The monochord, or kanōn, is a single-stringed instrument with a graded rule and movable bridges which can be used to shorten the length of the string in proportions that can be measured accurately. Invented sometime before 300 BCE, it was an important tool for some who studied harmonics in ancient Greece. In the modern period, harmonics has been rather neglected by historians even though a number of ancient authors emphasized its importance and its relationship to other areas of Greek mathematics. The relationships between harmonics, arithmetic and geometry are re-explored by David Creese in The Monochord in Ancient Greek Harmonic Science. He argues that with the monochord claims about the arithmetical relationships between musical pitches could be demonstrated in ways that were analogous to the proof of propositions using geometrical diagrams.
Creese has produced an important contribution to the field; his book promises to become a classic, relied upon not only by those interested in harmonics in antiquity, but also by those working on later periods as well. He does not study harmonics only from the standpoint of mathematics as a theoretical ‘science’; rather, his work recognizes the central place of music within broader Greek culture, and contributes new insights to texts we thought we had previously understood. Creese brings to his studies expert knowledge of the technical aspects of the theory of harmonics as well as musical practice, together with the skills of a classicist and historian, and a detailed understanding of relevant areas of ancient Greek philosophy. This is a most impressive and unusual combination; the book relies on his expertise across these disciplines.
The first paragraph of his Preface (p. vii) offers an admirably succinct summary of the volume:
This book is about an instrument that shaped the way scientists thought about music in Greek antiquity. It is also about the way Greek science shaped the use of a musical instrument. With its single string, movable bridge and graduated rule, the monochord straddled the gap between notes and numbers, intervals and ratios, sense-perception and mathematical reason.
The history of the monochord begins with the Sectio canonis (Division of the Monochord, a short text on harmonics ascribed to Euclid in most of the extant manuscripts); Creese's work ends with a chapter on Ptolemy. He argues that the monochord offered a way to represent musical sounds as visible and, indeed, measurable distances (by using the lengths of strings), and also to represent numbers audibly to the musically informed ear, thereby enabling the study of ‘music as an arithmetical science through the medium of geometry’ (p. vii). He suggests that the monochord provided those investigators working in harmonics with a tantalizing opportunity to try to extend the irrefutability of mathematical argumentation to the auditory realm.
For historians of mathematics and science, Creese's focus on an ancient scientific instrument, the monochord, and his arguments regarding the empirical character of ancient Greek harmonics, will force many to reconsider some long-held, but apparently misguided, prejudices; the crucial role of the instrument and of empirical studies is emphasized throughout the book. Furthermore, his discussion of the geometricization of harmonics, through the introduction of the monochord, challenges other assumptions about scientific methods, and the uses of mathematics, in Greek antiquity.
The volume begins with an introduction to the geometry of sound; this is followed by a chapter on the role of instruments and diagrams in harmonic science. Here Creese argues that the monochord can be understood as an audible extension of the lettered diagram used in Greek geometry. The second chapter looks at mathematical harmonics before the monochord, and treats the Pythagoreans Philolaus and Archytas. The Sectio Canonis is the focus of Chapter 3; Creese regards the use of the kanōn in this work as a watershed in the history of mathematical harmonics, a moment in which an instrument is used to complete a chain of argument, beginning with silence and ending with the notes of a scale. Whether Eratosthenes (late third century BCE) used a monochord is one of the questions in the brief fourth chapter, focusing on this author who wrote on a number of mathematical topics, amongst many others. The final chapters are concerned with the study of the division of the monochord, known as canonics (or canonic theory, relating to the kanōn), including that accomplished by Ptolemy. A consideration of what Creese refers to as the ‘laboratory methods’ used by harmonic theorists – actual procedures rather than thought experiments – is an important feature of his approach; he emphasizes the empirical aspects of Ptolemy's investigations. Creese's characterization finds much support in an article which appeared while his book was in press, discussing another harmonic instrument described and possibly invented by Ptolemy, Andrew Barker's ‘Ptolemy and the meta-helikôn’, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science (2009) 40, pp. 344–351.
Creese's work displays scholarship of the highest order – including close and careful engagement with the relevant sources and critical studies. His book will appeal to a wide audience, not only classicists and historians of ancient mathematics, science and philosophy, but musicologists and musicians themselves. Because of the importance of the monochord in music and natural philosophy in the Middle Ages and continuing up through the nineteenth century, historians working on other periods will recognize Creese's book as a fundamental resource. He recognizes that certain areas may be unfamiliar to some readers; accordingly, he offers commendably clear and concise points of entry for the uninitiated.
The monochord remains an instrument used in scientific demonstration to this day; part of its appeal is its antiquity and seeming simplicity. I can well imagine that some physics teachers will be recommending Creese's work to students, as well as drawing material from it for their own use. In short, Creese has produced a work of scholarly achievement which will have a very wide readership and impact.
