In Faithful Fighters, Kate Imy undertakes a refreshing investigation into the Indian Army between the 1910s and 1930s to trace the roots and development of religious militarism and racial masculinity in the colonial military institution of British India. In doing so, she also provides a snapshot of the civilian communities from which the Indian Army recruited and that it protected. As Imy makes clear, the decision to examine the three-decade span covering World War I and the interwar period allows us to observe the Indian Army in war and peace, the ever-changing contexts of political demands from within, the collapse of a global economy, and the British Empire on the international stage.
Imy strategically positions this topic at the intersection of key scholarship as varied as World War I colonial soldiers (Das), the discourse of “martial race” (Streets), and colonial masculinity (Sinha), to name just a few. She also engages with specific works on individual religions (Sikhism, Islam, Hinduism, and Christianity) and regions (Punjab and Nepal). A major contribution of the book is to draw on a wide range of scholarly debates, which she skillfully integrates into her own focused narrative. The result shows the reader a panoramic view of the army and its transformation over nearly thirty years.
While the book's cover, opening sentences of the introduction, and conclusion all point to Sikh soldiers’ World War I engagement on the Western Front in Europe, Imy manages to tackle a much broader array of topics. In the first three chapters, she focuses on three major ethno-religious communities (Sikh, Muslim, and Hindu Gurkha) represented in the Indian Army and their positions around World War I. Discourse of “martial race” dictated who would be recruited into the Indian Army and how to discipline, train, and deploy each ethno-religious group in segregation. Yet South Asian soldiers “simultaneously internalized and challenged” (p. 11) these imposed identities for their own communal and political agenda. They also demanded secular benefits under the disguise of “religious complaints” of rituals and provisions.
Imy presents one compelling example of contradictions in practice. This concerns the Indian Army's food provision and how that met or denied the varied religious needs (chapter 4). The army was reluctant, for example, to cater to the Hindu “Brahmin diet” and saw it as “incompatible with military service due to [its] perceived stringency” (p. 126). Meanwhile, fasting for Ramzan and the feast of Eid were allowed to be observed, because they were accepted as “a legitimate form of community belonging that could solidify . . . military discipline and loyalty” (p. 139). Following this line, the military authority deemed the 1914 Muslim mutiny in Singapore a religious complaint over a forced premature end of the Ramzan that year. As a result, the army failed to understand the mutiny was instead a protest from the rank and file concerning inadequate food supply and distribution in anticipation of the war (p. 138).
While individual episodes like this are carefully presented and revealing, readers may ask what underlay all these institutional contradictions beyond any specific religion or specific ethnic group. What was—if at all—the colonial consistency, or a colonial “master plan” in thoughts and practice, for these seemingly inconsistent treatments that favored Islam over Hinduism in terms of food provision? Similarly, what explains contradictions within the same religion, such as in the case concerning Muslim Panthans’ removal from the World War I front line, whereas Muslims from Punjab and other regions were extensively deployed in the Middle Eastern theater? Alternatively, were these cases merely an incidental, chaotic consequence of an assortment of uncoordinated improvisation at local levels?
The increasing impact of the Indian Army's religious hierarchy and segregation on interwar India is a focus of the last two chapters. In these sections, Imy assesses the process and consequences of the “Indianization” reform that encouraged military and political participation of the South Asian population. The strict ethno-religious boundaries, being so diligently safeguarded by the army, were apparently abandoned in India's new military educational institutions, which invited applicants from all corners of the society. Yet their control over and emphasis on individual ethno-religions, according to Imy, were indeed enhanced via regulated places of worship on campus, and institutionalized rites of “parades” (pp. 173–80). Outside the army, the concept of “martial race” was deeply internalized by subject communities to form a principal criterion for anticolonial campaigns (or the lack of it, in the case of Hindu nationalists). As it had been so closely associated with the army and its practice, it inevitably embraced a military and violent outlook, and in some cases, a fascist ideology. As Imy points out, the rigid division based on religion and race spilt from the army to the entire society, and no doubt paved the way to the disastrous partition with extensive violence that took place soon after World War II.
Faithful Fighters gives us many vivid examples of regulating the body—for example, the close association between male bodies’ physical prowess and kirpan (a Sikh sword), sexual intimacy between British and South Asian officers and soldiers, and a ritual to purify Hindu Nepalese soldiers who crossed the inauspicious kala pani (black water) during overseas campaigns. Each of these examples illustrates the struggle of myriad faiths in “family, community, nation and empire” (p. 10). One wishes Imy could have taken this further to explore a general ponderance over the intricated relation and strange interplay of the culture of body and faith, including, but not limited to, religion.
Overall, Faithful Fighters is an engaging and informative read that includes an impressive number of sources to paint a mosaic of the Indian Army in the first decades of the twentieth century. Moreover, this work helps explain the social divisions and mass violence that followed in the second half of the century in India's military and civilian spheres. Students of modern India and British Empire at all levels, with a wide range of interests in military formation, religious conflict, body politics, nationalist demand, and colonial reform will all find inspiration here.
