Those familiar with the series in which this volume is offered will not be surprised to hear that it is at once a survey of the landscape of its topic and a fairly ambitious attempt to contribute constructively to that landscape. This contribution is made both through critique and counterproposal. Although the lineaments of the constructive proposal are intimated throughout the volume, they come fully into view in a closing trio of chapters which lay out Waters’ account of the order internal to a Christian conception of the family and its relation to other realms of social existence.
The argument is constructed in broadly chronological terms, beginning with a lengthy and dense chapter surveying biblical and historical sources. This sketches a trajectory from the Greco-Roman backdrop of antiquity through a treatment of New Testament themes and sources with a quick review of patristic and medieval authors. It includes a more fully developed account of Reformation and Puritan writers, a stop on Schleiermacher, and a fairly extensive treatment of relatively more obscure nineteenth-century theorists like F. D. Maurice and Horace Bushnell. All this is not mere summary, but a constructive (and therefore inevitably contestable) interpretation of the various writers and of their relation to one another and to the times in which they wrote. It has the value as well as the inherent weaknesses of such a survey.
Much of the critical weight of the volume falls on the next two chapters, which offer a reading and an increasingly acidic assessment of liberal social theorists on the family along the historical continuum from the early Hugo Grotius to Susan Moller Okin. These are interpreted and evaluated in light of various recent critiques and responses which Waters labels as he sees them: revisionist, resistant and so on. Since, to some extent, the normative standpoint is presupposed throughout this reading, those who take major issue with Waters’ own views are likely to find his readings problematic as well.
The transition from survey and review to normative proposal is marked by a pair of chapters that provide a clarifying and helpful summary, first of the readings of historical sources to date and then of the conceptual themes that Waters wishes to offer as alternative foundations for his own work. However, in this section the abstractness of the language (substantially adopted from Herbert Dooyeweerd and Oliver O'Donovan with brief explanatory summaries) and the absence of concrete specifications or examples leave the reader with the frustrating sense that a variety of ordinary words are being used in quite distinctive ways that never come to clarity. Examples are Dooyeweerd's concept of sphere sovereignty and O'Donovan's central theme of a vindicated order of creation that is to guide and judge normative moral proposals. Since a great deal of the intelligibility and persuasiveness of the argument depends upon a grasp of these theoretical underpinnings, this is a significant weakness for readers not already well acquainted with Waters’ sources.
In the final constructive section, Waters turns his attention first to the family itself as a teleologically ordered realm of creation, established by God as part of the given direction of human existence towards its ends of communion with God and neighbour. Although the family changes through time, and historical circumstance and Christian teaching may to some extent change with it, nevertheless those changes are bounded by the divine will and intention for creation. The family is a gift and command of God and not a pure social construct endlessly amenable to the aims of states, ideologies or individuals. The next chapter frames the family in relation to the life and telos of the church, placing it firmly within the ordering structures of this world. It is ultimately subject to critique, limitation and eventual supersession in an eschatological vindication that does not merely restore but transforms created order. A final chapter draws out the implications of this theological proposal for the social and political ordering, including both support and limitation, of marriage and family life. Waters critiques a whole range of contemporary proposals to reform, redefine or even effectively to abolish families as a normative and privileged locus of human existence. Not only does he find them misconceived and over-reaching in asserting a kind of unlimited authority to define the parameters of human existence, but he finds their service of the ‘liberal’ values of equality and autonomy to be decidedly illiberal in practice, marked by the readiness to intervene overpoweringly to redefine the human good in terms of the liberal state.
In the closing chapters, the problems of vagueness or ambiguity in the language are substantially if not completely overcome. Here is a substantive theological proposal which places judgements about family life and its social and political ordering squarely within a particular conceptual framework. This framework is, as Waters acknowledges, significantly dependent upon O'Donovan's moral theology, and readers will probably respond to it along similar lines, but at all events it is a vigorous contribution to dialogue and debate richly grounded in the Christian confession.
