This article will explore the effects of anti-Catholic ideology in the diocese of Bergamo during the early twentieth century, considering the reactions of Christian communities to the process of secularization of education. There is a large body of research related to the history of the Italian Catholic Church in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, including studies by Arturo Carlo Jemolo and Silvio Tramontin, the six-volume encyclopaedia on the History of the Catholic Movement edited by Francesco Malgeri, and more recently the studies of Alberto Melloni.Footnote 1 However, relatively little has been written about the relation between church and education, and even less adopting a methodology that uses local sources.Footnote 2 The first part of this article discusses in general terms the relation between state and church with regard to education; the second focuses on the action taken by the bishop of Bergamo, Giacomo Radini-Tedeschi (1905–14), to undermine the ubiquity of secular culture and to root Christians in the faith, starting from childhood.
During the period covered by this study, the long-standing conflict that saw the nascent Italian state opposed to the church was not resolved, but rather in some respects accentuated. The clash between the Catholic Church and Italian nationalism derived from the church's hostility towards the Kingdom of Italy and its refusal to recognize the kingdom's legitimacy, which was perceived by Pius IX initially as a threat to temporal power of the papacy and later (after the end of the Papal State in September 1870) as a danger also to its spiritual power. The tension between Catholicism and liberal-national principles, which would not be resolved until 1929, was accentuated by the spread of socialist ideas, especially among the working classes. Marxist ideologies were considered particularly dangerous by the Catholic Church because they gained a consensus not just among the urban proletariat but also amongst peasants, who had traditionally shown themselves receptive to Catholic doctrine. In addition, the attempt to reject and control the errors of so-called ‘modernism’ was a constant concern during the pontificate of Pius X (1903–14). Fear of being perceived as hostile to the traditional faith – for example, by fostering a rationalist approach to the Scriptures or encouraging a clear separation of church and state – restrained the actions of many lay people and priests. However, at the same time, anxiety to determine the authentic meaning of sacred Scripture and the dogmas of the Christian faith led the ecclesial authorities, from the cardinals and bishops to local parish priests, into vigorous educational effort that reached the seminaries, the Catholic associations and the faithful in general.Footnote 3
This article examines these phenomena from the bottom up, starting from local sources such as diocesan archives, bishops’ bulletins, correspondence with priests and associational activity in parishes. It seeks to move away from the stereotype of a church of the faithful separate from the church of the hierarchy, instead contributing to a new genre of studies which illustrate the contribution of Christianity to the growth of Italy as a nation. The results of this research make it possible to counter a historiographical tendency to position the conflict between church and state within an over-simplified political and ideological perspective, a point of view that tends to consider the reaction of the papacy against the Kingdom of Italy's political power, consigning questions of pastoral action to the background. Instead, it is suggested that both the hierarchy and the parish priests found themselves in a field of experimentation and innovation in a world anchored to a traditional faith.
Secularization of Schools after Italian Unification
The Casati Act of 13 November 1859 laid out the public education system of the nascent Kingdom of Italy in three hundred and eighty articles.Footnote 4 It marked an important (and transient) moment that constituted a point of equilibrium between two developments. The first was the introduction of direct state control over the entire chain of studies from the university to elementary school. Article 3 of the Casati Act stated: ‘The Ministry of Public Education governs public education in all branches and promotes their development: it oversees private instruction to protect morality, hygiene, state institutions and public order.’Footnote 5 This act brought universities almost entirely under government control, and all educational initiatives by private individuals were carefully scrutinized by the new state apparatus. High schools (liceo)Footnote 6 and grammar schools (ginnasio)Footnote 7 were carefully placed by the state to ensure an appropriate geographical spread, while elementary schools across the kingdom were entrusted to the care of municipal administrations but made subject to a national inspection system.Footnote 8
The second development stressed the need to preserve the liberal character of the nascent Kingdom of Italy. Accordingly, the state was to avoid monopolistic excesses in education; thus, for example, the act safeguarded the freedom of families to choose the kind of compulsory education to be undertaken by their children in the early years.Footnote 9 The opportunity to open an institution of secondary education was granted to ‘every citizen who had reached the age of 25 and met the necessary moral requirements’.Footnote 10 Freedom of teaching was granted to all university professors except those who through their writings, their teaching, or both had contradicted ‘the truths on which religious and moral order rests’.Footnote 11 The rights of religious minorities were also recognized,Footnote 12 although the constitution of the Kingdom of Piedmont-Sardinia (1848), later effectively the Italian Constitution, did not explicitly permit religious freedom but rather identified Catholicism as the only state religion.Footnote 13
Within this general framework, it is not surprising that religion was a compulsory subject in elementary schools, designated the first branch of learning both in the lower and higher grade of compulsory elementary education (comprising four school years), where it was taught by the ‘ordinary teachers’. In secondary schools, the subject had to be delivered ‘by a spiritual director [direttore spirituale], appointed by the Minister of Public Education’.Footnote 14 However, practising Catholics, who at the time represented the majority of Italians, regretted that priests were not responsible for the teaching of religion in elementary schools, and that the ‘spiritual director’ who presided over religious education in high schools was appointed by the ministry and not by the local diocese.Footnote 15
Without doubt, the separation of public education from religious authority was greater after Italian reunification; in Lombardy, for example, priests had previously been accustomed to being appointed to school leadership roles. The position of school director now became a civil rather than an ecclesiastical one.Footnote 16 Nonetheless, the process of secularization was less pronounced in Italy than in France. In Italy, members of governments and, more generally, the political elites who had led the laborious process of unification, who were often representatives of the secular bourgeoisie and the enlightened aristocracy, put in place a number of arrangements intended to secure a Catholic consensus and obtain wider support for the liberal cause.Footnote 17
From the Catholic point of view, the situation deteriorated after the passing of the Coppino Act on 15 July 1877, as a result of which religion was replaced by ‘elementary notions of the duties of man and the citizen’ in the compulsory school curriculum.Footnote 18 The act's main purpose was to combat illiteracy, but it was named for Michele Coppino, a left-wing parliamentarian and minister of education, known for his membership of the Freemasons. Signs of the decline of Catholic influence had been apparent since 20 September 1870, when Rome was conquered, as the long process of Italian unification and the final defeat of the Papal States under Pius IX were largely realized. These events had far-reaching effects on education. For example, the circular issued by Cesare Correnti, minister of education, in 1870 made the teaching of religion in schools optional rather than compulsory; in 1873 theology faculties were abolished in state universities; and spiritual directors were removed from secondary schools in June 1877.Footnote 19
Bishop Radini-Tedeschi of Bergamo and Education
Building on this general background, we turn now to our case study, to analyse on a small scale the effects of the government's education policies and the church's reactions. Bergamo in northern Italy offers a useful case study of the effects of nineteenth-century secularism during the early twentieth century. It was a densely populated agricultural centre in the process of rapid industrialization, and had a strong Catholic tradition. The Opera dei Congressi, a body of clergy and priests which sought to defend the position of the Catholic Church against government policy, was very active in promoting economic and social activity through agricultural loan provision, mutual aid societies and cooperatives. The diocese of Bergamo was led by a bishop who would leave a rich legacy of pastoral activity: Giacomo Maria Radini-Tedeschi had been appointed by Pius X in 1905.Footnote 20 His biography provides insights into the special connection he had with the field of education.
Two experiences prior to his nomination as a bishop seem to have been particularly formative for his understanding of the difficulties encountered by practising Catholics in a society in process of secularization. Born in Piacenza in 1857, two years before the Casati Act was passed, Radini-Tedeschi attended ginnasio and liceo in Bergamo from 1870 to 1874, experiencing some of the problems faced by colleges and boarding schools with a religious affiliation. He attended the College of St Alexander, which in March 1872 was placed under observation and then suppressed by the authorities of the Kingdom of Italy because it was accused of ‘instilling into the soul of the pupils’ the ‘clerical spirit’. The replacement of the rector, Alessandro Valsecchi, who had been accused of ‘anti-national sentiment’, made possible its reopening, but the threat of closure caused students to transfer to other institutions in 1872 and 1873.
Secondly, in 1889, at the Catholic congress of Lodi, Radini-Tedeschi, together with a lawyer from Brescia, Giuseppe Tovini, contributed to the drafting of the programme of the Pia Opera for preserving faith in Italian schools, as part of the third section of the Opera dei Congressi, dedicated to education. The Pia Opera was an attempt to curb the power of those opposed to Catholic initiatives and to build networks among lay people engaged in the development of educational institutions not hostile to the clergy.
From 1890 Radini-Tedeschi lived in Rome, where he began his diplomatic career at the Vatican Secretariat of State under Cardinal Mariano Rampolla. He carried out some missions abroad but continued his relationships with the Opera dei Congressi and the Catholic associations; for example, he was involved in organizing pilgrimages to the Holy Land from 1896 to 1905.Footnote 21
By the time of his appointment as bishop, two largely incompatible positions had emerged within the Opera dei Congressi. On one hand some, defined as ‘intransigent’ Catholics (Cattolici interansigenti), asserted the exclusive responsibility of the clergy to lead the Christian populace. These ultramontane Catholics, or Integristes, hoped to restore the past, in which the hierarchy was respected and feared; they sought to counter the separation of church and state. Catholic Action groups, on the other hand, believed in cooperation between clergy and laypeople, both in defence of the church and in political action, although at this stage they did not support any specific political party. They undertook initiatives such as the establishment of male and female associations, support of the Catholic press, workers’ organizations, welfare initiatives for immigrants and, last but not least, the defence of education,Footnote 22 recognizing that education could offer an ideal terrain on which to cultivate de-Christianization and that it was being so used by the new ruling class which was ideologically in favour of a secular state.
Anti-clericalism reached even the conservative and disciplined diocese of Bergamo during the first decade of the twentieth century. The city was less exposed than some others to the process of secularization, because the mayor and the municipal and provincial councils embraced Catholicism. Since the early 1880s, the Opera dei Congressi had been active in this area. Of particular importance was the local Catholic press: the weekly Il Campanone and the newspaper L'Eco di Bergamo, both of which had a significant influence on the laity of the province. Catholics also worked to establish the bank of the Piccolo Credito Bergamasco (1891) and to organize the electorate in local and national elections, and it was in this province that the first ‘Catholic deputy’, Agostino Cameroni, was elected to the Italian parliament in 1904. Cameroni could not be part of a Catholic party since the non expedit, the Catholic hierarchy's policy of non-cooperation in elections, was still in force.Footnote 23 However, these restrictions could be avoided in specific cases, such as when it was necessary to defeat a candidate viewed as an ‘expression of Masonic and socialist arrogance’, such as Adolfo Engel, Cameroni's adversary. Cameroni's election offered hope to those who were attempting to increase Catholic influence on society.
The working classes in northern Italy were affected by illiteracy and widespread poverty, two factors which were also at the root of an alarming migratory phenomenon. At the same time, vocations to the priesthood were flourishing, as attested by the large number of seminarians, four hundred at the bishop's arrival. The ratio of clergy to inhabitants placed the diocese of Bergamo in first place amongst the dioceses of Lombardy.
Radini-Tedeschi's pastoral approach gave primacy to the energy of the Catholic associations, as a reaction to growing anti-clericalism. The bishops and parish priests believed that scepticism undermined the very roots of human experience. The abandonment of the faith was particularly serious and visible in the educational field. A pastoral letter issued by the nine bishops of the highly populated dioceses of Lombardy in 1910 highlighted the risks of abandoning young people, ‘tyrannized by their own unbridled passions and surrounded in every part, in every way, by every kind of incentive to evil, [to] run carefree on the path of error and vice’. The bishops were concerned about ‘[i]nfamous novels, schoolbooks stained with errors and mockery of religion, atheistic and materialistic teachers, obscene photographs, sensuous scenes in cinemas and theatres, [and the] absolute lack of religious instruction in many schools and in many families’.Footnote 24 Likewise, they identified a worrisome spread of sports, designed not as a tool to provide strength but to foster ‘the inhuman courage of the Gladiator’.Footnote 25 Last but not least, they expressed their anxiety about the abandonment of churches, catechesis and the sacraments by many children in the years immediately following their first communion.Footnote 26
The Lombard bishops believed that it was pointless to complain about the moral crisis while appealing to the remedies suggested by secular forces. The fining of parents who failed to allow their children to attend school, the establishment of leisure centres, and calls for decorum, patriotic sentiment and honour all mattered very little if the moral perversion of teenagers was not counteracted by religion. ‘The catechism will save society, without the catechism there is no salvation’, the bishops asserted. The duty of all parents was therefore to provide education regarding the truths of religion, but also to demand that this teaching be given in elementary schools. This renewal of catechesis, seen as a bastion against socialist propaganda, was to bring with it the reward of a restoration of Christian life.Footnote 27
At the same time, a process of disciplining the clergy was under way, with a constant insistence upon respect for the authority of the pontiff and bishops in line with the anti-modernist sentiments of Pius X's encyclicals Pascendi Dominici Gregis (8 September 1907) and Motu proprio Sacrorum Antistitum (1 September 1910).Footnote 28 The implications of this ecclesiastical policy were far-reaching: for example, in seminaries, ‘the reading of any newspaper or periodical’ was prohibited, a harsh restriction that also applied ‘outside the seminary, during the vacations’.Footnote 29 Careful control was exercised over teaching programmes aimed at aspiring priests. The return to the foundations of Catholic tradition was also reaffirmed through the requirement that priests, parish priests, confessors and preachers take an anti-modernist oath.
In his pastoral letter of 1910, Radini-Tedeschi upheld vigilance as one of the virtues of a bishop. This would be given expression during his second pastoral visitation of the diocese, during which he visited villages and observed the activities of the local clergy, seeking to verify how the pontiff's prescription was being applied. The bishop was committed to providing for the spiritual needs of the people; he also carried out confirmations.Footnote 30 He consistently encouraged the faithful to respect orthodoxy, for example, in his recommendation that lay people might observe a season of penance and recollection in Lent by not attending shows and theatre spectacles, which were, he warned, accompanied by promiscuity amongst the audience and the actors.Footnote 31 On the political side, in line with the encyclical Rerum Novarum issued by Leo XIII in 1891, Radini-Tedeschi affirmed his right to make pronouncements on social issues against the excesses of capitalism. In autumn 1909, he expressed support for the workers of the Zopfi cotton mill in Ranica, a village near Bergamo, justifying the six-week strike which had been called by the Catholic-inspired trade union in the quest for a decent wage and the right of workers to organize themselves.Footnote 32
Speaking in Nembro in 1910 at the twenty-third Federal Feast of the Catholic Associations, Radini-Tedeschi directed the attention of the Catholics of Bergamo to the serious problems in the educational realm. In particular, he stressed the danger of schooling without the catechism and without God and urged families to support a series of projects that the diocese was initiating to ‘save the rights of the Christian school’.Footnote 33 He reminded the clergy, and above all their lay followers, of the need for humility: ‘Too many want to be captains, too few want to become soldiers.’Footnote 34 This entailed sincere obedience by individual members of every Catholic association to their leaders, for submission to one's superiors was the indispensable condition for fighting the enemy effectively.
In his pastoral letter ‘Mali e Rimedi’ (‘Diseases and cures’), presented on the first Sunday of Advent in 1910, Radini-Tedeschi also noted deficiencies in education. He claimed: ‘Education has lost its guiding light, its crucifix, its discipline, its catechism, its high ideals, its missionary purpose; and schooling has become [an opportunity] to attack young souls, to assault the truth, [to work] against science, against true civilization, against man, society, Church and God.’Footnote 35 This pessimistic tone pervaded the entire document: for Radini-Tedeschi, ‘apostasy’, in the sense of the complete negation of the transcendent, seemed the best definition of this terrible time.Footnote 36
Many concerns troubled the diocesan clergy and increased the bishop's anxiety: the spread of modernism, even among the flock of believers, the spread of rationalism in the study of Scripture, the emergence of new understandings of obedience and discipline amongst clergy and laity, the spread of a ‘worldly’ conception of life, and a feeling of hostility towards the hierarchy and the authority of the pope.Footnote 37
For Radini-Tedeschi, the causes of the diocese's afflictions were to be found in three separate but related factors: the increase of humanitarian and apolitical associations supported by Freemasonry, the dissemination of the anti-clerical press and the secularization of education.Footnote 38 With the removal of the crucifix, the catechism, the gospel and compulsory religious instruction, the school, he claimed, was no longer a temple of knowledge, but ‘a den of iniquity’ (una tana).Footnote 39 The remedies he proposed were, inevitably, the exact opposites of the evils. Catholic associations must oppose atheist societies; for this reason, the bishop encouraged the presence of Catholic Action in every parish. Many parishioners expressed scepticism: they did not understand the reasons for this novelty, but Radini-Tedeschi countered their hesitancy: ‘These associations were not present in the villages in the past, as once there was no railway, telegraph, the use of electricity’, but the church must keep up with the new challenges presented by modernity. Priests who were slow to establish groups in defence of religion posed problems as serious as those posed by sceptical priests. Radini-Tedeschi warned that while the priests ‘slept’, trusting in the orthodoxy of their flock, liberal or socialist societies, supported by the anti-clerical press, fuelled the fires of rebellion. The slowness of many dioceses to grasp the situation had allowed the growth of anti-clericalism to the point that the ‘serpent’ of atheism was already biting the heel of ‘dormant Christians’. Lastly, he replied to the objection of some parishioners that ‘we are parishes for all’ and who did not favour creating associations that they feared would divide the people into parties and foster discontent. ‘Better divided than completely disorientated’, was Radini-Tedeschi's response.Footnote 40
Education and catechesis were key to the defence of lay people's interests, which, in line with the instructions given by Pius X in the encyclical Acerbo Nimis (On teaching Christian Doctrine) of 15 April 1905, had to begin during the early years of children's lives; as much as possible must be done to prevent children and young people from joining groups not authorized by the church. The bishop suggested setting up a società tra i fanciulli (society for work with young boys), to support boys who had recently made their first communion.Footnote 41
Catechism and Catechism Competitions
The attention to catechesis was related to several factors: the National Catechetical Congress held in Piacenza in 1889, with further catechetical congresses taking place in Milan in 1910 and Brescia in 1912, the requirement of Acerbo Nimis for religious education through catechesis, and the lowering of the age for first communion to seven in the papal decree Quam Singulari (8 August 1910). One consequence of the catechetical congresses was the birth of schools of religion aimed at the laity, and particularly young people. These schools spread throughout the Italian peninsula, offering religious education to young Catholics attending high schools and universities. They were intended to provide an answer both to the abolition of theological faculties in state universities and to the removal of religious education from the secondary school curriculum. This was a difficult task. Acerbo Nimis instructed that the catechism had to be imparted to one and all ‘in a plain and simple style adapted to the intelligence of the hearers’.Footnote 42 Each parish was meant to have a special confraternity intended to improve the knowledge of the catechism; this would only be possible with the help of Catholic Action combined with the efforts of lay people under clerical guidance.
The educational dimension, including the strategies used to attract the interest of children and young people and the organizational and pastoral aspects of widespread catechesis aimed at consolidating the faith of children at an early age, deserves attention. As noted above, Pius X had lowered the age of first communion ‘in order … to help children even at a tender age to be united to Jesus Christ, live his life, and obtain protection from all danger of corruption’.Footnote 43 Some scholars consider that the pope's intention was also to impress the solemnity of the rite on the sensitive and innocent minds of children, so that it would have a lasting effect, even into adolescence. In addition, he wanted to encourage the religious supervision of children by their parents.Footnote 44
In response, Radini-Tedeschi launched a series of initiatives, congresses and publications relating to catechesis. He maintained contact with the parish priests of his diocese through correspondence and by means of a monthly bulletin, La Vita Diocesana. The bishop invited the clergy to set up committees of fathers for the study of the catechism, arguing that ‘the apt study of catechism, properly taught’ was ‘one of the most important marks of the Christian life’.Footnote 45 In the seminary, the formation of ordinands and young clerics was to be based on the Roman Catechism; they would then implement what they had learned in their parishes. Catechesis should be given not only to children but also to adults; special attention was to be given to young people and families who, for reasons of poverty, were migrating to other continents.Footnote 46 Guidelines and practical advice were offered to catechists in a list of seventy points divided into various topics. Under surveillance, he explained how to keep order in class, how to prevent chaos, how to enforce discipline, how to place students on school benches and how to maintain ‘detachment’ from students. The rules to be followed during the lesson included punctuality, gentleness and balance; threats, reprimands, rebukes and punishments, especially if they caused humiliation, should be avoided. There were some points about preparation and a discussion of how the adults were supposed to behave before and during the lesson. Priests were invited to prepare lessons well; to encourage timid children to take part in the discussions and not to reward arrogant pupils; they should ‘never reproach the children for their ignorance’; in their teaching, they should offer examples taken from everyday life. Finally, the teacher should lead the pupils in prayer, and priests should also entrust their pupils to God through prayer.Footnote 47
Although he tailored the message of the catechism to an audience of male and female pupilsFootnote 48 – boys and girls were taught in the same context, but in separately timetabled classes – Radini-Tedeschi's priority was to reclaim children from religious ignorance. Curates and parish priests were to spend Thursday mornings on male catechism classes and Thursday afternoon on female classes.Footnote 49 Sundays should also be devoted to making religion accessible to children. The early age of children making their first communion became an opportunity to influence not only their ‘tender souls’ but also the souls of their parents on the ‘happiest day of their life’, as the day of the children's first communion was described.Footnote 50
The bishop's efforts were successful, as indicated by the catechism competitions.Footnote 51 These had a history dating back to the sixteenth century, but had been suspended in 1700 due to violent altercations.Footnote 52 The renewed competitions began in 1909 within the Diocesan Federation of the Church Male Youth Centres and the Diocesan Union of Daughters of Mary. Resuming the academic competitions represented a ‘return to the old system of public disputations’,Footnote 53 but under Radini-Tedeschi, these competitions lost their link with the young people's associations and were drawn into the work of the diocese. The available data, though incomplete, shows their success: 157 participants took part in the Bergamo competitions in 1909; in 1911 there were 282; a year later there were 330; and in 1913 the number of participants reached 1,762, with 451 participants in the competitions for boys and young men, and almost three times as many in those for girls and young women.Footnote 54 However, given that the province of Bergamo had a population of about 520,000 in 1911, the numbers of youngsters involved in the competitions represented a tiny minority. Moreover, although an increasing number of children participated, catechism contests were limited in that they were only accessible to the best students of each parish or diocese. These competitions must have enlivened the teaching of catechism, and they became public festivals. Similar initiatives were organized in other parts of Italy. In Bologna, Bishop Della Chiesa suggested a competition for the publication of a catechism book that would attract children's interest.Footnote 55 In Rome, priests gave the children bread, stationery or little pictures of saints to encourage attendance at catechism.Footnote 56
Over time, the catechism competitions came to be carefully structured, according to regulations approved in December 1911.Footnote 57 Three levels were established: parish, ‘vicariate’ or deanery and diocesan. Selection took place in front of a jury chaired by the parish priest (for parish competitions), the dean (for vicariate competitions) or the bishop (for diocesan competitions). Each participant could choose between the recitation competition, which required the ‘literary recital of a part of the Catechism’, which in practice meant answering the catechism questions correctly, or an ‘intelligence competition’ with a written examination.
The recitation competition was divided into sections for boys and girls between the ages of nine and twelve and young men and women aged twelve to twenty. Contestants were placed in a semicircle and interrogated; those who made mistakes were eliminated; and the prize was awarded only to those who answered ten questions correctly from memory and three more by insight. The intelligence competitions took place only at diocesan level and involved the writing of an essay on a section of the catechism, for those aged between twelve and fourteen, or an apologetic theme, for those aged between fourteen and twenty-five years. There were different tests for male and female students at elementary, middle and high schools, and for workers, shop assistants and artisans; for young women a distinction was made between aspiring teachers, students of technical and commercial schools and workers. The diocesan competitions were particularly solemn and ended with communion. Arising from the competitions, an account was sent to the Congregazioni Primarie Diocesane della Dottrina Cristiana (Primary Congregation of Diocesan Christian Doctrine), which monitored the spread of catechesis in the parishes of the diocese.
These events offered an opportunity for different social classes to meet, being attended by university students, teenage members of church groups, workers and young Catholics; the festival also brought together the inhabitants of city and countryside, with lay people coming from villages, towns and cities to receive their awards from the bishop's hands.Footnote 58 These awards, inscribed with the winners’ name, were doubtless displayed at home.
Conclusion
The diocese of Bergamo experienced, and had to respond to, many aspects of the Italian state's secular vision. Radini-Tedeschi defended the Catholic community against these dangers by reproducing the clerical and hierarchical character of the church of Pius X. The bishop took full control of the activity of laity and diocesan clergy, but at same time, he knew how to dialogue with the people and how to focus on warning the faithful about the risks of immorality, vice or blasphemy rather than political struggle. This explains, for example, the commitment to both religious education at school and catechesis in the parish. As demonstrated in recent research,Footnote 59 Radini-Tedeschi's episcopate could be linked with the group known as Integralists, but it diverged from their approach in two respects: the organization of the laity for close collaboration in the church's apostolic work, especially in pastoral action, and his commitment as a socially concerned Christian, championing workers’ rights in one of the first great strikes in 1909.
This article underlines the first aspect, the multi-faceted ‘care of souls’, and particularly the educational question, which certainly also had political implications. The bishop's initiatives indicate his desire to control the flock, but also his concern about their piety and his desire to foster catechesis, knowledge of doctrine and forms of popular devotion such as prayer, pilgrimage and processions.Footnote 60 Radini-Tedeschi promoted the formation of committed lay people, aware of, and able to respond to, the spiritual needs of their families. He no longer saw piety exclusively in terms of the liturgy and the activities of traditional confraternities. He endorsed pilgrimages to the Holy Land, in search of the foundations of the Christian faith.Footnote 61
Although the conflict between church and state was strong, attention to the catechism allowed the introduction of interesting novelties. For example, in 1911, a priest of Brescia, Angelo Zammarchi (1871–1958), a co-founder of the Catholic publishing house Editrice La Scuola, presented the advantages of catechesis using new means such as lantern slides, missionary films and popular newspapers.Footnote 62 This opened the way to the use of mass media. Radini-Tedeschi would not see this, for he died on 22 August 1914, just weeks after the outbreak of the First World War.
The activity of parishes and the mobilization of Catholics against the loss of the social and cultural significance of religion could be interpreted in different ways. This article has shown that Radini-Tedeschi was careful to remain within the parameters of the theology of Pius X and that his pastoral education, aimed at the simplest people, sought to preserve an ideal of purity and refusal to compromise with the secularized world. However, it has also shown that the response of families and young people highlighted the inescapable need for the faithful to compromise with that world, and Catholic ability to pursue spiritual, cultural and political growth through diocesan initiatives. Catechetical education utilized popular religion for pedagogical purposes, employing popular rites and practices in the service of the anti-modernist principles that were currently fashionable. Training people in proper devotional practices became the means to achieve religious ‘purity’, that is, orthodox adherence to the teachings of Pius X. In this way, the effort went beyond simply defending the faith to constructing cohesive communities whose members shared the same values. In Radini-Tedeschi's thinking, the only way to survive the temptations of the secular world was to strengthen the bonds between the faithful and the Christian community; this accounts for his focus – and that of his clergy – on catechism and religious education, and on the sacrament of first communion. One of the results of this new focus on education was the use of practices such as the teaching of religion in school and the catechism competitions.
At the beginning of the twentieth century, secularization was an unquestionable fact in Italy, but Catholic education nonetheless continued to constitute one aspect of Italian collective identity. The Catholic Church had not lost its disciplinary power, but at the same time its hierarchies demonstrated their ability to dialogue with, negotiate with, or confront social actors and political decision-makers in responding to the problems of daily life, especially in local pastoral work. Radini-Tedeschi's initiatives in Bergamo left a legacy in the work of Fr Angelo Roncalli, who had been his secretary and was later his biographer. In 1958, Roncalli became Pope John XXIII. The question of Radini-Tedeschi's influence on John XXIII's pontificate remains to be explored.Footnote 63
