No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 26 February 2004
Although gender has often been neglected in standard academic discourse concerning violence and the state, increased media attention to collective violence against women in Bosnia and Rwanda in the 1990s raised public consciousness and challenged scholars to view political conflict through a gendered lens. For a long time, political analysts failed to recognize the gendered organization of violence during armed conflict. As a result, rape and other sexual assaults committed during riots, wars, and other political conflicts were viewed as distinct deviant acts perpetrated by a few individuals. In this paper, I argue that the common view of rape as an individual act spontaneously committed during violent confrontations is erroneous. In fact, sexual assault is a common strategic weapon in the commission of political violence.
The first half of this paper focuses on how and where incidents of gendered political violence occurred. Narrowly defined, gendered violence includes molestation, rape, other sexual assaults against women, and rape-murders. These acts of abuse have a broader purpose than the sexual exploitation of individual women, however, because they serve as a way to demoralize individuals and damage entire communities. This explains why gender violence is often closely associated with ethnic cleansing and genocide. Excerpts from a human rights factfinding task force report are provided to reveal how victims of gendered political violence suffered during and after armed conflicts in Gujarat and Kashmir. These reports conclude that the state did not sufficiently protect or defend women from having their civil rights violated. After the assaults ended, women continued to suffer from psychological trauma, miscarriage, unwanted pregnancy, social ostracism, divorce and abandonment, domestic violence, and life in refugee camps. A review of these cases suggests the assaults against women were strategically planned, deliberate attempts to incite violence by recruiting new members and clearly identify an enemy, supporting the thesis that violence against women is an integral part of hostile political struggles.
The second half of this paper exposes the narrative that supports collective violence against women. Religious norms, traditional rituals, and indigenous customs are rearranged to construct a new identity politics of community. Gender is an essential component of this warrior discourse, which is composed of the dichotomous rhetoric of masculinity versus femininity as well as the deeply gendered rhetoric of family. Through this discourse, dominant men make women signifiers of the family and community, and chastity comes to symbolize the group's honor. In the context of this ideology, raping women is a highly effective way to denigrate the enemy group's honor. Transformed into objects by men's struggle for power, marginalized women become trapped between enemy men and their own men in a desperate attempt to prove the authenticity of their own bodies. In volatile political situations, marginalized groups are called on to prove their worth in the community, and women are often exploited by both their own men and enemy men as the men struggle for power. Thus, the dynamic of communal violence against women both has its roots in, and supports the commission of, domestic violence.
By comparing the political violence during riots in Gujarat and military occupation in Kashmir to other incidents of collective violence against women around the world, as well as to particular forms of domestic violence in India—sati, dowry murder, and triple telaq—this paper reveals how political violence is deeply gendered, and how patriarchal ideology and family structure support both domestic and communal violence. Each of these individual cases of violence against women was justified using the discourse of family privacy. As long as women are confined to the domestic sphere and that space is defined as one where men are entitled to exert authority over other family members, women will continue to be victimized. In the age of globalization and democratization, however, patriarchy is facing serious challenges in politically volatile societies like India. The basic units of society—family and community—are in the process of transformation, as are the concepts of tradition and religion. I conclude that we must not only assign gender a central place in analyses of political processes, but that we also need to develop a feminist critique of politics based on bordered sovereignty. Such a critique may enable us to develop an alternative way of organizing the political system to effectively challenge violence in our international society.