Hampton's book aims to fill the gap left by previous policy and historical works on disability in the UK. It is premised on the assertion that books on British disability policy to 1944 and after 1979 are available; the period 1948–1979 has received less attention. The book is well written, is driven by key dates in policy history and is rooted largely in archival resources. In this sense it offers a detailed insight into policy aims, pronouncements and effectiveness. To that end, it succeeds in the goals it sets out to achieve. The book is made up of 8 chapters, with chapters 2 through to 7 providing substantive disability policy insights. What is novel about the book? The book provides a carefully crafted appraisal of key legislative, parliamentary and select committee developments. For me, it is especially useful in mapping the deliberations of the Boucher, Guillebaud and Piercy Committees – their explorations of disability and their struggle with pre-existing official constructions of disability policy. It makes clear that the Beveridgean welfare state, its association with work and the contributory principle, in turn, left many sick and disabled people out of the welfare state settlement. The book also documents the struggles between those who attempt to take disability beyond the contributory principle and impairment-specific entitlements to more inclusive pan-impairment welfare. Hampton weaves these debates into the broader economic and political backdrop from the post-WW2 nation-building of the 1940s through to the Oil crises and stagflationary era of the 1970s.
Central to this book is the assertion that many academic and official accounts of disability policy omit to fully explore the role of the non-statutory sector and the mix of welfare across the state and non-statutory binary. Hampton rightly asserts that the voluntary and charitable sectors have played a greater part in the questioning and development of policy than previous accounts suggest. He does this in a way that is largely dispassionate and again places their role in a specific historical context. Thus much early pre-WW2 charitable work was rather paternalistic and often specific to given impairments, most notably blindness and deafness. He asserts that following the mid-20th Century welfare settlement, the charitable and voluntary sectors played a key role in pushing for deinstitutionalisation, non-contributory entitlement (e.g. disabled housewives) and breaking the link between disability and household poverty. I especially liked Hampton's discussion of the role of the non-statutory sector in trying to get ministers to better join up health and social care policy, to afford greater parity of esteem between health and disability provision and to highlight the inadequacy of locally-funded disability provision in the National Assistance Act 1948 and the Chronically Sick and Disabled Person's Act of 1970. These efforts, he argues, provided a plurality of voices in policy-making and brought often high-flown ministerial pronouncements back to street-level. Hampton alights on what he sees as the pivotal work of the Disablement Income Group (DIG) in pushing for more comprehensive disability support and broader entitlement less driven by the nature of a given impairment (and cause). He explores from documentary sources the work of Du Boisson, Large and Greaves, each key members of the Group.
Assessing the development towards more inclusive, less impairment-focused disability welfare, Hampton notes that despite the rhetorical rise of these issues in the 1960’s, progress was slow. Despite the rediscovery of poverty by Townsend and others in the 1960s, archival and parliamentary records point to the resistance from health ministers to greater coverage of the disability category. Both Conservative and Labour ministers displayed such antipathy, Macmillan's opposition to greater spending and raised expectations in the mid-1950s was echoed again in the late 1960s, with Richard Crossman's fierce opposition to Alf Morris and Jack Ashley's attempt to widen provision to more disabled people. Crossman also refused to appoint a Royal Commission on Disabled People in 1969. However, symbolic strides were made as early as 1966 with discussion of a ‘civilian pension’ which would not require a contributory history. Morris, of course, persevered and the 1970 Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons acceded to statute with an emphasis on community living and a breadth of services and environmental access provision. This is notable as the words chronic sickness had previously been placed in scare quotes in most previous enquiry or committee reports. The 1970s was the decade in which cash benefits, greater non-contributory entitlement and less gendered constructions of care roles formed the basis of UK disability policy. Severe and Constant Attendance Allowance, Invalidity Benefit, Mobility Allowance and Non Contributory Invalidity Pension (NCIP) all featured in this period, with Barbara Castle, the Minister overseeing disability policy, pushing through many of these and against considerable opposition. Disability began to shake off the assumed if flawed associations with the Ministry of Health and began to shift to a welfare issue more squarely. Alf Morris, for example took up the post of Minister for Disabled People within Castle's Department for Health and Social Security.
Evaluating Hampton's book, it does achieve that which it sets out to do. I have issues with it however. In placing the disciplinary base of the book in history and policy history, it lacks the internal critique of critical policy frameworks and to maintain its disciplinary purity it rather cursorily dismisses disability studies. This feels unnecessary and rather arbitrary. For example, saying there are few other histories of disability policy between 1945 and 1979 ignores the important work of Robert Drake, Patricia Thornton and Roy Sainsbury. I also penned a book or two which include the era in question. Equally, by dismissing disability studies as too distracted by models of disability, the book fails to give credit to competing definitions of disability and some really rich work on policy narratives but rooted in more sociological ideas. In specific terms, the valorising of the Disablement Income Group (DIG) above the more radical and disability-led UPIAS, the book may raise hackles. The DIG are often seen as a paternalist extension of the broader charitable sector. To debate these, even briefly, would arguably have added to the richness of the book. My other comment is that the book has the word perceptions in the title. I don't feel it really framed how it aims to operationalise this term and how it might be different to say policy narratives? In this same way, it does not really state what disability policy is and what it is constituted by. For example, do disabled people's own voices arguably shape policy by the 1970s and substantially from the 2000s? To be fair, it does not claim to do the latter. The book will be very helpful for policy writers interested in disability; less so, as the book claims, to activists. By being so strident about disability studies, its limitations, it will not likely appeal to that growing area of study. I enjoyed reading the book however.
