Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T18:23:26.309Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Turbulence of generalised flows in two dimensions

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 December 2019

Simon Thalabard*
Affiliation:
Instituto Nacional de Matemática Pura e Aplicada, IMPA, 22460-320Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Jérémie Bec
Affiliation:
MINES ParisTech, PSL Research University, CNRS, CEMEF, 06904Sophia-Antipolis CEDEX, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: simon.thalabard@ens-lyon.org

Abstract

This paper discusses the generalised least-action principle and the associated concept of generalised flow introduced by Brenier (J. Am. Math. Soc., vol. 2, 1989, pp. 225–255), from the perspective of turbulence modelling. In essence, Brenier’s generalised least-action principle is a probabilistic generalisation of Arnold’s geometric interpretation of ideal fluid mechanics, whereby strong solutions to the Euler equations are deduced from minimising an action over Lagrangian maps. While Arnold’s framework relies on the deterministic concept of Lagrangian flow, Brenier’s least-action principle describes solutions to the Euler equations in terms of non-deterministic generalised flows, namely probability measures over sets of Lagrangian trajectories. In concept, generalised flows seem naturally fit to describe turbulent Lagrangian trajectories in terms of stochastic processes, an approach that originates from Richardson’s seminal work on turbulent dispersion. Still, Brenier’s generalised least-action principle has so far hardly found any practical application in the realm of fluid mechanics, let alone for turbulence modelling. The purpose of the present paper is to provide a hydrodynamical perspective on Brenier’s principle, and to assess its skills at coarse graining the Lagrangian motion of fluid particles, in order to reconstruct the space–time dynamics of the underlying Eulerian velocity fields. In practice, we rely on a statistical-mechanics interpretation of the concept of generalised flows, whereby the latter become akin to statistical ensembles of suitably defined ‘permutation flows’. We then employ Monte Carlo techniques to numerically solve the generalised least-action principle, and analyse the Eulerian and Lagrangian statistical features of the associated generalised flows. For simplicity, we restrict ourselves to two dimensions of space and consider situations of increasing complexity, ranging from solid rotation and cellular flows to freely decaying two-dimensional turbulence. Our analysis highlights a major caveat of the generalised variational principle. When used over long time lags, e.g. longer than a well-defined hydrodynamic turnover time, it generates artificial generalised flows, with non-physical statistical features. We argue that this limitation is not specifically inherent to Brenier’s formulation, but rather to the variational framework being formulated as a two-end boundary-value problem. When appropriately used over sufficiently short times, the generalised least-action principle is however relevant, and generalised flows can be explicitly constructed, that represent a space–time coarse graining of the underlying dynamics. We show numerical evidence that Brenier’s principle may then even accommodate irreversible Eulerian behaviours. This suggests that, if carefully used, generalised variational formulations could provide new tools to coarse grain genuine multi-scale hydrodynamics.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.A solid-rotating flow with pulse $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}$ only solves the variational principle (2.2) up to final times $t_{f} (in green), when the final map has rotated less than half a turn (a). For $t_{f}>t_{\star }$ (in red), the minimising vorticity $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}_{\star }$ is lower and may even be of opposite sign. This can be seen in (b), which shows the action-minimising vorticity $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FA}_{\star }$ as a function of the final time $t_{f}$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Illustration of a realisation of two-dimensional permutation flow. Colours code the initial positions.

Figure 2

Figure 3.The solid-rotation example, this time interpreted as an ensemble of permutation flows on a coarse $(2\times 2)$-box: nothing but a sliding puzzle. The middle inset provides the energy cost of the representative elementary permutations: permutation flows are discrete sequences of $N_{t}$ such elementary permutations, and the minimising discrete generalised flow is defined as the uniform probability measure over the set of permutation flows with minimal energy cost. Panels (a,b) represent the minimal permutation flows, when the final permutation is either a quarter of a full turn (a) or half of a full turn (b). The physical trajectory is uniquely defined in the first case as an anti-clockwise rotation. In the second case, the generalised flow is an average over both clockwise and anti-clockwise half-turn rotations. Panels (c,d) represent the time evolution of Lagrangian transition probabilities for the corresponding generalised flow, obtained in the limit $N_{t}\rightarrow \infty$ (see text for details).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Reconstruction of the Beltrami dynamics as a function of time and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FD}$ for $t_{f}=0.75. The colour code stands for the initial $y$ position of fluid particles.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Convergence of the action for the case $t_{f}. Panel (a) shows convergence at zero temperature of the time-averaged kinetic energy – given by the action in (3.4) – towards the optimal Beltrami action. Panel (b) shows the time dependence of the generalised flow energy for inverse temperatures $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FD}=0.01$, $0.03$, $0.1$, $0.3$, $1$ and $3$ (from top to bottom).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Kinetic energy spectra for (a) $t_{f} and various $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FD}$ (same values as figure 5a) and (b) for $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FD}=1$ fixed and various $t_{f}$ ranging from $0.75$ up to $2$ every $0.125$. The curves corresponding to $t_{f} are shown in green, the others in red.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Typical permutation flow for the generalised solution with $t_{f}=2t_{\star }$. We again show here, as a coloured background, the initial $y$ label as a function of time. (b) Time evolution of the kinetic energy. It is no longer conserved, and exhibits significant variations at the time boundaries.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a) Average Lagrangian displacement for both $t_{f} (green) $t_{f}>t_{\star }$ (red). (b,c) Realisations of the Lagrangian trajectories, again for time lags $t_{f}$ below (b) and above (c) the critical time $t_{\star }$. The colour scale there codes the initial vertical positions of the trajectory.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Snapshot of the vorticity field at time $t=t_{f}/2$. Positive values are shown in blue and negative ones in yellow. Panel (a) is the original vorticity field obtained from the direct numerical simulation with $256^{2}$ collocation points. Panel (b) is a fluctuating realisation of the reconstructed vorticity on a $64^{2}$ coarse graining with a finite temperature $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FD}^{-1}=1$. Panel (c) is the generalised flow approximation obtained by averaging over the Gibbs ensemble.

Figure 9

Figure 10.(a) Energy and enstrophy as functions of time both for the actual field (dashed lines) and the reconstructed one (thin solid lines). Here, $Z(t)$ is averaged over the reconstructed time intervals $[n\,t_{f},(n+1)\,t_{f}]$, while $E(t)$ is not, whence the stronger fluctuations for the second. Time is here in units of $Z^{-1/2}(0)$. (b) Kinetic energy spectra of both the original velocity field (solid lines) and of the reconstructed one (dashed lines with symbols) at different times, as labelled.