Between 1709, the year the Kangxi emperor (1654–1722) began construction of his garden Yuanmingyuan north of the Beijing Forbidden City, and 1799 when Kangxi's grandson the Qianlong emperor (b. 1736) died, building projects of the Qing court, particularly pleasure gardens, reached an all time high. The first century-and-a-half of Qing rule was an age when Jesuit missionary-artists had the ear of the Chinese emperors: Matteo Ripa (1682–1746), Ferdinand Verbiest (1623–1688), and Guissepe Castiglione (1688–1766) were among them. It was also a time when western science and technology entered China, and the Qing empire was confident enough to accept selected aspects of the world outside China without threat or retreat. The century of only three imperial reigns, Kangxi, Qianlong, and Yongzheng (r. 1722–1735) between them, saw extensive repair and construction inside the Forbidden City. The building of Qianlong Garden from 1771 to 1776 where the emperor anticipated retirement behind his already self-contained Ningshougong (Tranquility and Longevity Palace) inside the confines of the Forbidden City, and its treasures, are the subjects of this beautifully produced book. The volume is especially timely because it was published in conjunction with an exhibition at the Peabody Museum in Salem, Massachusetts, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and a conference at the museum in Salem. It is also a precursor to the anticipated ten-year restoration project of Qianlong Garden under the sponsorship of the Palace Museum and World Monuments Fund. Prior to this publication, many who have visited the Forbidden City and even Ningshougong may not have been aware of it.
The book consists of five essays and a checklist of the 90 objects in the exhibition. Many of the objects are discussed more fully in the essays. The first essay, by Mark C. Elliot, is an elegantly written and provocative introduction to the man behind the garden. Although many, including Elliot, have written biographies of the Qianlong emperor or studied him in other contexts, the essay is fresh. In part this is because Elliot knows which details to offer the reader. It is also because of the illustrations and the way Elliot weaves them into his narrative. The three portraits of Qianlong are especially rich in the texture and patterns of his garments. One makes reference to this in its title, “Portrait of Qianlong in Ancient Costume” (pl. 1). A second, Elliot tells the reader, is worn for inspection of his troops but not in battle (Fig. 1). The three-dimensional texture of the horse trappings in this second portrait does not compare to the breath-taking fans (pl. 4) that give Elliot the opportunity to illustrate the overused phrase “splendor of imperial China”. He aptly writes that many of the images associated with the 1700s “owe greatly to the tastes and fashions of the Qianlong court”. Elliot also juxtaposes the privacy of Ningshou Palace and Qianlong's garden with the Emperor's most personal life. With the garden as backdrop, we learn that before his fortieth birthday Qianlong had buried two empresses and eighteen children, and that his decision to journey to Shandong to take his favourite wife's mind off the one-year-old son just lost to smallpox resulted in her illness and death. Elliot concludes the essay by arguing that the emperor's attention to detail in his retreat, planned for retirement during his sixtieth year on the throne, was not an audacious act of self-indulgence but rather a place for homage to the memories of his life.
The next three essays, more than fifty percent of the book, are by Nancy Berliner, Curator of Chinese Art at the Peabody Museum and organiser of the exhibition and collaboration. The first is a brief history of Chinese gardens. Like Elliot's essay, this one judiciously selects details so that the author is able to touch on Shang, Zhou, Han, Wang Xizhi, the Seven Worthies, Tao Qian, and Wang Wei, before coming to the Huizong emperor whose love of gardens as well as books can be likened to Qianlong's. Khubilai Khan's pleasure garden at Xanadu then leads to the famous Suzhou garden Shizilin, then to Wen Zhengming's writings and paintings about rocks and gardens, and then Ji Cheng's Yuanye (Garden Manual) of ca. 1631, Li Yu's Mustard Seed Garden Manual and other writings, and garden design in the famous seventeenth-century novels Jin Ping Mei and Hong Lou Meng. The essay concludes with the western-designed Yuanmingyuan in Beijing. All were gardens known to the Qianlong emperor. The survey well argues Berliner's concluding remark: “The Qing emperors had created a new imperial garden culture ”, (p.68) and positions the reader for Qianlong who would “take garden design to a still higher level”. (p.68)
Berliner's second essay surveys the gardens built by Qianlong prior to his garden behind the Ningshou Palace. Supporting the premise with which Berliner starts the chapter, that “an emperor should have extensive grounds to stroll in and lovely vistas to enjoy” before holding audience or attending to the affairs of state (p. 76), the gardens constructed by Qianlong from the 1740s through the 1780s are surveyed. The emperor began in 1742 with the garden of Jiafugong where he had spent his childhood, 44,000 square feet in area. Yuanmingyuan, the famous garden attacked by joint western forces in 1860 during Opium Wars, already existed but since Qianlong spent 150–200 days a year there, he expanded it. That work was completed in 1744. Five years later Qianlong began Changchunyuan, 400 acres in area. Berliner explains that three concepts were behind his gardens during these years: the Chinese idea of a “borrowed view”, or a scene that captured the essence of another garden or scene; newly acquired knowledge about European gardens from Jesuits at his court; and a particular fascination with the concept of trompe-l'oeil. The last feature is illustrated in some of the most powerful images in the book. Qianlong's achievement which immediately preceded the creation of his gardens at Ningshougong was a new construction at the Mountain Resort for Escaping the Heat in Chengde, a little over 100 kms northeast of Beijing, which like Ningshougong had also been started by Kangxi. All these projects were preparation for his ultimate construction design.
Like traditional Chinese gardens for centuries leading up to Qianlong's project, the two-acre garden behind the Palace of Tranquility and Longevity is as much architectural as it is landscape construction: 27 buildings form around four courtyards along a north-south line. Qianlong's goals were to simulate nature and to offer visual surprises. Berliner describes each courtyard, and illustrates her discussion with superb details of objects such as a clock, stool, rock, or plaque. Rocks are pre-eminent. Berliner rightly comments that rocks offered Qianlong a unique atmosphere in the Forbidden City, even beyond those in other imperial projects, and that one of Qianlong's purposes was to show that man is part of nature. We learn that the emperor had a private, humble chamber accessible by a completely contrasting lavishly decorated Buddhist shrine. Turning to a major theme in the garden, the “three friends” (bamboo, pine, and prunus blossom), the author writes that Qianlong used them to seek perfection in his design and to identify himself as a literatus in this creation. At the same time, Qianlong recognised the significance of Buddhism in his life in this garden.
The last section and longest section of this chapter is a discussion of objects displayed by Qianlong in his garden that illustrate illusionism. This is an opportunity for the author to write about Europeans at the Qianlong court as well as European-inspired paintings. Each object is worthy of an essay. In composite, the complex man Qianlong is revealed through a tapestry of treasures more exquisite even that one imagines for an emperor who reigned for sixty years.
Qianlong's final wishes were that the garden should remain unaltered after his death, but objects were removed in 1814, 1837, and 1897. Still, compared to the scale of destruction at most of the other imperial Qing gardens, the fact that this one was intact but in a state of disrepair at the end of the nineteenth century is noteworthy. Major renovations occurred under Empress Dowager Cixi, yet by the 1930s the gardens again was in serious need of repair. The task was undertaken only in the twenty-first century, with major support from the World Monuments Fund. This volume and the exhibition were part of the multi-faceted efforts of this organisation. Complete restoration will be the final task.
The Emperor's Private Paradise informs us that there are still unknown elements of the Forbidden City. It equally demonstrates that there are aspects of the life of the Qianlong emperor that have not been fully explicated. It demonstrates, as well, that Chinese art and architecture are what they are because decoration brings a meaning and intensity beyond the object and its patron. Through exceptional photography and choice of details the reader glimpses the private life and personal taste of an extraordinary emperor. The details link the reader to the themes of Qianlong's garden: self-reflection and self-expression. By the end of the book, the reader is convinced that Qianlong, a man worthy of the attention history has given him, created a private world for himself.
