Paula Lupkin has written a fascinating but frustrating book about the significance of the YMCA and its buildings from 1865 through 1929. Lupkin explores the Y's values and purposes and examines the ways in which the organization used physical space to express those values and purposes. Drawing on a wide variety of materials including YMCA branch records, national publications, local newspapers, postcard collections, and secondary sources from a wide variety of fields, Lupkin has written an organizational history that is also a cultural history of space. In studying a single-sex institution, she intends as well to make a statement about gender.
Lupkin successfully presents the subtitle of her book, YMCA Architecture and the Making of Modern Urban Culture. She is interested in the shifting mission of the YMCA as expressed in its buildings, and she follows that mission through several phases. The Y originated as a Christian haven for male youth in antebellum cities, a haven with strongly missionary purposes. Housed in rented rooms, the YMCA in its early days generally shared spaces with similar kinds of Christian organizations.
In the Gilded Age, the Y's mission evolved. It sought “to develop the working power and increase the capacity for usefulness of every young man” (21). To the extent that a useful young man was one who steered away from the snares of urban “sporting life,” there was continuity between the ante- and post-bellum YMCA. However, the organization's new purposes had less to do with saving souls and more to do with saving the character of the white-collar workforce. After the Civil War, the New York Y fell under the influence of young men like J.P. Morgan, wealthy sons of the New England-rooted segment of New York's merchant aristocracy. These young men imagined an institution that not only had a more secular purpose that it had before the Civil War, but they also envisioned great buildings that would represent that purpose in cities and towns across the nation. In this late-nineteenth-century phase, the standard YMCA building resembled a men's club, not a church, and even included a gymnasium.
By the turn of the twentieth century, the Y's spiritual purpose, says Lupkin, had largely dropped away: “What had been designed as moral ballast and a beacon . . . within the commercial landscape and the market system became a free-standing, civic institution and a purveyor of services to a larger public” (111). In an urban setting where boardinghouses were disappearing, the YMCA now offered dormitory-style housing to young men. The new buildings that provided this housing rejected symbols of Christian domesticity (omitting the parlors that had featured prominently in earlier buildings) and styled themselves after commercial hotels. The YMCA at the start of the twentieth century sought to attract members by providing alternatives to the commercial leisure that lured young urban males. In finding innovative ways to package under one roof a wide variety of recreational activities for males of varying ages, the YMCA made its greatest twentieth-century impact. Protestant churches and progressive reformers, hoping to provide alternatives to commercial recreation, used YMCA buildings as their model of how to combine many activities in one structure. The multipurpose school buildings, churches, and community centers that are so common in today's institutional landscape are a product of YMCA innovations in the Gilded Age and Progressive Era.
Lupkin's analysis ends with the Great Depression, as construction stopped and the built empire of the YMCA ceased to expand. Lupkin mentions but does not examine what would be the next phase in the YMCA's history: post-World War II expansion to the suburbs.
If Lupkin enjoys great success in addressing her subtitle, her book falls short in dealing with its title, Manhood Factories. Anyone looking for new insights into manhood in the Gilded Age or Progressive Era will not find them here. Lupkin addresses gender issues abstractly in her introduction, drawing on the available literature on men and masculinity as it relates to the YMCA. After that, manhood appears often in the text, but it neither fixes Lupkin's attention nor engages her analytical energies.
This is especially frustrating because her research churned up many interesting nuggets of gender history that call out for closer examination. For instance, Lupkin notes that the YMCA in the Midwest and small towns was gendered “female” in the Gilded Age. Whereas the Y in eastern cities was run by men as a masculine space, it was understood elsewhere as part of women's empire of benevolence and served as “a symbol of the feminine ‘home’ sphere . . . a refuge from vice, corruption, and greed” (106). This is a fascinating regional difference that is rich with gender implications, but Lupkin does not explore or elaborate. Lupkin also makes frequent but unexamined reference to the growth of age segregation in YMCA buildings and programs during this era. What does this reveal about the process of learning to be a man and, more broadly, what does it say about the shifting relationship of age to gender? In this and many other instances, Lupkin walks away from the gender implications of her own material. In assessing a book entitled Manhood Factories, this is not a quibble.
Lupkin's book is, in most regards, a valuable contribution to understandings of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. Lupkin has shown how the growth of a crucial institution both shaped and reflected an urban American that was becoming more secular, more bureaucratic, more oriented to commercial leisure for identity and meaning. She also adds to an appreciation of the ways in which the organization of space expresses values and beliefs. Although Lupkin missed promising opportunities to add to understandings of gender in this era, the shards of evidence and insight that lay strewn across the book serve as a reminder that there is still much to be learned about manhood, even in a historical period whose manhood has already been studied to a considerable degree.
