In a world torn apart by World War I, captured soldiers quickly fell victim to violence and hardship in prisoner-of-war (POW) camps where they were sequestered, many for years after the war’s end. To those on the outside, capture has seemed a comparatively easy escape from the horror of the front lines. Yet, as Heather Jones emphasizes throughout her richly contextualized study, French, German, and British POWs were not insulated from the hazards of warfare or even from the front lines. As Jones convincingly shows, the hardships prisoners faced—jeering crowds and physical abuse, forced labor and inadequate food supplies—are evidence that POWs were in the crosshairs of an ever more brutal wartime mentality.
Violence against Prisoners of War is structured to illuminate the impact of the culture of war and evolving military strategies on the lives of POWs over the course of the war and its aftermath. The text is divided into three sections, with each chapter and subsection further divided by country. Section 1 examines the interconnectedness of popular representations of POWs and their treatment. Propaganda by captors painted POWs as war criminals, justifying harsher treatment (chap. 1). In turn, allegations of enemy mistreatment of innocent captives—for example, the horrors attributed by Germans to French colonial soldiers who ran POW camps in North Africa—likewise helped rationalize the violation of prewar international standards for humane treatment (chap. 2). Section 2 moves from propaganda to internal policy and the tribulations of POW life over the course of the war. Jones highlights how deteriorating camp conditions were in part attributable to the scarcities of war, but they were also the result of increased labor needs. As Jones details, conditions worsened for prisoners in the employ of the German, French, and British armies alike, despite attempts (by the British and French at least) to uphold basic humanitarian standards. German officials, by contrast, went so far as to deploy POWs to the Eastern Front as their military situation became more desperate, something that would outrage British officials and worry neutral international observers (207). Section 3 turns from policy back to popular culture to study the reception of POWs in the postwar era and their rapid disappearance from representations of the war by the 1930s. Jones argues that, on the one hand, POWs were pawns in the peace process, furnishing proof of German war guilt. They could also be an embarrassing symbol of cowardice. On the other hand, the POW experience provided promising material for Europeans intent on emphasizing common humanity rather than national rivalry. The British in particular were drawn to the theme of common suffering, Jones states. Yet, even in Britain, POWs disappeared from later representations of the war. Why exactly? Jones is hard pressed to say.
Although not an unstudied topic (among recent studies, see Rachaminmov on the Eastern Front, Hinz on the prisoner question in Germany, and Speed on POWs in diplomatic correspondence), POW history has been treated as peripheral to accounts of wartime brutality, in part the result of the earlier marginalization of POWs, the origins of which Jones describes well. Jones’s comparative account offers an important corrective in this respect. Thanks to its impressive scope, the book promises to become a necessary read for students of the war and a go-to book on POWs more broadly speaking. For scholars of World War I, Jones’s study will be critical for her contributions to the contextualization of wartime violence. It has become commonplace to study wartime brutality as a social and cultural phenomenon, especially in the decade since the US publication of Stéphane Audoin-Rouzeau and Annette Becker’s 14–18: Understanding the Great War (New York, 2002). Nevertheless, Jones revises much of the literature on POWs in which scholars tend, like popular commentators of the immediate postwar era, to believe prisoners were protected from the extremes of wartime radicalization (6–7).
Yet, it is in these areas of strength that we also find the fundamental weaknesses of Jones’s text. Trained narrowly on fitting POW history into a particular line of World War I historiography, Jones’s basic findings are unsurprising, while her more suggestive lines of argumentation are often lost in scaffolding that is cumbersome and at times repetitive. One wishes to see more sustained commentary on some of her more interesting and perhaps innovative subsidiary arguments—for example, Jones’s observations on the fate of prewar humanitarian standards. Jones explains early on that Germany was quick to abandon the terms of the Hague and Geneva Conventions (119). Later, she makes the important observation that, as the war progressed, French and British officials began violating the terms of international conventions while adhering to a language of humanitarianism that helped to obscure these abuses (249). As is typical of much of the detail Jones provides in this nearly four-hundred-page text, the point is tantalizing but unsatisfying. Offered almost in passing, her mention of this normative language leaves open the question of why French and British humanitarian discourse differed so much from German patterns. Exploring this contrast might in turn deepen the comparative insights that Jones can provide from her rich case studies.
Overall, Violence against Prisoners of War is a thoroughly researched text, although it does not fully exploit the broader implications of its findings. Despite this limitation, however, more specialized students will thoroughly enjoy making the connections Jones’s study suggests. In so doing, they will find rich avenues for further comparison between, for example, POWs and disabled veterans, POW treatment on colonial frontiers in World War I and World War II, and nationalistic propaganda and emerging humanitarian norms.
