With its focus on masculinity, Farha Ghannam's thoughtful ethnography, Live and Die Like a Man, makes important interventions into the anthropological scholarship on gender, childhood, and family in the Middle East. The book is based on the author's twenty years of ethnographic commitment to a low-income neighborhood in northern Cairo called al-Zawiya al-Hamra, during which she developed close relationships with several families.
Ghannam foregrounds the biological and cultural constructs by which men define themselves and are defined by others, while at the same time emphasizing the importance of deconstructing gendered ideologies when studying masculinities. Unlike other ethnographic studies of contemporary life in the region that privilege women's bodies, this study argues that “[w]hile the over-embodiment of women has led to their objectification, alienation, and fragmentation, the disembodiment of men has led to their dehumanization, the suppression of their emotions, and the subordination of their bodies to patriarchal and capitalistic demands” (pp. 170–71). The men in Ghannam's study are emotional, body aware, vulnerable, worried, and assertive.
Ghannam adopts an ethnographic approach to uncover how men negotiate and redefine their position in the growing and changing urban space of Cairo. Her central contribution is to demonstrate that a compelling balance exists between the life worlds of men and women under neoliberal political and social policies. Her ethnographic sensibility perfectly grasps the dynamic and complex intertwining of male and female ways of being and self-presentation and how that interrelationship forms men's lives. Women shape and discipline men's appearance and behavior by “instructing their sons, brothers, husband, and male neighbors about the proper way of being a man” (p. 88). Mothers, sisters, and wives are constantly seeking to perfect men's reputations by supervising and commenting on their grooming and actions, making sure that they perform as men.
For Ghannam, the most pressing problem for men is their continuing need to be recognized not only by other men, but also by women as being in control, and as having authority. Men's hopes, sorrows, sense of humor, and familial and social relationships are vividly recounted through detailed life histories collected from selected families in al-Zawiya al-Hamra. These life histories enable Ghannam to give the reader a deep and long-ranging sense of men's day-to-day lives, from childhood experiences on, along with a vivid picture of how they struggle with their fears of vulnerability and not meeting family and societal expectations. The theoretical core of Ghannam's book is her analysis of the body as the consolidation of everyday socially situated practices, which are ultimately realized through a continuing process of trial and error. We learn from this book that men are under constant pressure in their endeavor to “live and die like a man,” for fear of being perceived as feminine.
Throughout the book, the direct and personal voices of boys, men, girls, and women combine with the author's own voice and sensibility. Ghannam narrates her subjects’ lives in intimate detail—through marriages, pregnancies, births, illnesses, and deaths—and the affection and mutual respect borne of close relationships spanning two decades is evident. However, I wonder if this affectionate connection makes the author reticent at times to delve further into the harsher realms of people's lives, despite the possibility that so doing could have supported some of her arguments. One example pertains to the subject of violence. We hear about domestic violence and abuse, but Ghannam does not discuss male violence in any detail. I wonder if this absence is because of her closeness to her interlocutors, whom she does not want to embarrass. Her friendship with her interlocutors in al-Zawiya al-Hamra also raises methodological questions related to how—after two decades of fieldwork in this location—she picked the particular interviewees to involve in this book. Ghannam moves between insider/outsider categories without clarifying her position or explaining how and when her interviewees situated her as friend or researcher.
There is much original thought in Farha Ghannam's ethnography, yet there are also aspects regarding the formation of family life in Egypt that owe a particular debt to historians working in Egypt. While Ghannam mentions the significant work of Beth Baron on the role of women and family in Egypt's national endeavors, I think Lisa Pollard's social history of the Egyptian family and domestic space is also very relevant.
Impressive for its easy style and close readings, this thick anthropology from Cairo has much to praise. The book will contribute to the growing body of anthropological work on masculinities under conditions of social and political change. This wonderful text is appropriate for college instruction and for researchers interested in gender, family, and daily life in Egypt.
