In post-neoliberal Argentina, the green economy does not exclude the neo-developmentalism of mineral and hydrocarbon extraction, and large-scale agribusiness.
Mendoza employs some cross-cutting conceptual figures, which help him structure the argument and link the disparate chapters together. They ensure that this book, so rich in time- and place-specific insights, will travel well to other contexts where the green economy also works to restructure livelihoods and landscapes. The green economy – ‘any mode of economic activity that facilitates environmental protection, health and well-being’ (p. 8) – is a term which in its real-life application refers to ideas of sustainable development that have come to restructure national politics, policies and planning documents. Green growth and economics often claim that one of the objectives is the promotion of social inclusion and equality, but this book manages well to show how the green economy exacerbates inequality between tourists, operators, entrepreneurs and others. As Mendoza suggests, this is but an expansion of capitalist economic reasoning, which for El Chaltén operates through the spheres outlined above: consumption, provision and conservation. The way different processes and actors come together in the green economy allows Mendoza to understand how subject positions come into being through agency and imagination, which are subjugated to wider operations of power. In Patagonia's green economy, risk is a key creative force in the production of these subject positions: risk, as it relates to mountaineering and trekking, entrepreneurship and service provision, and ecology and policing. The ‘Patagonian risk society’ thus emerges in different configurations throughout the chapters, where different social actors seek to position themselves to minimise exposure and enhance certainty and security in the volatile ecological, economic and political environments of Patagonia.
The Patagonian Sublime provides a great understanding regarding the workings of Patagonia's green economy, and how the political and economic dynamics of this seemingly faraway region are deeply entangled with national-level politics and the transnational movement of people, capital and imaginaries. El Chaltén was only founded in 1985. However, the indigenous peoples and the settler colonists who later came to the area retain a spectral presence in the book. We learn little about how the green economy of El Chaltén stretches beyond the narrow confines of the national park and populated centre, and how its existence is conditioned by the erasure of other ways of inhabiting the landscape. The structure of the book is both its strength and weakness: while it elegantly illustrates the ways in which the green economy in El Chaltén operates in the three interlinked spheres, it comes at the cost of ethnographic depth because of the speed by which Mendoza leads the reader through engaging vignettes and personal stories. This also has consequences for our understanding of how some of the empirical examples contribute to the overall argument. Notwithstanding these critiques, the book is likely to find a readership amongst regionalists interested in contemporary Patagonia, as well scholars focused on the workings of the green economy and conservation policies on a global scale. Its writing style captures different levels of complexity, and the book will therefore be useful for teaching on both undergraduate and graduate courses of anthropology, geography, political ecology and environmental sciences. It is also a pleasure to read if one simply wants to read a good book.
