The common assumption held by most Americans is that the West is a civilized place and that when its various governments extend a hand to others in the non-Western world, they do so with altruistic intent. With this assistance, it is assumed, the non-Western world got science and technology, high-yield agriculture and modern medicine, educational reform, and government efficiency. In other words, the West dispensed modernity, and that made, and makes, the world better. That this picture is so persistent and strong is a function of two things. The first is ignorance. Most Americans do not know where the non-Western world is, much less what successive governments have really been doing out there in that great beyond that constitutes the lands of the “Other.” The second is that a picture built on propaganda has filled the void of public ignorance. The same politicians and bureaucrats who have produced Western behavior in the non-Western world have also cultivated the public's image of these activities, and that propaganda is the source of the myth of altruism.
As is the case with all myths, this one contains a grain of truth—a small grain. Just how small is made painfully clear in Jeremy Salt's book, The Unmaking of the Middle East. Salt's book is well researched and massively documented, using mostly primary sources. Its uniqueness lies in its pulling together in one volume all the myriad tales of disaster that one might find in a hundred other books. As such, it takes us on a chronological tour of the consequences of Western intervention in that part of the non-Western world known as the Middle East. Salt begins with the slow but systematic dismantling of the Ottoman Empire culminating in the slaughter of World War I. The “war to end all wars” did not end up delivering “self-determination” to the non-Western peoples of the Middle East. Failure of this early 20th-century effort to spread democracy bolstered the empires of France and Great Britain in what Woodrow Wilson described as a “game of grab” (p. 74). Subsequent resistance on the part of the Arabs, detailed by Salt in the early nation building of Iraq, was brutally repressed by the use of aerial bombardment, artillery, and machine guns against civilian populations. Then came the “double colonization” (p. 121ff.) of Palestine by British imperial forces and European Zionists.
Finally, the American age waxed as the imperial energies of Britain and France waned. Although the Americans avoided policies of direct occupation (up until their 2003 invasion of Iraq), they carried on the generally dictatorial, exploitative policies of their Western predecessors through ruthless proxy regimes. Obsessed with the Cold War, successive American administrations simply ignored local conditions and backed with money and guns whatever set of thugs would do their bidding. Those Arab leaders who resisted were aggressively undermined in various ways until they were murdered, overthrown, or exiled.
As it turned out, the biggest and most long-lived thugs were the Israelis—the offspring of the European Zionist invaders who came along with British victory in World War I. With only one exception (Eisenhower in 1956), every American president since Harry Truman has allied himself to Israel and used that nation as a willing enforcer to further the often messianic and maniacal ambitions of American ideologues from cold warriors to Christian fundamentalists to the U.S. branch of Likudist fanatics.
All of this is depressingly detailed by Jeremy Salt as a progression of “aggressive wars” and “defensive lies” (p. 225ff.) that have yet to exhaust themselves. In a chapter titled “George the Son,” Salt shows how the “defensive lies” of the George W. Bush administration filled the void of ignorance among Americans with a “campaign of propaganda monumental in its deceit and dishonesty” (p. 317). America's corporate media, run by conservative corporate boards and editors and staffed by passive and obedient “journalists,” played to Washington's tune—just as the British press had reflected their own imperial government stories about Egypt and Iraq and the French press had, for 130 years, sung the glories of France in Algeria.
Several hundred years of Western intervention has “unmade the Middle East.” It has left Arab nations with weak and corrupt governments, most of which, to this day, are afraid of and dependent upon the West. This has opened the door for Islamic fundamentalist movements, the most dangerous of which (to the West at large) is Osama bin Laden's al-Qaʿida. As Salt tells us, the number of Muslims who are willing to “go the whole distance” with Bin Laden is tiny. However, when Bin Laden talks of a history of Western aggression against the Middle East, the general populations of the region know that he is not filling a popular void of ignorance with a myth.
The lesson taught by Salt's book is that, sooner or later, you reap what you sow. This lesson was long hidden because for the last 200 years or so the massive imbalance of power between Western governments and the peoples of the non-Western world did not allow for any effective counterattack that might impact Western lives. That time is over. Now Westerners must recognize that it is not just the positive benefits of development that we are bringing to the non-western world. George W. Bush and his neoconservative advisers refused to recognize this reality. Rather, behaving as “the incarnation of Western power in the present age” (p. 358), they subsituted their own interests for the needs and desires of the people of the Middle East. What about Barack Obama? As a start, I suggest he read this book by Jeremy Salt.
