Dissertations often impose organization that is intellectually rigorous but discouraging for the general reader. Like the old style Doctorats de troisiême cycle, they repeat to you along with the fresh material too much that you already knew. Van der Blom is a serious and careful scholar but for this reader the solid merits of her book (of which more later) were diminished by the comprehensive arguments of the first half of this study, which take Ciceronian exempla and list them first in the context of a given work, then by genre (judicial and political speeches, letters, treatises), then by date or phase in Cicero's career. As B.'s valuable bibliography (around 600 items) shows, much — too much? — has already been written about Cicero's use of exempla and the invocation of the mos maiorum. Listing only work focused on Cicero since 1990 we have Bettini, ‘Mos, mores and mos maiorum’, in Braun, Haltenhoff and Mutschler, Moribus antiquis res stat Romana virisque (2000), 303–52; Hölkeskamp (1995), reprinted in Glitzke Möller, Exempla und Mos Maiorum: Uberlegung zur Kollektiven Gedächtnis der Nobilitas; Linke-Stemmler's Historia Einzelschrift: Mos maiorum (2000); Bücher, Verargumentierte Geschichte; Exempla Romana (2000); Oppermann, Zur Funktion Historische Beispiele in Ciceros Briefe (2000); and Stemmler, Auctoritas exempli: zur Wechzelwirkung von kanonisierte Vergänglichkeitsbildern und Gesellschaftlichen Gegenwart in der spätrepublikanischen Rhetorik (2000). Many of these excellent studies are German, but we must face the fact that study of exemplarity, particularly Ciceronian exemplarity, is now suffering from the Law of Diminishing Returns. Nor does B.'s section on definition of the historical exemplum and personal exemplum help greatly in particularizing this common rhetorical phenomenon: since Cicero takes on the persona of a wise and patriotic statesman he will assimilate himself to rather than differentiate himself from all the traditional good examples of Rome's past.
The most remarkable and stimulating aspect of this book is only hinted at in the keyword ‘newcomer’ of its subtitle. For the last century definitions of novitas and nobilitas have given rise to continuing dispute about what constitutes novitas, and how it is relevant to the rising statesman's career. Cicero, himself a proud novus, makes hay with the issue in two of his defence cases — defending the newly-elected consul Licinius Murena (during his own consulship) and the less important Plancius; in each case he claims that the prosecutor, a disappointed rival candidate, has made it an issue against his own client that, as a novus, he had less expectation of being elected without hanky-panky than the noble Laterensis or Sulpicius Rufus. Novitas was only significant in the run-up to elections and probably in evaluating past consulships.
Let us test Cicero's consistency in treating this issue in Mur. 15–17. The military praetorian Murena was son of a successful praetor awarded a triumph — a man apparently cheated of his consulship by death; Murena was also grandson and great grandson of other praetorian generals. Short of a consular father, what was lacking to his noble status? Unless perhaps we acknowledge that Rome systematically elected military commanders as praetors like Pomptinus and Flaccus in 63 b.c.e. because she needed legates, but implicitly excluded them from the real summit of consular standing. In contrast, Sulpicius, like Aemilius Scaurus the Elder (cos. 115 b.c.e), suffered from father and forefathers who had fallen short of office, and so were virtual new men: Scaurus would win his dominant position by virtus and industria in the tradition of actual upstart new men like Cato the Censor and Marius; here Sulpicius failed because he had not chosen the public face of rhetoric but the back-room boy academic exercise of legal scholarship, and was proclaiming himself a loser by his threats of prosecution.
B.'s account of Scaurus and Cicero's use of him is one of the most complex and interesting elements of her work, suffering only because she is not prepared to analyse Sallust's vivid portrait of this conservative intriguer. (But why does she lapse into talking about Scaurus' ‘senatorial status’ when she means nobilitas (217–18)?) Cicero's stance in his defence of Murena is of course pride in being a novus, even the claim that his own overwhelming success has ended any possible discredit to the category: his models as novi vary between the wholly admirable Cato, the wise and self-subordinating Laelius (son of a novus and one of the figures best handled throughout the book; cf. e.g. 185–8, 273–5), and to a lesser extent Antonius (cos. 99 b.c.e). B.'s arguments come together at their most fruitful in ch. 8 ‘Cicero's Use of Personal Exempla’.
Something she could have brought out more strongly is the influence on Cicero's choice of exempla not just of the (largely equestrian) jury with its natural affinity with homines novi, but of an historical figure's whole career, and the prominence of his surviving descendants. She makes it clear that Cato the Elder was particularly valuable to Cicero as a foil for his Stoic descendant. Among the precedents for his own exile Cicero speaks most often of the conservative Metellus Numidicus, who was exiled for resisting the oath imposed by Saturninus with his corn law, and, like Rutilius, refused to return to Rome. Popilius and Opimius fared differently and Cicero drops the former — he had no influential descendants, whereas Opimius, probably just as ruthless, redeemed himself for Cicero by creating the Senate's emergency decree of which Cicero himself made use, and perhaps also by the erection of his temple of Concordia. Marius was Cicero's fellow-townsman and a military hero: he was also the uncle whose trophies Caesar restored, so it was desirable to speak only positively of this brute who ended his career by storming Rome and inflicting a massacre. Even Aemilianus, whom B. treats as a rôle model for Cicero, had met a hostile reception on his return, not unlike Pompey in 61 b.c.e. In general Cicero ‘always looks on the bright side’ of his exempla and I do not recall any negative reservations about his models in either his public speeches or B.'s presentation of them.
In short, although the book loses by putting its emphasis on exempla rather than the careers of novi homines, it contains much of value for the reader who will persevere beyond its relatively pedestrian first half.
