No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 June 2004
The management of property rights in land has generated paper work ever since the art of writing diffused across Western Europe. Of the documents that defined and authenticated titles to land and the income streams it generated in classical antiquity, no more than an excruciatingly minute sample survives, though we know from contemporary legal texts and notaries' formularies that the practice of maintaining archives attesting possession persisted through the Carolingian era, when the first inventories arguably describing “feudal” property rights in land and persons appear in fiscal and administrative documents. The present volume reviews the class of documents that recorded such rights in the later medieval and early modern period, which towards the end of the period were sometimes accompanied by maps showing the disposition of holdings. Despite their massive destruction during the French Revolution, the number of these documents may well approach a hundred thousand, constituting a body of source material of the highest importance for understanding how “feudalism” actually worked.
Written by specialists for specialists, the 26 papers in this volume are unlikely to find a wide audience. Nevertheless, they raise issues of utmost importance to the interpretation of European economic and agrarian history. The first question concerns when and how the fiscal obligations inventoried in Carolingian documents were transformed into quasi-private rights recorded in thirteenth-century manorial terriers? Answering this question demands a meticulous examination of the early terriers. The copious documentation from Auvergne suggests that the form of the terrier reflected growing utilization of documentary evidence in legal disputes about property rights after 1200. But since the conveyance of property and fiscal liability in the early Middle Ages also left a paper trail, the later terriers raise the problem of possible continuity hidden from view by the paucity of such documents between the tenth and twelfth centuries.
The second issue concerns the implications of the high the cost of maintaining the terriers. Although the medieval seigniory has been likened to a mafia regime founded by force, the exceptionally high cost of maintaining inventories of feudal rights suggests a legal institution governed by due process. When a terrier was dressed or renewed, tenants and freeholders had to declare their obligations and their holdings to commissioners, who in the absence of prior documentation could not have verified the declarations. Moreover, the inventory had to be approved by the tenants before it could be legally registered, without which approval lords faced heavy court costs often not worth the rights in dispute. Like cadastres and tax rolls of which they are the private analog, terriers were continually becoming outdated by the flux of transfers occasioned by death, marriage, migration, and sale. It is hardly surprising that in much of Europe this cumbersome machinery for extracting part of the agricultural surplus crumbled in the wake of plague and war. The obvious question is how it established itself in the first place. Early medieval fiscal institutions would appear to be the most plausible starting point for investigating that question.
For too long general economic historians have been content to repeat textbook stylizations of seigniorial property based on sociological interpretations dating back a hundred years and more. It is easy to forget that a society as jealous of private landed property as post-Roman Western Europe was likely to possess legal procedures for defining and protecting it. The variety of medieval and early modern claims settled on landed property—rent in kind and in cash, mortgages and annuities, taxes and other public liabilities diverted into private hands and payable in cash, kind or labor—produced the welter of legal titles that comprised “feudal” property. The study of these regulations was once the province of legal specialists known as “feudists.” If we are to recover the workings of that complex system of overlapping property rights, and thus to appreciate the true economic significance of the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century abolition of feudal property, we will have re-enter their domain and learn the meaning of the texts. This is one of those books that remind us that classification, decipherment, and testing written documents are the bedrock of scientific history.